Koch Group Brings Canadian to Charlotte to Attack Health Law

Shona Holmes
Canadian citizen Shona Holmes, right, joins members of the House Republican leadership, from left, Rep. Roy Blunt, Minority Leader John Boehner, Rep. Judy Biggert and Minority Whip Eric Cantor for a news conference about health care policy at the U.S. Capitol in Washington on July 23, 2009. Photographer: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

Blocks from where Democrats are holding their convention, a Canadian resident is warning of the dangers of President Barack Obama’s health-care law.

Shona Holmes is in Charlotte, North Carolina, to promote an Americans for Prosperity ad this week, Bloomberg reports in its Political Capital blog. The nonprofit backs Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney and was co-founded by billionaire industrialists David and Charles Koch.

Its latest ad, called “Replace,” is part of a $27 million Americans for Prosperity ad buy in swing states including North Carolina that expressly calls for people to vote Obama out of office. Holmes said she sought treatment for a brain tumor in the U.S. rather than wait several months for health care in Canada, a delay that she said would have put her life at risk.

“To protect Americans patient-centered care, we must replace president Obama,” an announcer says in the ad.

Holmes made a similar claim in Americans for Prosperity ads in 2009. She has also testified before Congress and appeared at rallies related to the health-care law.

Some groups have questioned both Holmes’s personal story and the tie between Obama’s health-care law and the Canadian system. One difference between them: The U.S. health-care law doesn’t implement a single-payer system in which all Americans are covered by the government. Canada does.

Americans for Prosperity President Tim Phillips said the two plans are “not exactly alike, but they’re relatively similar.”

“The history of greater government involvement in other countries is that wait times do increase,” he said.

Criticism Avalanche

It is an “exaggeration” to say Holmes would have died from her condition, a top Canadian neurosurgeon said in a July 31, 2009, report by the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. Holmes was diagnosed with Rathke’s cleft cyst, a benign, slow-growing tumor that’s not known to be fatal.

Back home, Holmes was vilified as a traitor and received death threats, according to a July 30, 2009, report in the Globe and Mail.

At today’s press conference, Holmes said Obama supporters “attacked the messenger rather than listening to the message.” She said she has endured “an avalanche of criticism” because Canadians “are very defensive of our health-care system.”

In addition to highlighting its new ad in Charlotte, Americans for Prosperity will hold a rally this evening outside the convention center there. And the group is starting a bus tour this week from Charlotte.

Holmes said she’ll be in Charlotte all week to do interviews. The group also held events during the Republican National Convention last week in Tampa, Florida. Co-founder David Koch and fellow board member Art Pope were honored by their group for their contributions to business.

Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal. LEARN MORE