We Tried McDonald's New 'Create Your Taste' Menu

Bloomberg's U.S. Consumer News Team scoped out McDonald's newest offering for New Yorkers

McDonald's new Create Your Taste custom-burger concept arrived in Manhattan this week, giving New Yorkers their first look at the chain's high-tech future.

Photographer: Bloomberg News

A remodeled store on Third Avenue in Midtown now lets customers order via large touchscreens, allowing them to pick the toppings, buns, and sauces they want on their sandwiches.

Photographer: Bloomberg News

The touchscreen kiosks are slick and fun to use, though they take a bit of practice. One of our testers missed such basic items as tomatoes and lettuce because he didn't scroll down far enough.

Photographer: Bloomberg News

And it's not cheap. A medium Create Your Taste burger meal with bacon, fries, and a Coke cost more than $12. That's in the realm of Shake Shack, a chain known for higher-end fare.

It's also a long wait, at least by McDonald's standards. The kitchen doesn't even begin cooking the sandwich until customers complete and pay for their orders. (You can use a payment card right at the kiosk.) After that, it takes eight to 10 minutes. For our testers, the time was at the upper end of that range or slightly beyond it.

Photographer: Bloomberg News

Customers are given a buzzing coaster, like what you might get at Olive Garden. When the order is ready, the staff comes out to find you—even if you're getting it to go. You also can get the same Create Your Taste options at the register, though that will probably take longer. The experience seems to work better for customers who dine at the restaurant.

The order comes in a large grocery-style bag with no McDonald's logo on the front. That lets New Yorkers go incognito.

Photographer: Bloomberg News

One question: Why does the chef hat have a skewer through it? Looks painful.

The burgers also come in special packages, and they're laid flat like a McDLT. (Remember that?)

Photographer: Bloomberg News

The food was universally praised by our testers, with one saying it was the best McDonald's burger he'd ever had. The optional artisan roll elevates the sandwich, another said. Create Your Taste also offers mushrooms, guacamole, sriracha, and other items not typically found on McDonald's burgers.

Photographer: Bloomberg News

The quality and selection may entice customers back to McDonald's, which is trying to recover from its worst slump in more than a decade. The question is whether they'll stay after the novelty wears off.

—By Bloomberg's U.S. Consumer News Team

Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal. LEARN MORE