Stradivarius at $15.9 Million Means Investors Bet on Violins
The first time Satu Vanska held the Australian Chamber Orchestra’s $1.8 million Stradivarius and played the opening notes of Jean Sibelius’s violin concerto, she knew she wanted it.
“The thought that it could be yours, it makes you a little nervous -- and very happy,” Vanska, 32, assistant leader of the Sydney-based orchestra, said in a telephone interview.
The violin, a composite of two made by Antonio Stradivari in 1728 and 1729, is the first asset of a new fund set up by the orchestra that gives investors the chance to speculate on the value of rare musical instruments. Auction house Tarisio sold a 1721 Stradivarius called the Lady Blunt on Monday for a record 9.8 million pounds ($15.9 million), 116 times the 84,000 pounds it fetched at Sotheby’s in 1971.
“Violins appear to be quite a good investment,” said Kathryn Graddy, a professor of economics at Brandeis University in Waltham, Massachusetts. “The returns are comparable to art, lower than stock returns but slightly higher on average than bonds. They are in a sense a safe haven because the returns are steady and not as volatile as art.”
Violins made by Stradivari and his contemporary Giuseppe ‘del Gesu’ Guarneri averaged gains of 6.9 percent a year between 1980 and 2006, compared with an average advance of more than 9 percent in the S&P 500 Index (SPX) and about 6.6 percent from U.S. treasuries, Graddy wrote in a study published in 2008.
Russell Crowe’s Teacher
The new fund is the brainchild of Richard Tognetti, the orchestra’s artistic director, who taught actor Russell Crowe to play the violin for the film “Master and Commander.” He wanted to find a way to make some of the world’s best instruments available to the orchestra, which gets most of its funding from ticket sales and sponsorship.
The minimum investment is A$50,000 ($53,000) and the fund will terminate in 2021, when the instruments will be sold and the money disbursed unless investors vote to extend it, the orchestra’s website says.
“None of the musicians can afford to buy any of these fine instruments,” Tognetti, 45, said in a telephone interview. “Even way below a Stradivarius, you’re in an amount of money that is beyond what we earn.”
Tognetti plays a 1743 ‘del Gesu’ called the Carrodus, valued at $10.5 million, that was bought by an anonymous benefactor for $6.6 million in 2006, according to the website.
The orchestra’s new Stradivarius has “quite a powerful sound that carries all the way to the end of the concert hall,” Vanska said. “At the same time, it’s very sweet and brilliant, and that’s a very nice combination.”
Decreasing supply and increasing demand from markets such as Russia may accelerate the gains for fine violins, many of which are almost 300 years old, said Steven Smith, a director at London-based dealer J & A Beare Ltd., which sold the Stradivarius to the orchestra.
“Prices are going up more steeply than they were, and I would expect that that’s very likely to continue,” Smith said in a telephone interview. “The supply and demand situation is getting much, much tougher.”
Stradivari and Guaneri worked in the northern Italian city of Cremona during the 17th and 18th centuries. About 650 Stradivari violins and 135 del Gesu violins survive, according to the Chicago-based Stradivari Society. That makes them increasingly valuable and relatively illiquid, Graddy said.
“Compared to real estate and even art, the market for high-end violins is ‘thin’ and many violins are sold through dealers rather than auctions,” she wrote in the 2008 report.
The Lady Blunt, auctioned on Monday, was one of 19 Stradivarius instruments owned by the Tokyo-based Nippon Music Foundation. The proceeds of the sale will go to the organization’s parent, the Nippon Foundation, for its Northeastern Japan Earthquake and Tsunami Relief Fund.
The Australian Chamber Orchestra, which tours Australia and performs at international venues, has raised A$1.6 million so far for its fund and aims to reach as much as A$10 million to buy instruments, said Jessica Block, the ensemble’s deputy general manager. Investors will be able to sell units to the orchestra every three years, starting in July 2014. They can sell to other investors approved by the fund’s trustees at any time. There are no fees.
“There’s no point denying that there is a philanthropic element to this,” said Block, a trustee of the fund. “We need people to hold on to their units as long as possible. We needed to make it attractive enough so that people wouldn’t think that it was a donation dressed up as an investment.”
Block declined to say how many investors the fund has.
Guido Belgiorno-Nettis, chairman of the orchestra’s board and joint managing director of Sydney-based Transfield Holdings Ltd., helped design the fund and invested A$200,000 with his wife Michelle.
“It’s a good place to park some cash,” Belgiorno-Nettis said in a telephone interview. “The instruments are rare and therefore it’s very unlikely you’re going to lose your money.”
To contact the reporters on this story: Simeon Bennett in Singapore at email@example.com