Critics: Just point to Google

Is criticism worth reading, or merely a pointer to Google?

Tyler Cowen wonders what critics are good for. He says he looks for only one thing when reading a book review: Whether he should Google it. He calls it a binary decision. The next binary decision is whether he should Amazon it.

If you look at life as a series of decisions about what to acquire, maybe these binary processes make sense. But imagine someone is talking to you about a fascinating book. Are you thinking: I wish this person would shut up and go away so I can get busy Googling and Amazoning the book? It might make more sense to focus on what the person’s talking about, to process a thought or two—and maybe later move into the acquisition mode.

In a way, this thinking Cowen describes is like when we walk through the forest or along the shore and think non-stop about taking pictures. Instead of concentrating on the present experience, we obsess about what we can harvest from it. I’m guilty of that.

Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal. LEARN MORE