Duke Energy Battles to Halt Leak Amid Coal-Ash Review

Duke Energy Corp. is still battling to halt a leak from a coal-ash pond into the Dan River in North Carolina, in the latest incident to draw attention to how power-plant waste is regulated.

No arsenic or other heavy metals, common in coal ash and considered toxic, were found in the first samples of treated river water taken at Danville, Virginia, Arnold Hendrix, a spokesman for the city, said yesterday in a telephone interview. Danville is located 25 miles (40 kilometers) downriver from the spill site. The Dan provides Danville’s water supply.

The latest spill comes as the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency prepares to issue regulations for coal ash after a record 1 billion gallons of ash sludge poured into Tennessee’s Emory River from a Tennessee Valley Authority disposal pond in 2008. Duke estimated its Dan River Plant pond has leaked as many as 27 million gallons of water and 82,000 tons of ash since Feb. 2.

Duke’s priority is to stop the leak, Meghan Musgrave, a spokeswoman for the largest U.S. utility owner in Charlotte, said yesterday in a telephone interview. The rate of spillage declined Feb. 4 after the pond emptied and has fluctuated since then because of rain and repairs, Musgrave said. Duke estimates that the pond contained 992,000 tons of ash and that about 10 percent has spilled, she said.

Overnight crews dug down to a broken storm-water pipe that runs under the pond, through which water and ash flowed to the river, and will attempt to plug it, said Lisa Hoffman, another spokeswoman for Duke. The company’s efforts to stop the leak were criticized by environmental groups.

Done Nothing

“Duke has done nothing to contain the spill,” Donna Lisenby, the global coal campaign coordinator for the environmental group Waterkeeper Alliance, said yesterday in an interview. When Lisenby visited the spill location Feb. 4, “there were no hard assets deployed on the river to clean up the ash, contain the ash, or stop the spill,” she said.

The ash originated at Duke’s Dan River Steam Station, closed since 2012 as the company replaced coal-fueled plants with those that run on cleaner-burning natural gas in anticipation of tighter air pollution rules. The TVA spill also came from a pond at a retired coal plant.

Danville had earlier said its water treatment plant was successfully removing bits of ash that had turned water from the river gray.

The first samples of treated river water were collected by Duke and the results announced by the city in a statement. Danville also has collected its own samples and sent them for analysis, Barry Dunkley, the local division director of water and wastewater treatment, said in a Feb. 4 telephone interview.

Tested Normal

River water at the site tested normal for temperature, acidity and dissolved oxygen, indicators that are important to fish, the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources said in a statement. Test results for heavy metals are expected today.

“Those who get their drinking water from private or community wells will be unaffected by this event,” John Skvarla, the department secretary, said in the statement. “Water from the river that has been treated by nearby municipal treatment facilities is safe to drink.”

As many as 190 coal-fired generators are set to be shut by 2022, mostly because of increased regulations and competition from shale gas, according to the Edison Electric Institute, the trade group for investor-owned utilities.

New Rules

Environmental groups have sued the EPA to force a decision on coal-ash regulations, arguing that new rules are needed to protect human health and the environment. The EPA told a judge last month it will publish a final rule for managing coal-plant waste by Dec. 19.

Duke agreed last year to pay $100,000 to settle North Carolina claims that ash ponds at two of its coal-fired plants had polluted groundwater, according to a filing with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.

The company said previously it’s working with North Carolina officials on a plan for ash sites at closed plants.

Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal. LEARN MORE