Germany Seeks Spy Probe as Spain Protests U.S. Tapping
German lawmakers called for an investigation of American spy activity and Spain condemned phone taps as the U.S. denied President Barack Obama knew about the hacking of Chancellor Angela Merkel’s mobile phone in 2010.
A parliamentary investigation is “unavoidable,” Social Democratic General Secretary Andrea Nahles told Germany’s Bild newspaper as German intelligence officials headed to Washington to discuss the issue. The Spanish Foreign Ministry called U.S. eavesdropping reported today by El Mundo newspaper “inappropriate and unacceptable.”
“I’m astounded at the scale, or rather the extravagance, of this surveillance,” Friedrich Merz, chairman of the Atlantik-Bruecke group that fosters German-U.S. ties and former caucus leader for Merkel’s Christian Democrats in parliament, told Deutschlandfunk radio today. “The Americans should understand better what kind of breach of trust has occurred with its most important ally on this side of the Atlantic.”
The fallout since Merkel spoke with Obama to protest National Security Agency eavesdropping led to recriminations between allies and calls to suspend U.S.-European Union trade talks. Merkel reacted to an internal probe showing that her mobile phone could have come under U.S. surveillance.
Spain’s Foreign Ministry summoned U.S. Ambassador James Costos to respond to a report that the NSA monitored millions of phone calls by Spaniards, according to an e-mailed statement. The NSA’s work helps protect U.S. allies and their interests, as well as U.S. citizens, Costos said.
“The U.S. and Spain have enjoyed a long friendship based on our shared values and a history of cooperating to advance mutual interests around the globe,” Costos said in a separate statement. “We will continue to work closely with Spain on a wide range of issues, including the collective security of our two countries and of U.S. and Spanish citizens.”
Obama’s spokesman, Jay Carney, refused to comment on any details of U.S. surveillance programs or what other leaders may have been targets of NSA snooping. With a trans-Atlantic trade pact high on Obama’s agenda, Carney said the U.S. doesn’t engage in such surveillance to advance American economic interests.
“We do not use our intelligence capabilities for that purpose,” he said today in Washington. “We use it for security purposes.”
Senator Dianne Feinstein, chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee, said today her panel will conduct an investigation into all intelligence collection programs.
“It is clear to me that certain surveillance activities have been in effect for more than a decade and that the Senate Intelligence Committee was not satisfactorily informed,” Feinstein said in a statement.
She said the president should be required to approve “any collection” of “phone calls or e-mails of friendly presidents and prime ministers.” She said “it is my understanding that President Obama was not aware Chancellor Merkel’s communications were being collected since 2002. That is a big problem.”
German authorities are in the process of clarifying the circumstances of the possible surveillance of Merkel’s phone, government spokesman Steffen Seibert told reporters today.
“If this information is confirmed, then this would represent a grave breach of trust,” Seibert said. Still, “where trust has been lost, it has to be restored.”
A group of high-level German intelligence officials is traveling to Washington to discuss the matter, he said.
The Obama administration denied a Bild report over the weekend that the president had been informed by NSA Director Keith Alexander about tapping Merkel’s phone three years ago and allowed the operation to continue. Bild cited an unidentified high-level official within the NSA.
“General Alexander did not discuss with President Obama in 2010 an alleged foreign intelligence operation involving German Chancellor Merkel, nor has he ever discussed alleged operations involving Chancellor Merkel,” the NSA said in a statement distributed by the White House. “News reports claiming otherwise are not true.”
Obama told Merkel he was unaware of the surveillance as he apologized to the chancellor in their Oct. 23 conversation, Der Spiegel magazine reported, citing unidentified chancellery officials.
U.S. authorities obtained Merkel’s mobile number in 2002, Spiegel reported, citing documents including those disclosed by former government contractor Edward Snowden. The surveillance was carried out by an NSA “Special Collection Service” from within the U.S. Embassy adjacent to Berlin’s Brandenburg Gate, Spiegel cited the documents as showing.
The NSA shut down the Merkel operation and others targeting world leaders after the administration conducted a probe over the summer, the Wall Street Journal reported, citing unnamed U.S. officials. Obama had been briefed on “intelligence priorities,” though not specific operations, the Journal said.
Carney refused to comment directly on the report.
The SPD’s Nahles said that Snowden, the source of the surveillance disclosures who is in temporary asylum in Russia, could be called on to give testimony to a probe by the Bundestag, parliament’s lower house, according to Bild. The SPD is currently negotiating to form a coalition government with Merkel’s Christian Democratic bloc.
Some U.S. lawmakers said the U.S. is justified in conducting a sweeping spying program.
Obama should “stop apologizing” for NSA surveillance that has “saved thousands of lives,” Republican Representative Peter King of New York said yesterday on NBC’s “Meet the Press” program.
To contact the reporter on this story: Patrick Donahue in Berlin at firstname.lastname@example.org
To contact the editor responsible for this story: James Hertling at email@example.com
Bloomberg reserves the right to edit or remove comments but is under no obligation to do so, or to explain individual moderation decisions.