Review by John Mariani
April 20 (Bloomberg) -- “When I was a little boy I liked
to eat lemons,” says Ricardo Freitas. “I think maybe that’s
where I got my love of acids.”
Freitas, 45, is using his fondness for acidic flavor to
update centuries of tradition as managing director and winemaker
for his family’s Vinhos Barbeito on the Portuguese Island of
“Madeira has a long history with many rules in place,” he
told me over a lunch at The Modern in New York. “But I always
believed that acidity is the key to making a brighter, more
refreshing wine than the old heavy, tannic, oxidized style.”
Freitas’s Madeiras have twice been judged one of the
world’s 10 best wines regardless of category at the annual
Vinexpo in Bordeaux, and his basic 10-year-old Verdelho Madeira
was judged the top fortified wine in the world at the 2009
exhibition, surpassing an array of Vintage Ports. His secret?
“Less technology and more thinking,” he says.
Having tasted half a dozen of his wines over lunch, I
discovered that not only are they far easier to drink than
traditional-style Madeiras but that they go better with food
than as dessert wines or after-dinner drinks.
One complete surprise was to find how well Madeira went
with Chef Gabriel Kreuther’s very spicy casserole of braised
tripe with chickpeas and red hot harissa aioli -- a dish I would
never think of accompanying with a sweet Madeira.
But Freitas’s Signature Series Barbeito VB, a blend of
equal parts verdelho and boal, was only medium sweet and the
acid so beloved by Freitas was perfect at cutting the richness
of the dish.
Other bottlings, like the 2001 Barbeito Boal Colheita
Madeira Casks 48+84 ($45/500 ml) -- those palindromic numbers
signaled good fortune to Freitas when he found the casks -- went
splendidly with a foie gras torchon with dried cherries and duck
prosciutto, while a duck confit a l’orange, with its own
bittersweet edge, was wonderful with the nutty “Charleston”
This last, along with a “Boston” Boal and “New York”
Malmsey, are part of what Barbeito calls its “Historic
Series,” commemorating the prestigious reputation Madeira had
in the U.S. in the 18th and 19th centuries.
Along with the firm’s American importer, The Rare Wine
Co., Barbeito creates its wines from single harvest and/or
single casks in limited production, with just a barrel or two
made at a time.
Freitas regards each step of the Madeira-making process,
including fortifying the wine with spirits, as an opportunity
for questioning old practices.
“It took me five years to convince my mother to stop using
caramel to color the wines,” he says of an age-old technique.
“I believed the caramel added its own flavor and I wanted the
wines to taste only of their grape.”
To this end Freitas demonstrated that Madeira’s workhorse
grape, tinta negra mole, can make fine wine without blending. He
also ages his wine using the slower canteiro method, without the
direct heat most producers use in the estufa (“hothouse”) that
accelerates the maturation of the wine. Barbeito’s slower
maturation keeps oxidation to a minimum and, as I found out over
lunch, allows the wines to be enjoyed with savory food.
When an age is indicated on a Madeira bottle, it
usually refers to the oldest wine or the average age of the
wines in the blend, as with Barbeito Malvasia 30-year-old
Special Lot Madeira ($125/750ml), which Freitas made as a
tribute to his grandfather Mario Barbeito, the company’s
The average age of the wines is 30 years, with some older
and some younger.
Freitas promises this is the only time he will make such a
blend; with only 1,550 bottles, it’s the company’s priciest
Barbieto will also vintage-date the wines to indicate a
single barrel Madeira like its 1994 Malvasia Single Cask ‘23c’
($50/500ml), bottled by hand in 2006, with 942 bottles made.
In the fall of 2007, upon finding that a cask from 2000 had
become quite concentrated after the summer’s heat caused
evaporation, he bottled the wine immediately to maintain its
refinement and richness, which might have been compromised by
We did enjoy the Madeiras with some artisanal cheese and
desserts like a milk chocolate and hazelnut dacquoise with
raspberry sorbet, the more conventional point in the meal to
drink the fortified wines. But Freitas, who seemed as surprised
as I was by the match-ups with the first and main courses,
proved to me the versatility of his wine with food.
I’m not sure I’m ready for an entire meal accompanied only
by Madeiras -- whose alcohol content is 19 percent and higher --
but with an individual dish, especially one with spice and a
little sweetness, they are delicious alternatives to dry whites
(John Mariani writes on wine for Bloomberg News. The
opinions expressed are his own.)
For Related News and Information:
More wine reviews: NI WINEREV
Wine auction stories: TNI WINE AUCTION
Top stories about arts and culture: MUSE
--Editors: Adam Majendie, Jeffrey Burke.
To contact the writer of this column:
John Mariani at firstname.lastname@example.org.
To contact the editor responsible for this column:
Manuela Hoelterhoff in New York at +1-212-617-3486 or
-0- Apr/20/2010 15:16 GMT
Please upgrade your Browser
Your browser is out-of-date. Please download one of these excellent browsers: