Putin Builds North Korea Rail to Circumvent Suez Canal

Photographer: Ivan Shapovalov/Russian Railways via Bloomberg

A train operated by OAO Russian Railways arrives for the opening ceremony of a reconstructed rail link between Khasan station in Russia to Rajin Port in North Korea, on Sunday, Sept. 22, 2013. Close

A train operated by OAO Russian Railways arrives for the opening ceremony of a... Read More

Close
Open
Photographer: Ivan Shapovalov/Russian Railways via Bloomberg

A train operated by OAO Russian Railways arrives for the opening ceremony of a reconstructed rail link between Khasan station in Russia to Rajin Port in North Korea, on Sunday, Sept. 22, 2013.

Vladimir Putin is inching closer to his goal of turning Russia into a major transit route for trade between eastern Asia and Europe by prying open North Korea, a nuclear-capable dictatorship isolated for half a century.

Russia last month completed the first land link that North Korea’s Stalinist regime has allowed to the outside world since 2003. Running between Khasan in Russia’s southeastern corner and North Korea’s rebuilt port of Rajin, the 54-kilometer rail link is part of a project President Putin is pushing that would reunite the railway systems of the two Koreas and tie them to the Trans-Siberian Railway.

That would give Putin partial control over links to European train networks 8,000 kilometers (5,000 miles) away. The route is as much as three times faster than shipping via Egypt’s Suez Canal, which handles 17,000 ships a year, accounts for about 8 percent of maritime trade -- and is increasingly beset by pirates and political instability in Egypt and Syria.

“Shipping companies face higher costs to secure their cargo,” said Thomas Straubhaar, director of the Hamburg Institute of International Economics, in an e-mailed response to questions. “The rail route will get attractive if Russia increases efforts to ensure a secure and reliable transport on the long stretch between Asia and Europe. Customers don’t want their Porsche to be stolen along the way.”

Photographer: Ivan Shapovalov/Russian Railways via Bloomberg

A train operated by OAO Russian Railways, arrives for the opening ceremony of a reconstructed rail link between Khasan station in Russia to Rajin Port in North Korea in this handout photo taken on Sunday, Sept. 22, 2013, and released to the media on Tuesday, Oct. 15, 2013. Close

A train operated by OAO Russian Railways, arrives for the opening ceremony of a... Read More

Close
Open
Photographer: Ivan Shapovalov/Russian Railways via Bloomberg

A train operated by OAO Russian Railways, arrives for the opening ceremony of a reconstructed rail link between Khasan station in Russia to Rajin Port in North Korea in this handout photo taken on Sunday, Sept. 22, 2013, and released to the media on Tuesday, Oct. 15, 2013.

OAO Mechel (MTLR), Russia’s biggest supplier of steel-making coal, will be among the customers in the first stage of the North Korea project, sending shipments eastward to Asian consumers, according to Moscow-based Russian Railways. The Rajin facility also can be refitted to move Asian goods westward to Europe. Mechel’s press service in Moscow declined to comment.

Faster by Rail

Shipments to and from western Europe and Rajin will be delivered in just 14 days, compared with 45 days by ship, OAO Russian Railways Chief Executive Officer Vladimir Yakunin told reporters in North Korea Sept. 22.

Getting the two Koreas to work together on the railway and a long-stalled plan to build a pipeline to supply both Koreas with Russian natural gas is fraught with financial and political hurdles, said Fyodor Lukyanov, head of the Council on Foreign and Defense Policy research group in Moscow. They stem from North Korea’s nuclear weapons program and lingering animosity from the 1950-1953 Korean War.

“Russia’s position is to get North Korea involved in profitable projects to make them realize that cooperation is better than isolation,” Lukyanov said by phone from the Russian capital.

Photographer: Ivan Shapovalov/Russian Railways via Bloomberg

OAO Russian Railways Chief Executive Officer Vladimir Yakunin told reporters in North Korea Sept. 22, shipments to and from western Europe and Rajin will be delivered in just 14 days, compared with 45 by ship. Close

OAO Russian Railways Chief Executive Officer Vladimir Yakunin told reporters in North... Read More

Close
Open
Photographer: Ivan Shapovalov/Russian Railways via Bloomberg

OAO Russian Railways Chief Executive Officer Vladimir Yakunin told reporters in North Korea Sept. 22, shipments to and from western Europe and Rajin will be delivered in just 14 days, compared with 45 by ship.

Nuclear Developments

North Korea is under United Nations sanctions for its atomic program. Six-nation talks that were designed to remove nuclear weapons from the peninsula were abandoned in 2009, when it detonated another device. The Koreas are technically still at war, having ended their military conflict with an armistice rather than a formal peace treaty. In 2003, the two countries opened a highway through their demilitarized zone, one of the most heavily armed borders in the world.

“The Korean project is strategically important for Russian Railways,” said Igor Golubev, an analyst at OAO Promsvyazbank in Moscow. “But it shouldn’t expect fast returns on its investment because at this point I doubt global companies are willing to risk sending cargo via North Korea.”

While Russian Railways says time savings will make up for the higher costs compared with the Suez route, the services train operators already run between China and Europe are too costly, said Michael Tasto, an economist at the German Institute of Shipping Economics and Logistics. They thus lack the capacity to take major market share from container-shipping companies such as A.P. Moeller-Maersk A/S. (MAERSKB)

Niche Product?

“The rail route is faster but more expensive, so it will probably become a niche product,” Tasto said by phone Oct. 7. “Cargo trains are not mass-transportation vehicles like container ships.”

None of that has stopped Russian Railways and its partners in the European Union and China from developing new links between the world’s two largest exporters, touting the routes as alternatives far removed from the political instability in Egypt and the wider Middle East.

Far East Land Bridge, a Russian Railways venture, opened a new service between Suzhou in eastern China and Warsaw on Sept. 30. The first shipment, of “electronic and technology items,” will make the 7,600-kilometer journey in 14 days, linking with the Trans-Siberian via Mongolia and reaching Poland through Belarus, the Vienna-based company said in a statement Oct. 7.

Direct Link

Russian Railways and its counterparts in China and Germany in August introduced a direct link between Hamburg and Zhengzhou in north-central China that takes as little as 15 days and travels through Kazakhstan, Russia, Belarus and Poland.

“Our goal is a daily service,” Ruediger Grube, CEO of Deutsche Bahn AG, said after 51 shipping containers of goods from China arrived in Hamburg by train Aug. 2.

The Russian and German rail operators opened an 11,000-kilometer service between Chongqing in southwest China and the German transport hub of Duisburg via Kazakhstan, Russia, Belarus and Poland in 2011. The travel time varies from 16 days to 23 days, according DB Schenker, Deutsche Bahn’s cargo unit.

Major customers include Bayerische Motoren Werke AG, which ships auto parts west to factories in China, and Hewlett-Packard Co. (HP), which transports computers the other way.

While the Chongqing line is focused on shipments between Europe and China, the Korean link caters to traffic between Europe and the rest of eastern Asia, Russian Railways said. China, Japan and South Korea together account for about a quarter of the global economy.

Korean Support

Putin has urged South Korean President Park Geun Hye, who assumed office in February, to work with North Korea on relinking their rail networks, most recently last month at the Group of 20 summit in St. Petersburg. Park publicly affirmed her commitment to reunifying the Trans-Korean when she met with officials in Busan, South Korea’s largest port, in July.

Putin plans to make his third state visit to Seoul for talks with Park in mid-November, Chosun Ilbo reported Oct. 1, without saying where it got the information. Dmitry Peskov, Putin’s spokesman, declined to comment on the report.

North and South Korea resumed cross-border rail service in 2007 for the first time in 56 years amid a mood of detente, though North Korea closed it down after 18 months and hasn’t reopened it since.

“I have personally dreamed of a railway that starts at Busan and reaches Europe via Russia,” Park told Putin at the summit, according to the website of her presidential Blue House office. “It is an important agenda item for the new government to strengthen Eurasia cooperation.”

To contact the reporters on this story: Ekaterina Shatalova in Moscow at eshatalova@bloomberg.net; Nicholas Brautlecht in Hamburg at nbrautlecht@bloomberg.net

To contact the editor responsible for this story: Denis Maternovsky at dmaternovsky@bloomberg.net

Bloomberg reserves the right to remove comments but is under no obligation to do so, or to explain individual moderation decisions.

Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.