Arizona’s Republican Governor Jan Brewer has been known nationally as one of the most outspoken foes of President Barack Obama -- a Fox News regular, border hawk and states’ rights advocate who once wagged her finger in the chief executive’s face on a Phoenix-area tarmac.
Now, Brewer, 68, is being called a traitor by members of her own party and heralded by advocates for the poor as she digs in for one of the toughest fights of her political career: expanding her state’s Medicaid program under Obama’s Affordable Care Act.
The proposal, which passed the Senate in an amendment to a budget bill last week and faces an uncertain future in the House, has pitted Brewer against Republican legislative leaders and given new relevance to the state’s beleaguered Democrats. It’s made for an unlikely alliance with advocates who vilified the governor in recent years for deep cuts that froze health coverage for children and temporarily cut off some lifesaving organ transplants for Medicaid patients.
“I think the governor has a little bit of a moral streak in her,” said Tim Schmaltz, coordinator of the Protecting Arizona’s Family Coalition, in the Senate lobby last week as lawmakers debated the proposal on the floor.
He ticked off past battles with Brewer. “All of that was really bad,” he said and laughed. “We’re just very grateful, frankly, that the governor had a conversion of heart, both economically and morally.”
The U.S. Supreme Court’s decision last year declaring the federal Affordable Care Act constitutional set the stage for state-by-state battles over Obama’s signature legislative accomplishment. The high court made Medicaid expansion, key to the law’s goal of expanding health coverage to at least 30 million more Americans, optional for states. Twenty states so far are opposing the enlargement of the joint federal-state health program to cover residents with incomes up to $32,500 for a family of four, as called for in the law, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation, a nonprofit health-research group based in Menlo Park, California.
That includes Texas, the second-most populous U.S. state, where 24 percent of residents are uninsured, the highest proportion in the country, according to Kaiser. Republican Governor Rick Perry, who was heckled by Medicaid proponents at luncheon this week, compared expanding the program to putting more people on a sinking Titanic in remarks earlier this month.
“Medicaid expansion, simply put, is just misguided,” Perry said in a May 3 speech in Dallas. “It is ultimately a doomed attempt to mask the shortcomings of Obamacare.”
Brewer’s contrary stance on Medicaid “is about choosing pragmatism over ideology,” said Matthew Benson, a spokesman for the governor.
“This was both a financial decision and a moral decision,” Benson said, citing the return of billions of Arizona tax dollars to the state and the ability to maintain and expand existing Medicaid coverage.
Other Republican governors who opposed Obama’s health care overhaul have said their states can’t afford to reject the federal Medicaid money, which will cover the entire cost of expansion initially, falling to 90 percent in 2022. At least eight of the nation’s 30 Republican governors have backed Medicaid expansion, including New Jersey Governor Chris Christie. Of those who, like Brewer, have legislatures also controlled by their party, only North Dakota Governor Jack Dalrymple succeeded in getting it past lawmakers so far.
Ohio Governor John Kasich, a first-term Republican, tried to get Medicaid expansion passed as part of the state’s two-year budget bill. The Republican-controlled House removed it from the measure last month.
Kasich has said he hasn’t given up on legislative approval. If that fails, his administration is negotiating with federal authorities to develop an alternative plan that would allow it to use Medicaid dollars to help poor residents buy private health coverage. Advocates for the poor and mentally ill have also proposed a statewide ballot issue for expansion.
“I’m for whatever it takes to get this done because I think it’s important for our state,” Kasich told reporters in Columbus on May 7.
In Florida, Governor Rick Scott’s pitch to expand Medicaid was rejected by legislative committees in both the House and the Senate in March; lawmakers adjourned May 3 without passing an alternative plan.
The defeat was a setback for Scott, who started his political career by financing a Tea Party group that opposed Obama’s health law, and faces re-election next year. His support for Medicaid upset Tea Partyers and didn’t move his 36 percent approval rating, according to a March 20 poll from Quinnipiac University in Hamden, Connecticut.
Florida Democrats, including U.S. Senator Bill Nelson, have asked Scott to force lawmakers back to the capital to address the issue. Scott told reporters on May 3 that the legislature “made their decision” on Medicaid.
Brewer, like Scott and Kasich, was no fan of the president’s health law. Arizona was among the 26 Republican-controlled states that sued to stop it. She also declined to create a state health exchange, joining 26 other states that are ceding control to the federal government.
Her announcement supporting Medicaid expansion in her January State of the State address surprised the political establishment and kicked off a war with Republican legislative leaders and party officials.
The head of the Republican Party in Maricopa County, which includes Phoenix, compared Brewer to Judas in remarks to the legislature. Republican lawmakers, who helped her pass the strictest immigration law in the nation in 2010, are publicly questioning her conservative stripes.
“All of us Republicans have spent the last five years bashing Obamacare -- now some us have done 180s on it,” Representative John Kavanagh, a Republican who chairs the House appropriations committee, complained in the Capitol courtyard last week. Like other opponents, Kavanagh, who has threatened to block Medicaid expansion in his committee, cited his concern about the federal deficit and opposition to the health law.
While state lawmakers may want to stand on principle against the law, the reality is that states need the money that expansion brings -- as do hospitals and other health-care providers, powerful interest groups for whom Medicaid is “lifeblood,” said Julian Zelizer, a political historian at Princeton University in New Jersey.
Brewer “became a symbol for many of a Tea Party Republican, who was not willing to be flexible, who was going to stand up for red states,” Zelizer said. “This kind of position challenges that and suggests she may be more politically pragmatic than she appeared to be.”
Expanding Medicaid will provide health coverage to about 300,000 more residents and bring about $1.6 billion of federal funds to the state each year, Brewer’s office said. Brewer has proposed to pay for the increase in state costs through a provider tax on hospitals, which otherwise face mounting costs as the federal government scales back reimbursement for uncompensated care.
The standoff with lawmakers brought legislative progress in Phoenix to a halt, keeping legislators in session past the deadline when their per diem pay is automatically reduced. Yesterday, Brewer vetoed five unrelated measures saying that she wouldn’t sign any bills until progress was made on Medicaid.
Last week, five Republicans teamed with Democrats to amend the Senate president’s budget plan to include Brewer’s Medicaid proposal. It awaits action in the House, where the Speaker has proposed leaving the decision up to voters.
Last week, in the largest of four rallies Brewer has hosted at the Capitol to promote her plan, more than 1,000 supporters gathered on the Senate lawn. Brewer shared the stage with a local talk-radio personality, a hemophiliac who said he needed Medicaid to live, an emergency room doctor and others. The audience chanted, “It’s the right thing to do!” as opponents on the periphery heckled them and held signs deriding socialism, death panels and “Obrewercare.”
Brewer vowed not to give up, saying she had mathematics and morality on her side. She called Medicaid expansion the “most important health issue that our state has faced in a decade.”
“I knew it wouldn’t be easy,” she told the crowd. “But let me tell you something else, I don’t think the opponents realized how hard we are going to fight.”
To contact the reporter on this story: Amanda J. Crawford in Phoenix at firstname.lastname@example.org
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Jeffrey Taylor at email@example.com