Abe Warns Japan Losing Image Battle Over War Legacy

Photographer: Haruyoshi Yamaguchi/Bloomberg

Shinzo Abe, Japan's prime minister, speaks during a budget committee session in the lower house of the Parliament in Tokyo on Feb. 28, 2014. Close

Shinzo Abe, Japan's prime minister, speaks during a budget committee session in the... Read More

Close
Open
Photographer: Haruyoshi Yamaguchi/Bloomberg

Shinzo Abe, Japan's prime minister, speaks during a budget committee session in the lower house of the Parliament in Tokyo on Feb. 28, 2014.

Prime Minister Shinzo Abe stepped up a war of words with China, alleging an international campaign to taint Japan’s image by focusing on past militarism rather than decades of peace since World War II.

“There’s propaganda to depict Japan in a way that’s far from the truth,” Abe said in parliament yesterday in Tokyo. “There is danger emerging, where such propaganda will have a huge influence on our children’s generation. I would like to think of a strong public relations strategy going forward.”

While he did not reference China directly, the comments follow a period of escalated tensions and name calling between the two countries. His remarks came days after China announced national days to commemorate Japan’s war defeat and a massacre in Nanjing by Japanese troops in 1937. Last month China opened a museum to honor Ahn Joong Geun, a South Korean nationalist who assassinated then-Japanese Resident General of Korea Hirobumi Ito in 1909. China’s official People’s Daily unveiled an online game where users can shoot Japanese war criminals.

For China and South Korea, the legacy of Japan’s occupation before and during the war continues to infuse popular thinking and government policy. A recent pickup in revisionist rhetoric by some of Abe’s nationalist allies, plus his December visit to a Tokyo shrine honoring Japan’s war dead, is fueling the backlash even as China’s military assertiveness in the region raises concerns about President Xi Jinping’s own aspirations.

’Bold Decision’

“The Japanese government must make a right and bold decision for the two countries to overcome a painful past and move on together for a prosperous future,” South Korean President Park Geun Hye said today.

“They should stop denying the past and face the truth of history. Otherwise, they will be isolated,” she said in a televised speech in Seoul to mark the anniversary of a 1919 uprising against Japanese colonization.

Qin Gang, spokesman for China’s Foreign Ministry, criticized Japan yesterday. “I just want to emphasize that some people in some countries have selective amnesia 70 years after the WWII, denying atrocities in the Nanjing Massacre and still repeatedly paying respects to their war criminals,” Qin said.

Xi and South Korea’s Park Geun Hye have refused to meet with Abe, citing friction over Japan’s take on its role in history. The tension threatens to hurt trade among East Asia’s three biggest economies and complicates efforts to defuse territorial disputes that have raised military frictions.

Xinhua Editorial

“A thousand years will pass and the guilt of Japanese militarism will not be erased,” China’s official Xinhua News Agency wrote Feb. 27 in an editorial. “If Japan continues to turn a deaf ear to the call of peace and warning bells against its militarist past, it will have no place in the world.”

For Japan’s part, the government has revised school teaching manuals to emphasize its claims over islands disputed with China and South Korea. In his first press conference in January, Katsuto Momii, the Abe-appointed head of national broadcaster NHK, said the military’s wartime use of sex slaves, known as comfort women, shouldn’t be judged by “today’s morality.”

“While it is true that politicians in other East Asian states often play on anti-Japanese sentiments for their own domestic political ends, Japanese public figures provide them with plenty of ammunition,” said Tina Burrett, associate professor of political science at Temple University’s Tokyo campus. “Shinzo Abe’s own frequent use of nationalist rhetoric and insensitive framing of World War II history does not help Japan’s image abroad.”

Yasukuni Visit

Abe drew criticism from the U.S. alongside China and South Korea for his Dec. 26 visit to the Yasukuni shrine in Tokyo, where 14 Class A war criminals are enshrined among other war dead. That visit came weeks after China declared an air defense identification zone over much of the East China Sea covering the islands disputed with Japan. He has also pushed to loosen Japan’s pacifist constitution to allow a strengthening of the military.

“Emotional friction is inevitable if Japan continues acts that appear to justify its past aggression” such as the shrine visit, Lee Won Deog, a professor of Japan studies at Seoul’s Kookmin University, said by phone. “Wouldn’t that make Koreans feel bitter who were forced into the imperial army during World War Two and made to fight alongside Japanese soldiers who vowed to reunite at Yasukuni as souls if they died?”

School Textbooks

South Koreans have been active in taking their campaign abroad. In Virginia the state legislature, lobbied by Korean Americans, passed a measure requiring new school textbooks to note the Sea of Japan is referred to as the East Sea by Korea, the Richmond Times-Dispatch reported. Local officials in Glendale, California and Palisades Park, New Jersey faced protests from Japanese Americans after erecting a statue and a plaque respectively to commemorate Korean comfort women, according to the Glendale News-Press.

Japan’s foreign ministry on Feb. 27 released a video to assert the Sea of Japan as the international name of the waters between Japan and South Korea.

The tensions also pose a bigger problem for the U.S. by creating a wedge between its two biggest allies in the region -- Japan and South Korea -- as it pivots to Asia partly to check China’s growing economic and military muscle.

The U.S. maintains 28,500 troops in South Korea and about 38,000 in Japan, and has framed the two countries as natural partners in the region.

To contact the reporter on this story: Andrew Davis in Hong Kong at abdavis@bloomberg.net

To contact the editor responsible for this story: Rosalind Mathieson at rmathieson3@bloomberg.net

Bloomberg reserves the right to remove comments but is under no obligation to do so, or to explain individual moderation decisions.

Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.