Air Pollution Turned This Chinese City Into a Ghost Town

Mill shutdowns in Hebei province worsen industrial China’s ills

Photographer: James Whitlow Delano/Bloomberg Business

Smog envelopes Xingtai, China, at dawn in southern Hebei province.

 

The city of Handan in Hebei province is the birthplace of Qin Shihuang, the first emperor of China. That illustrious history isn’t apparent today. Aging, coal-burning steel factories belch grime over the city of 1 million, one of China’s 10 most polluted. Dotting the downtown area are half-constructed high-rises, relics of a property bubble that started more than five years ago but was finally punctured last summer after the central government in Beijing curtailed credit and developers stopped paying creditors. Locals who lost their savings in dodgy real estate investments regularly block city streets in angry protests, demanding their money back from the developers.

The collapse of the property market is only one of Handan’s problems. Hebei province, which nudges up against Beijing, is heavily industrial, and in China, heavy manufacturing means pollution. The sulfur dioxide, nitrogen dioxide, and dust from Hebei’s smokestack industries end up fouling the air of Beijing, and the government wants to make the capital breathable again. The only solution is to wean Hebei off manufacturing.

Last year the province’s economy was one of China’s worst-performing, growing 6.5 percent, below its 8 percent target. Hebei’s mills produce some 25 percent of China’s more than 800 million tons of steel. The province is one of the country’s biggest glass and cement manufacturers. All three industries face serious oversupply, much of it built up since cheap loans became available after the 2008 global financial crisis. China’s steel factories run at 72 percent of capacity: A mill generally has to run at 80 percent to make a profit.

Coal trucks wait at a power plant between Handan and Xingtai, two of China’s most polluted cities.
Photographer: James Whitlow Delano/Bloomberg Business
Coal trucks wait at a power plant between Handan and Xingtai, two of China’s most polluted cities.

 

Under pressure from top leaders, provincial authorities have promised to cut capacity in steelmaking and cement manufacturing by 60 million metric tons each by the end of 2017 and reduce coal use by 40 million tons.

Thousands of factories have already been closed, and thousands more will suffer the same fate. “Our economy is collapsing, and we are facing a crisis,” says Wang Lihe, a cab driver for the past five years. He says his monthly earnings have dropped from 5,000 yuan ($800) last summer to 3,000 yuan to 4,000 yuan today. “My place used to be full. Now look at it,” says Su Xiushang, whose empty restaurant sits near the east gate of Handan Iron & Steel, the city’s biggest mill. “Handan was a rich town with its history and steel. Now regular people can’t even afford to eat out.”

Smoke from Hansteel billows right above this Handan neighborhood, washing over it, and its residents, with toxic fumes.  The Chinese government has begun a program of closing down select factories using coal-fired blast furnaces and of industrial consolidation in an effort to reduce the worst air pollution in China.  Handan is ranking #3 in China behind Xingtai and Baoding (both in southern Hebei Province) as the worst air pollutors in the country and the world.  Handan, Hebei Province, China.  Behemoth, Hansteel is too big to close.
Photographer: James Whitlow Delano/Bloomberg Business
Smoke from Hansteel billows right above this Handan neighborhood, washing over it, and its residents, with toxic fumes. The Chinese government has begun a program of closing down select factories using coal-fired blast furnaces and of industrial consolidation in an effort to reduce the worst air pollution in China. Handan is ranking #3 in China behind Xingtai and Baoding (both in southern Hebei Province) as the worst air pollutors in the country and the world. Handan, Hebei Province, China. Behemoth, Hansteel is too big to close.

 

A residential compound next to a closed factory.
Photographer: James Whitlow Delano/Bloomberg Business
A residential compound next to a closed factory.

 

By the time Hebei finishes restructuring its industries, an estimated 200,000 steel jobs will be gone, the Hebei Provincial Development and Reform Commission says. The factory shutdowns fit with a national plan to consolidate steel production in larger, more efficient mills closer to the ports that bring in Australian iron ore, says Michael Komesaroff, principal of Urandaline Investments, a Melbourne-based consulting firm. “The transition is coming at a much faster rate and on a larger scale than had been previously anticipated. That’s making it much harder for everyone to manage,” Komesaroff says.

China’s leaders are trying to bolster the province’s economy through a regional development plan called “Jing-Jin-Ji,” short for Beijing, Tianjin, and Hebei (“Ji” is a one-character traditional name for the province). Endorsed by President Xi Jinping last year, it calls for expanding the network of roads and high-speed rail. Some government offices, as well as most of Beijing’s wholesale markets in clothing and household goods, will be moved to Hebei to relieve congestion in the capital and create jobs in the province.

A sign of the property bubble: a half-built high-rise in Xingtai.
Photographer: James Whitlow Delano/Bloomberg Business
A sign of the property bubble: a half-built high-rise in Xingtai.

 

A pig is butchered outside a fertilizer plant that spews coal ash over the area.
Photographer: James Whitlow Delano/Bloomberg Business
A pig is butchered outside a fertilizer plant that spews coal ash over the area.

Earlier nationwide efforts to consolidate the steel industry foundered as local governments resisted closures that would have led to job losses and tax revenue shortfalls, says Komesaroff. The latest attempts may as well. “Our equipment is backward, and yes, we are polluting the skies, but we have maybe 30,000 workers—this factory is the biggest employer here,” says a worker eating beef noodles in a cafe by the main gate of the Handan steel factory. His employer, a subsidiary of China’s largest steelmaker, Hebei Iron & Steel Group, is ultimately controlled by the central government. “All of our revenues go to Beijing. They won’t shut us down.”

The bottom line: With the restructuring of the steel and cement industries, Hebei may lose at least 200,000 steel jobs.

Young men make there way out to a main road surrounded by closed glass factories on Shahe, Hebei Province that used coal-powered blast furnaces.  The central government began a program of closing down, older, less-efficient, heavily polluting glass factories to reduce air pollution in Beijing which is ringed by Hebei Province.  The results, thus far, have been mixed.
Photographer: James Whitlow Delano/Bloomberg Business
Young men make there way out to a main road surrounded by closed glass factories on Shahe, Hebei Province that used coal-powered blast furnaces. The central government began a program of closing down, older, less-efficient, heavily polluting glass factories to reduce air pollution in Beijing which is ringed by Hebei Province. The results, thus far, have been mixed.