Photographer: David Ryder/Bloomberg

Lumber Trade War Brewing as Hope of New Canada-U.S. Deal Fades

  • Officials began fourth round of negotiations Wednesday
  • Sides remain ‘far apart’ on several key issues: Moen

A trade dispute between the U.S. and Canada over softwood lumber is escalating, raising the specter of higher tariffs as officials downplay the likelihood of reaching a deal before an October deadline.

President Barack Obama and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau directed their governments at a June meeting in Ottawa to push forward and reach accord on the issue, long a thorn in relations, while acknowledging “significant differences” remain. Officials began two days of talks in Washington on Wednesday, the fourth round of negotiations since the leaders met.

Optimism is fading. Canada’s Ambassador to the U.S., David MacNaughton, and the country’s chief softwood lumber negotiator, Martin Moen, have each said this month the sides remain far apart. Trade Minister Chrystia Freeland signaled the same, saying Canada would rather go past the October deadline than settle for a bad deal.

“We’re not going to be bound by any particular deadline,” Freeland said in an interview on Tuesday. “We’re going to try and reach an agreement, and we’re working hard now in the fall to do that.”

New Tariffs

If the deadline is missed, the U.S. is expected to begin a process to enact new tariffs, which would be a barrier to Canadian producers including major players such as Canfor Corp., West Fraser Timber Co. and Interfor Corp. Exports from Canada accounted for most of the increased lumber demand from U.S. builders this year through April, Bloomberg Intelligence estimates.

The previous softwood lumber deal -- which included export quotas for Canadian producers -- expired in October, triggering a one-year standstill that includes a tariff freeze. Monthly softwood exports to the U.S. are up 23 percent on average, on a seasonally adjusted basis, since the pact expired, data compiled by Bloomberg show.

The value of softwood lumber exports to the U.S. is up 25 percent to C$3.6 billion ($2.8 billion) in the first six months of 2016, compared with C$2.9 billion in the same period last year, according to trade data compiled by statistics Canada. In 2015, Canada exported C$5.9 billion to the U.S.

U.S. industry has long complained that Canadian “stumpage” prices for standing timber constitute an unfair subsidy and that Canada, the world’s largest lumber exporter, is therefore undercutting the U.S. market.

Without a new deal, there’s a “high risk” U.S. producers will petition the Commerce Department to enact “high countervailing and anti-dumping duties on Canadian softwood,” Moen told a parliamentary committee this month. Canadian legal challenges to U.S. tariffs have been successful but “have taken years to get results,” he said.

Any new U.S. tariffs wouldn’t take effect immediately and would therefore create something of a second deadline for trade negotiators, raising the prospect of a deal after the grace period ends but before the tariffs are expected to actually kick in sometime during spring of 2017.

“There is an overtime period, but we’re working hard now” to reach a deal, Freeland said. In another interview, she called it a “really tough issue” with no guarantees. “Can we guarantee a positive outcome? No, we can’t. But I think it’s important to say from the Canadian side, we’re not looking for any deal, we’re just looking for a good deal.”

A spokesperson for U.S. Trade Representative Michael Froman didn’t respond to requests for comment.

Protectionist Climate

The protectionist climate in the U.S. only adds to the complication around a softwood lumber deal, Freeland added. The Trudeau cabinet was briefed by MacNaughton earlier this week about rising anti-trade sentiment in the U.S.

The talks are “challenging,” MacNaughton told journalists on Aug. 21. He reiterated Canada would rather miss the October deadline than cede to U.S. demands. “We’re not there yet. We’re still quite a ways away from getting there” and reaching an agreement, he said.

While goodwill between the two governments is essential to concluding a new softwood agreement, it’s not enough because a majority of U.S. companies must approve any deal, Moen said, describing the prospect of an agreement by October as a “goal” for Canada.

“We do remain far apart on several key issues,” Moen told the lawmakers. “There are considerable gaps that will need to be bridged in order for a new agreement to be concluded.”

The 2006 softwood agreement expired on Oct. 12, 2015. Canada sought to extend the agreement but the U.S. declined.

Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal. LEARN MORE