How Businesses Survive When Caught in the Middle of a Territorial Dispute

Updated on
Edwin's fast-food
Edwin's fast-food restaurant owned by Edwin L. Tan, president of the Palawan Filipino Chinese Chamber of Commerce, in Puerto Princesa City, Palawan. Photographer: Sanjit Das/Bloomberg

China’s territorial assertions in the disputed South China Sea are making life complicated for ethnic Chinese businessmen in smaller claimant nations like the Philippines.

Filipino-Chinese businessmen take care to show they are on the side of the Philippines, according to Edwin Tan, president of the Palawan Filipino Chinese Chamber of Commerce. Palawan island, which draws tourists for its pristine beaches and diving, is a Philippine gateway to the South China Sea.

“The Chinese community of the Palawan Chamber, they own the town,” Tan said in an interview in his five-story mall, the tallest building height allowed in Palawan’s capital, Puerto Princesa. “There are doubts, there’s suspicion, they might say we’re siding with the Chinese.”

Chinese merchants have long traded in Southeast Asia. But as Asia’s biggest economy accelerates reclamation work on disputed reefs in the South China Sea and increases its military presence in the area, it risks inflaming historical tensions for ethnic Chinese who live and do business in the region.

Some of the most prominent businesspeople in the Philippines are ethnic Chinese. Henry Sy, the Philippines’ richest man, was born in China and at least seven of the 10 biggest companies on the national stock exchange are run by Filipinos of Chinese descent.

Philippine census data does not provide a breakdown by ethnicity, but some reports say the proportion of the population with pure Chinese ancestry is about one percent. China was the Philippines’ second-largest trading partner in 2014, according to the Philippine Statistics Authority.

Deadly Riots

Resentment has flared periodically for decades over the disproportionate influence that ethnic Chinese can have over the economies of Southeast Asia, leading to tensions with the broader population. There have been times when Chinese people were targeted in Indonesia, the Philippines and Vietnam over relatively minor incidents such as traffic accidents or brawls with Chinese traders.

Most recently, deadly riots erupted in Vietnam after China towed an oil rig into waters claimed by the two countries in May last year. The protesters targeted factories with Chinese names, including those operated by companies from Singapore and Taiwan, forcing some of them to shut temporarily.

While there have been few signs of fresh frictions in the major Philippine cities, closer to the South China Sea suspicions are growing and that may impact local Chinese residents.

Palawan residents say some Chinese fishermen are spies sent to gather information, and that China’s territorial claims have emboldened its fishermen to hunt endangered turtles and argue the sea is their territory.

‘Repeat Offenders’

“We’re starting to hate them,” said Alex Marcaida, 52, a division head at the Palawan Council for Sustainable Development, tasked with enforcing the law against the poachers. “Many are repeat offenders, that’s what makes it more insulting.”

In the past, members of the Palawan Filipino Chinese Chamber of Commerce volunteered to act as interpreters for Chinese citizens facing illegal-fishing charges in Philippine courts, according to businessman Antonio Ong.

“Now we hesitate to help because the locals might mistake us as supporters of the Chinese government,” Ong, 74, said in an interview. Ong, who came to the Philippines from Xiamen four decades ago, said he worries the negative sentiment would eventually affect his business ventures that include hotels and property.

Almost two-thirds of Filipinos have little trust in China, according to a June poll by the Social Weather Stations, or SWS, a Manila-based survey company. Net trust in China fell to a record -45 percent since the SWS started the poll in 1994.

Upcoming Chinatown

That isn’t yet stopping his fellow businessmen from extending their reach. A multi-story “Chinatown Center” complete with tiered red pagodas is under construction in the middle of Palawan, along a street lined with Chinese shops and restaurants with names such as Chow King and Great Wall.

The U.S. has also sought to build its influence on the island, conducting joint military exercises that have boosted business for locals such as travel agent Mila Daquer. Still, Filipino-Chinese have lived and done business on the island as far back as locals can remember, said Daquer.

Philippine exports fell the most in more than three years in May as shipments to China declined from a year earlier, according to data released Friday, underscoring the nation’s reliance on the country for trade and investment.

“The Philippines should stand on her own, but we don’t have enough strength,” said 47-year-old Daquer. “We have more Chinese here and they do business here. We don’t want war, if we can settle this in a very nice way, why not?”

Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal. LEARN MORE