Kashmir No Longer World’s Most Dangerous Place as Tourism Climbs

Kashmir Lures Record Visitors as Insurgency Hotspot Regains Calm
Kashmiri take tourists on shikara rides on Dal lake in Srinagar. It was that mix of natural beauty and a hybrid culture blending Sufi Islam, Hinduism and other faiths that each year in the 1980s drew more than 500,000 Indian tourists, western backpackers and skiers. Photographer: Rouf Bhat/AFP/Getty Images

Hotel owner Wahid Malik drives his ball down the fairway at the Royal Springs Golf Course in Indian Kashmir, taking a break from hosting tourists flocking to the disputed region guarded by half a million soldiers and police.

Malik plans to build a new guest house to cash in on a tourism boom that has seen the number of visitors double to a record 2 million in the past year, to an area over which nuclear-armed India and Pakistan have fought two wars. With an anti-Indian insurgency causing the fewest deaths since it began in 1989, five-star hotels are full and the cost of flights to Kashmir’s summer capital of Srinagar is up 40 percent.

“Our hope is that a few years from now, Kashmir will no longer be known as a place of tanks and troops,” said Malik, 50, whose hotel is overlooked by 2,700-meter (8,800-feet) Himalayan peaks and served as a residence for the army for 15 years until 2005. “No one who lived through the dark days wants a return.”

The tourist rush promises jobs in a region where half the population aged between 18 and 30 are out of work. Getting more young Kashmiris into full-time employment can further lower violence and aid peace moves along the subcontinent’s most intractable fault line, where fighting between militants and India’s army has killed 50,000 people over more than two decades.

“The security situation feeds off unemployment,” Omar Abdullah, 42, the chief minister of the Indian state of Jammu and Kashmir, said in an interview in Srinagar. “A youngster who is poorly educated with dismal job prospects is more likely to be recruited into militancy.”

‘Only Answer’

While the return of the tourists brings hope, Kashmir won’t be at peace until India and Pakistan reach a political solution for the region that’s been at the core of their conflict for seven decades, according to Abdullah, whose father and grandfather both led the state.

“We don’t see tourism as a barometer of normalcy,” he said, sitting on the balcony of his heavily fortified hillside home. “The problem in Kashmir is political. So even if militancy were to disappear tomorrow, we still need to address this problem. That’s the only answer.”

It was the mix of natural beauty and a hybrid culture blending Sufi Islam, Hinduism and other faiths that each year in the 1980s drew more than 650,000 Indian tourists, western backpackers and skiers.

Trekkers’ Kidnapping

By the end of the decade, an election widely perceived as rigged energized the separatist movement. The 1995 kidnapping of six westerners by Islamic guerrillas demanding that India free jailed militants dealt a hammer blow to Kashmir tourism, resulting in the decapitation of a Norwegian hiker and disappearance of four others. Visitors plunged to 60,000 that year, government data show.

Pressure on Pakistan from the U.S., its biggest aid donor, to drop state support for Islamic groups, and improved Indian defenses have seen the cross-border insurgency decline, with deaths down 90 percent since 2005.

Anger over alleged human-rights abuses by Indian soldiers and a lack of self-rule can still boil over into street clashes, such as those in 2010 in which police shot dead almost 100 protestors.

With India and Pakistan re-engaging in peace talks and pursuing their biggest initiative yet for cross-border trade, the fall-off in violence is reviving the Kashmiri economy.

Dal Lake

Vivanta by Taj, the Tata Group’s five-star hotel on a forested hilltop overlooking Dal Lake with room rates of as high as $300, has been booked out since May. The luxury Lalit hotel located in the residence of Kashmir’s last maharajah is full. Billionaire Anil Ambani, who runs part of the Reliance empire, and Hero Motocorp Ltd. Chairman Brijmohan Munjal were among this summer’s guests, said Ashwani Patel, the Lalit’s manager.

“This year has surpassed all our expectations,” making the hotel the chain’s best-performing property on a room-to-revenue basis across nine Indian cities, said Patel, 32.

The first five-star hotel in the ski resort of Gulmarg is being built by U.S.-based Interstate Hotels & Resorts Inc. and Kashmiri business group Khyber Industries Ltd. The 85-room hotel is due to open in October.

“Investing in Kashmir is no longer a roll of the dice,” Umar Tramboo, a director at Khyber, said in an interview.

Tourism is once again the second-largest employer, after farming, and accounts for 20 percent of Jammu and Kashmir’s $9 billion economy, which grew 6.6 percent last year, according to government data. Abdullah’s administration says a prolonged calm will see annual 10 percent growth in tourist arrivals over the next decade.

‘Enough Bloodshed’

“Enough bloodshed has been spilt,” said Malik at the golf course overlooking a glistening Dal Lake. “Each year more and more people are coming back. Let’s hope this time it lasts.”

Most of the visitors are domestic, with just 3 percent coming from abroad in the past 12 months. Abdullah, who took power after elections in 2008 in which 61 percent of eligible Kashmiris voted, up from 44 percent in 2002, is pressing U.S. and western European governments to rescind advisories against their citizens traveling to Kashmir.

While Kashmir has seen a steady decline in violence since U.S. President Bill Clinton called the region the world’s most dangerous place in 2000 -- a year after the U.S. intervened to restrain India and Pakistan from broadening a two-month border conflict -- the state still resembles a war zone.

Razor Wire

Bunkers covered in razor wire, armored vehicles and police cradling machine guns mark many crossroads in Srinagar. There are about half a million troops and police providing security in the state, according to Abdullah, one for every 25 civilians.

Finding a political solution to the region’s troubles has remained bogged down in issues of faith and identity ever since India and Pakistan gained independence from Britain. Two months after the 1947 split from the U.K., the Hindu maharajah of Jammu and Kashmir joined India following an invasion by tribal militias and Pakistani troops.

Pakistan, created as a homeland for the subcontinent’s Muslims, continues to claim the Kashmir Valley, where the majority follow Islam. For India, the region’s membership in the union bolsters the country’s secular credentials.

“For India and Pakistan, Kashmir is a non-negotiable issue,” Uday Bhaskar, a New Delhi-based analyst at the National Maritime Foundation, a research group, said Aug. 9. Still, “separatist forces within Kashmir are not getting the kind of support they used to get earlier. Kashmiris are becoming more aware that peace and prosperity is possible,” he said.

Helping ‘Downtrodden’

Mirwaiz Umar Farooq, the head Muslim priest of Kashmir and chairman of the All Parties Hurriyat Conference, a coalition of pro-independence parties, said the return of tourists will help improve life for the valley’s “downtrodden” people.

“That doesn’t mean peace has returned to the valley,” Farooq said by phone from Srinagar. “Yes people want better education, better health care and better roads. That doesn’t mean they don’t want freedom. The government of India should come up with something substantial in terms of moving forward.”

Separatist leader Syed Ali Shah Geelani says only 2 percent to 3 percent of Kashmiris would benefit from the tourists’ return.

Geelani, whom Abdullah has blamed for provoking the 2010 violence, rejects the talks with the Indian government that other top pro-independence politicians support. He says Kashmir is ready to erupt again as its people remain harassed and denied basic rights, with many who protest imprisoned and tortured.

‘Under Occupation’

“We remain under occupation and a very brutal occupation,” said Geelani over a cup of tea and almond biscuits at his home in Srinagar, which he says he hasn’t been allowed to leave for four months without being given a reason why. “There isn’t real peace, this is a managed peace.”

Previous governments that associated a return of tourism with an end to the uprising were caught off-guard by a resurgence of violence, so it’s essential that a high security presence is maintained, Abdullah said.

Tariq Ahmad Bhat, 32, embodies the challenges.

Unemployed and frustrated at what he considered a military occupation, he joined thousands of young Kashmiris who spent much of the summer of 2010 pelting Indian security forces with stones after a teenager was killed by a police tear-gas shell.

Police responded with bullets, fueling a cycle of violence. Geelani supported the demonstrations while Prime Minister Manmohan Singh spoke of some violence being orchestrated by pro-independence groups.

Bhat was arrested and after being released took a job earning $120 a month ferrying tourists to houseboats on Dal Lake. His new income hasn’t eased his anger.

“Every day we face harassment,” Bhat said, standing on the street corner where he was detained two years ago. “Kashmir is a tinderbox and it just takes one match for things to get out of control again.”

Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal. LEARN MORE