TD’S Clark Sees Canada’s Economy Underperforming U.S.

Toronto-Dominion Bank (TD) Chief Executive Officer Ed Clark said Canada’s economy is in danger of underperforming the U.S. as consumers become increasingly “fragile” amid rising household debt and home prices.

“Canada could well undergrow the United States for the next three or four years, which means we’re going to have lower interest rates for longer,” Clark, 66, said yesterday in an interview at the bank’s Toronto headquarters. “There’s a risk that people are going to keep borrowing.”

Canada’s economy, once the envy of developed countries following the global recession, is struggling to gain momentum as households deal with record debts. Low interest rates pushed the nation’s ratio of debt to disposable income to a record 163.7 percent in the third quarter, according to Statistics Canada, surpassing levels in the U.S.

“We’ve learned around the world that when you make the consumer indebted like that, their ability to withstand shocks is dramatically less,” Clark said. “So the economy as a whole is more accident prone, more fragile.”

Clark, who has run Toronto-Dominion since December 2002, said the situation undermines Canada’s competitiveness, and the country may not be able to “ride up the U.S. growth” as much as in previous times.

“Over time, the consumer becomes more fragile and the Canadian economy becomes less competitive,” he said. “That’s worth worrying about.”

‘Smooth Transition’

Clark, who led the Toronto-based bank in a $25 billion U.S. expansion, will retire in November after a dozen years in the post. He’ll be succeeded by Bharat Masrani, 57, the chief operating officer. Clark, a self-described “old-fashioned banker,” said he’s not going to spend the next few months trying to land another big transaction before departing.

“My job is to make sure there’s a smooth transition,” he said. “What you’re going to get is continuity, but with a new management team -- and in the sense the same management team, but refreshed and elevated.”

Toronto-Dominion gained 20 cents to C$97.20 at 10:42 a.m. trading in Toronto. The stock has risen 16 percent in the past 12 months, outpacing the 9.6 percent return of the eight-company Standard & Poor’s/TSX Commercial Banks index.

Clark joined in 2000 after the lender acquired Canada Trust’s parent CT Financial Services Inc., where he was president and CEO. He led a U.S. consumer-lending expansion that began with a 2004 agreement to buy a 51 percent stake in Portland, Maine-based Banknorth Group Inc. Toronto-Dominion now has more branches in the U.S. than it does in Canada.

Branch Building

The bank probably won’t pursue more U.S. deals for the moment, though it “doesn’t mean we’re anti deals,” Clark said. The premium for buying branches in the U.S. is too high compared with building them, Clark said, adding the lender plans to open 15 more locations in New York City this year. “That’s a better deal than trying to buy those 15 branches.”

It’s also hard to buy U.S. bank assets and earn a worthwhile return for shareholders, Clark said. Still, he would consider another credit-card transaction similar to the firm’s March deal with Target Corp. for $5.7 billion in U.S. balances.

Toronto-Dominion has led Canada’s banks in collectively buying C$20 billion of credit-card assets since 2009. The lender, which bought about half of Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce’s Aerogold Visa card portfolio last year, introduced a rewards card this month with Aeroplan owner Aimia Inc.

“They’re blowing the lights out,” Clark said of the initial response to the card. “It’s really taken us aback.”

Home Prices

While Clark said he remains concerned that rising home prices in Canada are putting pressure on consumers, he doesn’t expect a downturn similar to the U.S. housing bust. Canada’s residential market has outpaced the rate of inflation and wage growth during the past 10 years.

“I’m not worried that there’s a housing bubble that’s going to collapse and bring the economy down, nor am I worried that if there’s a significant fall in prices that TD itself would be directly hurt,” Clark said.

Toronto-Dominion is benefiting from the weakening Canadian currency. The loonie fell to its lowest level in 4 1/2 years against the U.S. dollar on Jan. 22 after the Bank of Canada kept its benchmark interest rate unchanged.

“In a short-run sense we’re a direct winner because we have significant U.S. dollar earnings and they’re getting revalued in Canadian dollars,” Clark said.

The weakening Canadian dollar is “probably net a good thing for Canada” he said. “Some recalibration was clearly necessary.”

To contact the reporter on this story: Doug Alexander in Toronto at dalexander3@bloomberg.net

To contact the editors responsible for this story: David Scanlan at dscanlan@bloomberg.net; Peter Eichenbaum at peichenbaum@bloomberg.net

Press spacebar to pause and continue. Press esc to stop.

Bloomberg reserves the right to remove comments but is under no obligation to do so, or to explain individual moderation decisions.

Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.