Desperate Americans Buy Kidneys From Peru Poor in Fatal Trade
Luis Picado’s mother remembers the day her son thought he had won the lottery. He came home to their tin-roofed cinder-block house in a Managua, Nicaragua, slum and said he’d found a way to escape poverty and start a new life in the United States.
An American man had promised to give Picado, a 23-year-old high school dropout who worked as a construction laborer, a job and an apartment in New York if he’d donate one of his kidneys. He jumped at the deal, his mother says.
Three weeks later, in May 2009, Picado came out of surgery at Managua’s Military Hospital, bleeding internally from the artery doctors had severed to remove his kidney, according to medical records. His mother, Elizabeth Tercero, got on her knees next to her son’s bed in the recovery room and prayed, Bloomberg Markets magazine reports in its June issue.
“I told my boy not to worry, that I would take care of him,” Tercero, 49, says. “But it was too late.” Picado bled to death as doctors tried to save him, according to a coroner’s report. “He was always chasing the American dream, and finally, it cost him his life,” she says.
Matthew Ryan, the American man, suffered a similar fate. Ryan, a 68-year-old retired bus company supervisor in New York, died two months after receiving Picado’s kidney in the same hospital.
Nicaraguan postmortem reports cited the transplant as a cause of death for both men. Prosecutors in Managua are now investigating whether anyone broke a Nicaraguan law that prohibits paying a donor for an organ.
The two men were participants in a growing and illicit market for organ transplants that spans the globe. Every year, about 5,000 gravely ill people from countries including the U.S., Israel and Saudi Arabia pay others to donate an organ, says Francis Delmonico, a Harvard Medical School professor and surgeon. The practice is illegal in every country except Iran, Delmonico says.
Affluent, often desperately ill patients travel to countries such as Egypt, Peru and the Philippines, where poor people sell them their organs. In Latin America, the transplants are usually arranged by unlicensed brokers. They’re performed -- for fees -- by accredited surgeons, some of whom have trained at the world’s leading medical schools.
The global demand for organs far exceeds the available supply. In the U.S., 110,693 people are on waiting lists for organs, and fewer than 15,000 donors are found annually.
Americans who go abroad for illicit transplants can contract infections or HIV from unhealthy donors, posing a public health threat when they return, Delmonico says.
‘Exploit the Patient’
“With all the anxiety in getting a transplant, they exploit the patient,” says Delmonico, who is president-elect of the Montreal-based Transplantation Society, which lobbies governments to crack down on trafficking. “It’s big money.”
The illegal organ trade is the ugly side of the otherwise legal medical tourism industry, in which people travel to other countries for cut-rate hip replacements, tummy tucks and gastric bypasses. The legitimate medical procedures generated about $100 billion in revenue in 2010, according to a report by Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Ltd.
For decades, wealthy Brazilians, Mexicans and Saudis have gone to U.S. and European hospitals for medical care they couldn’t get at home. In the past decade, that pattern has changed. Hospitals from Puerto Vallarta, Mexico, to Medellin, Colombia, now lure middle-class Americans with promises of high- quality care at a fraction of what it would cost them at home.
Preying on the Poor
In the illegal organ trade, brokers scour the world’s slums, preying on the poor with promises of easy money and little risk in exchange for a kidney. Inside hospitals, people are injured or killed by botched surgery as doctors place money above ethics, criminal investigators say.
In Colombia, 321 foreigners got transplants from 2005 to 2010, according to the country’s National Health Institute. Juan Lopez, a doctor who oversees Colombia’s organ transplant system as director of the NHI, says many of these surgeries are driven by profit for hospitals, doctors and brokers.
“I don’t want my country to be a Mecca for transplant tourism,” Lopez says. He’s gone to court to try to stop 23 organ transplants for foreigners since 2010, he says.
In Peru, Rafael Peraldo, a taxi driver who’s under investigation for being an organ broker, has plied Lima’s dusty slums since at least 2005, according to five people who say in interviews that they sold kidneys to him.
Peraldo paid as little as $5,000, the five people say.
Patients who bought these organs paid as much as $150,000, prosecutors have found.
The Peruvian National Prosecutor’s Office is investigating 61 transplants in seven of Lima’s top hospitals since 2004, documents in the case show. Peraldo is one of 150 brokers, doctors, nurses and others under investigation, says Jesus Asencios, the prosecutor leading the probe.
Peraldo says in a telephone interview that he’s done nothing wrong; he says he won’t say more until the investigation is completed.
Because people with kidney failure are always in poor health, a transplant is never a guaranteed cure. Still, legal transplants have a high probability of success. More than 75 percent of the recipients of kidney transplants in the U.S. live for more than 10 years, according to the National Institutes of Health.
Donors usually do fine; they can live a normal life span with just one of their two kidneys. In the illicit trade, by contrast, perils abound for all participants.
Organs removed by surgeons in Peru from 2004 to 2010 went to ill men and women from the U.S., Chile, Mexico, Spain and Venezuela, according to hospital records and prosecutors’ interviews with donors and doctors.
One of those patients was Oscar Soberon, the wealthy founder of a Mexico City computer systems company. After about a year of enduring dialysis sessions to survive kidney failure, Soberon negotiated a transplant at a Lima hospital with Peruvian doctor Christian Miranda, for $125,000, Soberon told prosecutors before he died.
On Nov. 1, 2009, doctors transplanted a kidney from a baker into Soberon. Eleven weeks after surgery, Soberon was dead, his body ravaged by infection, his medical records show.
The kidney is a fist-sized organ that continuously filters blood to clear waste from the body. Toxins are flushed into the bladder, which removes them. When a kidney fails, doctors use a machine system called dialysis to circulate and clean blood. A patient with kidney failure will die quickly without dialysis or a transplant.
In legal transplants, a kidney patient typically turns to relatives willing to donate one of their kidneys, or goes onto a waiting list if no one volunteers. A hospital screens potential donors, reviewing their health records, blood type and body tissue to ensure they’re medically compatible.
The illicit organ trade is dangerous for the donor and patient because criminals take shortcuts, such as accepting organs from people who are sick and wouldn’t be approved by hospitals in the U.S., says Gabriel Danovitch, medical director of the kidney and pancreas transplant program at the University of California, Los Angeles.
“It’s a filthy business in the same subcategory as the sex trade and child pornography,” Danovitch says. “That is why it has to be stopped.”
How it Started
It’s hard to stop critically ill people who are in a race against death from seeking solutions outside the official transplant system, especially if they have the money and connections to do something about it.
Ryan, the retired New York bus line supervisor, used his son-in-law in Managua to set up a deal for a kidney, says Picado’s boss, who overheard the offer. The chain of events that brought Ryan together with the 23-year-old Picado began in 2009.
Ryan, known by relatives as a quiet, levelheaded man who rarely got angry, had been living a grueling existence since his kidneys failed in 2007. He lived in Cedarhurst, New York, near John F. Kennedy International Airport, with his wife, Lily Molina, an immigrant from Nicaragua, and underwent four-hour dialysis sessions three times a week.
Welts covered his arms, where medical workers inserted tubes into his veins. Like many kidney patients, Ryan was seeking a transplant.
“He was on a waiting list but was suffering a lot,” says Molina, 53, who first met Ryan when she worked at a Wendy’s (WEN) restaurant in 2001. They married in 2005.
In March 2009, Ryan traveled to Nicaragua for vacation. He stayed with his stepdaughter, Julissa Molina, and her husband, Elvis Hernandez, in their two-bedroom home near Managua’s Augusto C. Sandino International Airport.
The house was being remodeled by Picado and his boss, Erick Bermudez, who remembers how the subject of transplants came up.
“Elvis said Ryan’s kidneys were bad and he needed a transplant,” says Bermudez, sitting in the windowless, dirt- floored room he rents in Managua.
Two months later, in May 2009, Ryan offered Picado a deal, says Bermudez. He says he heard the entire conversation as he stood a few feet away. Using his stepson as an interpreter, Ryan said he would arrange for a coyote, or human smuggler, to transport Picado illegally to New York if he donated a kidney, Bermudez says.
Picado went over the details of the offer several times, he says.
“Luis said they would give him a $5,000 gift for his kidney,” Bermudez says. “They told him everything he wanted to hear.”
For years, Picado, who had a round face and thick, curly black hair, had talked about going to the U.S. to escape the poverty that plagued just about everyone he knew, says his mother, Elizabeth Tercero.
“Luis said the gringo would take him to New York and he’d never have to worry about anything else,” Tercero says. “I begged him not to do it. It could be dangerous. But he wouldn’t listen.”
‘Not a Cent’
Hernandez says there wasn’t any promise of compensation for Picado.
“Luis did it altruistically,” he says. “Maybe Matthew said he would try to help him out, but there was no offer of any money.”
Ryan’s widow, Lily Molina, says her husband told her Picado had donated voluntarily and he never gave him any cash.
“Not a cent,” Molina says.
While in Managua, Ryan had dialysis sessions at Vivian Pellas Metropolitan Hospital, under the care of kidney disease specialist Jose Tenorio. A few days after he started dialysis, in early March 2009, Ryan asked the doctor for a transplant and introduced two men who said they were willing to donate a kidney, according to Tenorio’s July 29, 2009, statement to investigators.
Doctor Said No
Tenorio, who trained in nephrology at Lapeyronie Hospital in Montpellier, France, told Ryan he recommended against a transplant because of his age, according to his statement to police. Ryan asked for a second opinion, so Tenorio asked fellow nephrologist Orlando Granera, who was educated at National Autonomous University of Mexico, to look at Ryan.
Specialists like Tenorio and Granera earn about $500 a month at a public hospital in Nicaragua. Ryan had agreed to pay $20,000 in fees to the medical team for the transplant, Hernandez says. The two doctors declined to say how much they stood to earn. Both told police they weren’t paid anything after Ryan died.
Granera, 37, arranged to do the transplant at Military Hospital, which consists of a pair of long, mildew-stained buildings with cracked windows on a Managua hillside. Granera told police he asked Picado to sign a notarized statement saying he was volunteering his kidney at no cost.
“I clarify that I am doing it for humanity and without any profit,” the May 23, 2009, statement says.
Granera, in an interview at his office at Metropolitan Hospital, says he wouldn’t have taken the case had he known Picado was offered money.
“They said it was strictly based on their friendship,” he says. Tenorio says he hasn’t done anything wrong and has spent his career following the highest ethical standards. “I don’t know anything about any compensation,” he says.
Luis Callejas, a Nicaraguan congressman and a surgeon trained at Tulane University in New Orleans, doesn’t believe Picado agreed to donate an organ for free.
“An American doesn’t meet a stranger in Nicaragua and get an organ just because they like each other,” says Callejas, who supports a proposal to regulate transplants.
The Picado case led the Nicaraguan Ministry of Health to start writing tougher rules on transplants, and Congress will decide whether to approve them. It’s illegal in Nicaragua to sell an organ, but the law is vague and bans transplants only if there’s no proof of the donor’s consent, says Norwin Solano, a human rights lawyer in Managua.
Since Nicaragua permits organ transplants for foreigners, Picado and Ryan were wheeled openly into operating room J-5 at the end of a red-tiled corridor in the Military Hospital on May 30, 2009. Granera, who isn’t a surgeon, chose Javier Melendez -- a surgeon who had done 10 previous kidney transplants and had trained in urology at National Autonomous University -- to remove Picado’s kidney.
Melendez, 37, told police he severed the left renal artery, which leads from the kidney to the heart, and stitched it shut with silk sutures. Then he severed the ureter, which connects the kidney to the bladder, and removed the organ, the doctor told police on July 24, 2009.
Melendez handed the kidney to Jose Borgen, a urologist and surgeon who had also studied at National Autonomous University. Borgen later told police he transplanted the kidney into Ryan without complications.
Less than an hour after the surgery, Picado’s blood pressure plummeted and he stopped breathing, a coroner’s report says. Blood surged from the severed artery, and doctors tried to rescue him. By the time Picado died, he’d lost 80 percent of his blood, hospital records show.
Within five days, Ryan’s body began to reject Picado’s kidney, his immune system attacking it as if it were a virus. Surgeons removed it. Ryan died on Aug. 8, 2009.
Nicaragua’s health ministry found in February 2010 that the hospital had violated regulations by failing to examine Picado properly before surgery. The ministry is investigating whether the doctors were qualified.
Solano, the Nicaraguan human rights lawyer, says he hopes this case forces the nation to toughen its laws.
“Our country may be an organ shop for the rich,” he says. “This organ-trafficking business is a sleeping giant that is being awoken.”
In Peru, Latin America’s fifth-most-populous country, prosecutors are conducting a much more extensive investigation. They’re looking at 61 cases of suspicious transplants and are targeting the role of brokers.
It’s in the slums of Lima, the capital, where brokers have found most of their recruits. Brokers enlist people like Jose Levano, an unemployed medical laboratory technician, and his wife, Vilma Bramon. They live with one of their four children and Levano’s elderly mother in a derelict home in Ancon, a dusty coastal town on the northern edge of Lima. They have no running water.
In 2005, Levano, 45, placed an ad in a local newspaper offering to sell a kidney. Peraldo, the taxi driver, responded. Peraldo paid Levano $5,000, and surgeons at Clinica Internacional in Lima completed the transplant without any complications on Aug. 20, 2005, Levano says.
By late 2007, the couple was broke, after having cared for an ailing relative. Levano called Peraldo, saying his wife would sell a kidney so the family could get some money. Peraldo took Bramon, a housewife, to Laboratorio Clinico LAD SrL, a medical testing laboratory in Lima that’s co-owned by Peraldo’s friend Victor Salas, a pathologist, Bramon says.
A few days later, Peraldo brought Bramon to Christian Miranda, a nephrologist at Clinica El Golf hospital in Lima’s San Isidro neighborhood, where mansions and luxury apartments line the streets.
“He told me I was a perfect candidate to be a donor and nothing would happen to me,” Bramon says.
In early January 2008, Peraldo contacted Bramon with the news that he’d found a patient who needed her kidney, she says. On Jan. 20, Miranda had Bramon admitted to San Felipe Hospital, her medical records show. As she settled into a private room, Peraldo gave her $6,000 in cash, Bramon says.
The next day, on Jan. 21, 2008, Jose Arias, a transplant surgeon on the hospital’s staff, removed her kidney. The organ was transplanted into a Spanish man, hospital records from the criminal investigation say.
Immediately after her surgery, Bramon was moved to an intensive care bed, suffering from high fever, nausea and a urinary tract blockage, she says.
“I thought I was going to die,” she says.
Bramon says she has been in pain ever since. At night, she can’t lie on her left side because it hurts too much. She’s visited four different doctors, had six abdominal scans and taken five different painkillers. She spent all the cash she got for her kidney on medication and doctors.
In January this year, Bramon allowed a reporter to accompany her on a visit to Wilfredo Luna, a cardiovascular surgeon in Lima. She told the doctor that her pain was overwhelming. Luna, 50, examined images of Bramon’s abdomen and shook his head. The malady was caused by a poorly made incision during the transplant, which slashed nerves, he said.
“It cannot be reversed,” he told her.
Arias says in his office at San Felipe that he’s been paid $4,000 to $5,000 for each of the four transplants he’s done. All of his donors, as required by law, said they hadn’t accepted money for their organ, he says.
‘What Can I Do?’
“If these people are up to something but have all the correct papers, what can I do?” Arias says. Bramon says she signed a sworn statement saying she wasn’t compensated for her kidney because Peraldo said that was the only way she’d get paid.
Miranda, the nephrologist, told investigators he didn’t know anything about organ trafficking in Peru.
“I don’t belong to or know of any illicit organization,” Miranda said in a Jan. 14, 2010, statement to police. He didn’t return telephone and written requests for comment.
Peruvian prosecutors started their criminal investigation of Peraldo and his associates in October 2009. Peraldo said he was a taxi driver who knew nothing about donors paying for kidneys. Salas, who says he screens patients for transplants, told investigators he didn’t know anything about organ trafficking. He didn’t respond to requests seeking comment.
Within a year after harvesting Bramon’s kidney, Peraldo and Miranda found someone else who was willing to sell an organ. In late 2008, a friend who had sold a kidney sent Eduardo Yataco, a construction laborer in Lima, to Peraldo.
“He promised about $12,000,” Yataco, 33, says. “He said it was totally safe.”
In February 2009, when Peraldo said it was time to donate his kidney, Yataco says he told his wife he was going to Trujillo, in northwestern Peru, on a construction job.
“I was embarrassed that I was doing this, so I lied,” says Yataco, a thin man with black hair and deep-set brown eyes. Yataco went to Lima’s Clinica Vesalio.
Arias, Bramon’s surgeon, cut out Yataco’s left kidney on Feb. 12, 2009, hospital records show. The recipient of Yataco’s organ was a Lima woman, according to hospital records cited by police. Yataco, who says he signed a statement at Peraldo’s request before the procedure saying he wasn’t being compensated, says Peraldo paid him about $12,000.
‘She Was Horrified’
The for-pay organ trade cost Yataco his marriage and his health.
“When my wife saw this, she was horrified,” says Yataco, pulling up his work shirt to show a 4-inch (10-centimeter) scar where doctors removed a kidney. “She asked me what would have happened if I had died on the operating table, and she was right. My wife left me because of this.”
Yataco looks pale, and his eyes have a yellowish tint. He says he’s always tired and his side is in constant pain.
“Physically and emotionally, I am not the same man,” he says, shaking his head. “I’m alone, broke and humiliated.”
Seven months later, Miranda was contacted by a Mexican man who wanted to buy a kidney, according to police findings. Oscar Soberon, founder of Mexico City-based computer systems company S&C Constructores de Sistemas, had been suffering from kidney failure since December 2008.
He’d heard about the organ ring in Peru from a barber at his country club in Mexico City, his son, Oscar Soberon Jr., says.
In late September 2009, the senior Soberon called Miranda in Lima, and the doctor promised him a transplant with a donated kidney for $125,000, Soberon told police after the transplant.
‘Cover the Costs’
“He told me that would cover all the costs for me and the person who donated the kidney,” Soberon said.
Peraldo called Santiago Montero, a 34-year-old baker in Lima, according to a statement Montero gave police. When Montero was admitted to Santa Lucia hospital in Lima on Oct. 31, 2009, doctors listed kidney stones as the reason for removing his kidney, hospital records show.
“The idea was to hide what was happening,” Montero later told police as they were investigating the case. “The truth is, my kidney was never sick.”
Surgeons removed Montero’s left kidney on Nov. 1, 2009, and transplanted it into Soberon. As Montero recovered from the surgery, Peraldo stopped by.
“He gave me $7,000 in U.S. dollars,” Montero told investigators.
‘It’s All About Money’
Six weeks after the surgery, Soberon, 56, began complaining of severe pain. He went to San Felipe, the same Lima hospital where surgeons had removed Bramon’s kidney, according to police interviews.
Soberon’s body rejected the transplanted kidney, his medical records show. On Dec. 13, doctors removed it. Within 10 days, Soberon had developed a fever and pneumonia, a Dec. 23, 2009, investigation report shows. He died on Jan. 14, 2010, in Mexico City, and his body was cremated, his death certificate says.
“I don’t think this business has anything to do with medicine,” Oscar Soberon Jr. says. “It’s all about money.”
Fanny Fregueiros, an attorney for the Peruvian Health Ministry, says Soberon died because the transplant was poorly done.
“I investigated this thoroughly, and it’s clear there was criminal negligence,” she says. On Jan. 26, 2010, Fregueiros recommended the National Prosecutor’s Office charge those responsible with criminal organ trafficking. As of May 11, no one had been charged.
Miranda and Peraldo told investigators that they hadn’t paid Montero for a kidney.
“It’s false that I said there was a donor or spoke of economic figures,” Miranda told police.
These kinds of conflicting statements are typical of the organ transplant trade, making it hard to curb illegal behavior, Harvard’s Delmonico says. He’s spent the past six years traveling internationally to urge doctors and governments to stop organ trafficking.
“The problem is that you have so many people who are desperate for a transplant and willing to pay for one and so many poor people who need the money and can be exploited,” he says.
Back in Managua, Elizabeth Tercero weeps. In March this year, Tercero visited the prosecutor investigating her son’s death, and she says he told her that it may be too hard to prove anyone broke the law.
“This crackdown won’t bring back my son Luis,” she says. Her pain shows how putting a price tag on human organs isn’t just illegal; it’s also potentially deadly.
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Jonathan Neumann at firstname.lastname@example.org