Toyota Threatened in U.S. by Camry Converging Competition: Cars
Toyota Motor Corp. was already counting on the revamped Camry to spark a U.S. sales rally. The carmaker’s flagship model is now under additional pressure as a stronger currency and Thailand’s floods cut into profit.
The company reduced its earnings forecast last week by more than 50 percent for the year ending in March, blaming a slump in production after Thailand’s worst floods in almost 70 years. The 2012 Camry was released in October with a goal of boosting sales hurt by Japan’s earthquake and tsunami and retaining its title as the top-selling U.S. passenger car.
“There’s a lot of pressure on that car,” said Maryann Keller, an auto analyst and president at Maryann Keller & Associates. “It’s been reviewed as being competitive within the midsize sedan segment, but not that much better or worse than competitors. Right now, the perceived design leader is Hyundai’s Sonata, and Kia’s Optima is also doing well.”
While Toyota is set to lose its ranking as the world’s largest automaker this year to General Motors Co., the Toyota City, Japan-based company has said it’s determined to keep Camry the best-selling car in the U.S., a spot held for 13 of the past 14 years. Rebounding from parts shortages and assembly disruptions may prove easier than overcoming rivals.
“Camry bears the lion’s share of whether they succeed in recovering both market share and profitability” in the U.S., said Larry Dominique, executive vice president of TrueCar.com and former head of Nissan Motor Co.’s North American product planning. “The reality is the best way to gain market share and profitability is new product, and Camry is their biggest.”
Toyota’s American depositary receipts, representing two ordinary shares, fell 2.5 percent to $66.49 at the close in New York.
The success of Hyundai Motor Co.’s Sonata and Kia Motors Corp. (000270)’s Optima as well as Ford Motor Co. (F)’s Fusion, means Toyota no longer has the ability to price Camry above segment competitors, Keller said.
“The problem isn’t so much how many units of Camry they sell, but the margin of each vehicle,” she said. “They don’t have the kind of pricing power they once enjoyed.”
U.S. drivers bought 23,440 Camrys in November, 15,668 Sonatas and 9,533 Optimas. While Camry remains the best-selling car in 2011, even after production delays helped cut sales 7.3 percent so far this year, Sonata volume is up 15 percent and Optima deliveries more than tripled from last year.
Toyota doesn’t disclose its profit for the Camry. Neither Keller nor Efraim Levy, a New York-based equity analyst for S&P Capital IQ, who rates Toyota’s American depositary receipts “hold,” had estimates for how much Toyota earns from the car.
“The success of the Camry is very important to Toyota,” Levy said. “It’s similar to Ford’s F-150 pickup, since in each case it’s the single biggest source of sales volume.”
Toyota has set a goal of selling at least 360,000 Camrys in the U.S. in 2012. The company has sold 275,004 in the first 11 months of 2011, leading Nissan’s Altima’s 243,005, which has surpassed Honda Motor Co.’s Accord, at 217,958, for the No. 2 selling car.
The best-selling midsize sedans of U.S. automakers are Ford’s Fusion at 226,445 and GM’s Chevrolet Chevrolet Malibu at 191,774. GM’s top-selling car is the Cruze compact at 215,057.
“We have been increasing the volume of shipments to our dealers since we began production in September,” Steve Curtis, a spokesman for the company’s U.S. sales unit. “We’ll get as many to customers as possible.”
After a quake- and tsunami-related production slowdown in North America that lasted more than five months, Toyota has said it’s now working to build up inventory of Camry and other models as quickly as possible.
“We are running full production on Camry lines as we continue to replenish inventory and meet market demand,” said Mike Goss, a spokesman for the company’s manufacturing unit, without elaborating.
Toyota’s best year for Camry was 473,108 sold in 2007. Between its Kentucky plant and the Subaru factory, the company has said it can produce about 500,000 of the cars.
The automaker estimates that more than 6.8 million Camry models are on the road in the U.S., the largest owner base of any midsize sedan.
Toyota touts the latest version of Camry as more fuel- efficient than the previous version, with a better ride and handling. The car has added safety features and last week received a top score in federal crash tests.
The new Camry’s exterior has squared off corners compared with the earlier version’s rounder edges. The redesigned model has a roomier rear seat and bigger trunk.
It’s essential for the new car to be seen by consumers as safe and high-quality, following the company’s recalls of Camry and other models for flaws linked to unintended acceleration, said Eric Noble, president of the Car Lab, an industry consultant in Orange, California.
“This model will receive extra scrutiny,” Noble said. “To much of America, Toyota is the Camry. What Toyota needs is at least an acceptable launch out of this car as a signal to the North American public that ‘hey, we’re all right again.’”
Since sales began in October, most buyers of the new model are previous owners of Camrys and other Toyota models, Jim Lentz, president of Toyota’s U.S. sales unit, said in an interview last month.
Sales of Camry should rebound to about 30,000 units a month “sometime in February or March,” Lentz said. The car typically sold at that level or higher before the recalls and this year’s production slowdown.
Camry sales were shrinking prior to this year’s natural disasters as Hyundai (005380), Kia, Ford and GM raised competition with features matching or topping those of Camry. The latest Camry has an enlarged cabin and moves ahead of Accord, Sonata, Optima, Altima, Fusion and the Chevy Malibu with the highest fuel- economy rating among four-cylinder midsize sedans, at 25 miles per gallon of gasoline in city driving, 35 mpg highway.
The 2012 Camry Hybrid, whose 41 mpg average tops Hyundai’s Sonata Hybrid at 37 mpg and the Fusion Hybrid at 39, is the highest among all midsize sedans, according to U.S. Environmental Protection Agency data.
The price of a base model 4-cylinder engine 2012 Camry LE with an automatic transmission was trimmed about $200 to $22,500. That compares with $23,095 for a Sonata GLS model and $21,750 for an Optima LX.
Component shortages caused by Thailand’s floods disrupted production for Japanese automakers worldwide, compounding the challenge from the record quake and the yen’s surge. Toyota said the Thai floods will cut earnings by 120 billion yen ($1.55 billion).
Toyota’s net income will fall 56 percent to 180 billion yen in the 12 months ending March 31, the carmaker said in a statement. That’s less than half the profit projected by the average of 21 analyst estimates compiled by Bloomberg.
Disruptions from the Thai floods will probably result in 260,000 vehicles in lost production, or 3.4 percent of the previous annual target, according to Toyota.
Toyota probably lost more output than any other carmaker because of the floods, said Masatoshi Nishimoto, a Tokyo-based senior manager at research firm IHS Automotive.
Toyota also revised its outlook for the yen against the dollar to 78 from 80, and to 109 from 116 versus the euro, meaning the company expects the stronger domestic currency to reduce operating income by 160 billion yen, it said. The yen, the best-performing major currency this year, forced the company to raise prices, Toyota said.
Toyota delayed the new projections by a month because of the floods. Honda, which also pushed back its forecasts because of Thailand, plans to disclose them by the end of January, Chief Financial Officer Fumihiko Ike said last week.
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Jamie Butters at firstname.lastname@example.org