AIG Oversight Extended, Five Years After Spitzer Accord

AIG CEO Robert Benmosche
American International Group Chief Executive Officer Robert Benmosche. Photographer: Andrew Harrer/Bloomberg

American International Group Inc., the insurer seeking an exit from U.S. ownership, was told by regulators to extend the period of oversight imposed as part of a $1.64 billion fraud settlement in 2006.

Therese Pritchard’s term as independent consultant overseeing AIG has been extended through the end of the year, she said in an interview late yesterday. Her duties were set to expire today, according to the insurer’s regulatory filings.

Chief Executive Officer Robert Benmosche, 67, is working to distance AIG from legal disputes under previous leaders and restore confidence in the company as he seeks private capital to replace government bailout funds. The New York-based insurer disclosed a weakness in accounting for credit-default swaps in 2008 and said in February that a shortfall in reserves led to a charge of about $4 billion.

AIG “was the frontrunner in the crisis that occurred,” Phillip Phan, professor at the Johns Hopkins Carey Business School in Baltimore, said in a telephone interview. “That doesn’t allow them complete freedom yet, until they can be sure that the corporate governance has been put in place.”

Pritchard’s term was extended to document how AIG implements so-called best-practice recommendations, according to a person familiar with the matter. She’s scheduled to complete the last stage of monitoring, said the person, who declined to be identified because there has been no public statement about the firm’s progress on the requirements.

Florence Harmon, a spokeswoman for the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, declined to comment. Joseph Norton, a spokesman for AIG, didn’t immediately respond to a message seeking comment.

Fraud Settlement

AIG agreed to hire the consultant, acceptable to the SEC, for a three-year term as part of a 2006 fraud settlement with regulators including then-New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer, who accused the company of rigging bids, duping shareholders and underfunding workers’ compensation pools. The consultant was assigned to make recommendations for improving the insurer’s regulatory compliance and internal auditing.

AIG’s size and complexity, even after winding down derivative bets and selling assets to help pay down its bailout, may have contributed to the SEC backing a longer term, said Roddy Boyd, author of “Fatal Risk: A Cautionary Tale of AIG’s Corporate Suicide.”

“They’re very much of the view that this has been an under-regulated company that you can never have enough eyeballs or hands on,” said Boyd.

Justice Department

James Cole, now the nation’s No. 2 Justice Department official, was appointed as AIG’s independent consultant in 2005 after the insurer agreed to pay $126 million to settle SEC allegations it helped clients such as PNC Financial Services Group Inc. inflate profits. The monitoring duties were expanded after the Spitzer accord. The job is now held by Pritchard, a partner at Bryan Cave LLP, where Cole previously worked.

Cole was confirmed as the U.S. Justice Department’s deputy attorney general this week after President Barack Obama appointed him during a recess in December. Senate Republicans in May blocked a vote to confirm Cole after criticizing his approach to terrorism and his AIG role. The insurer was bailed out in 2008 after misjudging the risk of losses from investments tied to subprime mortgages.

The rescue swelled to $182.3 billion, and the U.S. Treasury Department retains a 77 percent stake after both the government and AIG sold shares in May. AIG said it would use $550 million in proceeds from the offering to compensate investors including pension funds for stock declines dating to Spitzer’s probe.

Stock Slump

AIG has plunged more than 95 percent since the end of 2005 on the New York Stock Exchange. The insurer has declined 40 percent this year through yesterday, the worst performance in the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index. The company advanced 7 cents to $29.21 in composite trading at 9:31 a.m.

Benmosche became CEO in 2009 and resolved legal disputes that year with former CEO Maurice “Hank” Greenberg, who was forced out during the Spitzer probe. The insurer agreed to reimburse as much as $150 million in legal fees for Greenberg and ex-Chief Financial Officer Howard Smith.

AIG said in a regulatory filing last month that the consultant’s term was extended to June 30 of this year.

Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal. LEARN MORE