European Aeronautic, Defence & Space Co. (EAD) Chief Executive Officer Tom Enders struggled to quell skepticism from German lawmakers about his merger plan with BAE Systems Plc (BA/) that would clip government say in the new group.
Enders, appearing before a parliamentary hearing in Berlin, laid out the proposed combination in a closed meeting that lasted about 1 1/2 hours. The executive wasn’t clear on the benefits of the merger and “contradictory” on what should be done with special shares for governments, Kerstin Andreae, a Green Party lawmaker and deputy head of the Economic Affairs Committee in parliament, said after the hearing.
EADS needs to convince governments to back a combination that would diminish their future role, as Enders seeks to build a company unrestrained from political meddling. German Deputy Economy Minister Hans-Joachim Otto told the committee that it’s “not just a question of how but whether” the merger should take place, underscoring the political resistance to the plan.
“We want to create a company that is even more successful internationally and attracts investors,” Enders said after the meeting. “There are lots of examples in this industry of companies that don’t have to be influenced by politics.”
There will be no backing of the merger from Germany without additional clarification, Otto said, who acknowledged that too much political influence has harmed EADS and that a merger would give management more room to maneuver. Still, questions remain regarding the plan, including the valuation of the companies in the merged entity, he said after the hearing.
Some German lawmakers have questioned a ratio that would give EADS 60 percent of the future company and BAE the rest, saying it doesn’t adequately reflect the value of either company. EADS is more than twice as large as BAE by revenue.
Enders dismissed the criticism over the valuation, saying the ratio wasn’t “simply hatched over a beer” and that it was carefully composed in concert with advisers. He said he had a “good discussion” with lawmakers in the meeting and that Toulouse, France-based EADS is ready anytime to follow up with the government and explain the merger rationale.
EADS and BAE announced on Sept. 12 that they are exploring a combination, which would create the largest aerospace and defense company in the world, with a market value of $45 billion. Enders would probably retain his role in the enlarged group, while the defense assets would be bundled in the U.K.
Unlike France, which owns 15 percent of EADS, Germany holds no major stake, and the country’s industrial interests are represented by Daimler AG, which controls 22.5 percent of EADS. German politicians have said they’re wary of future job guarantees, proposed synergies, and Germany’s role in the future company, which would have headquarters in France and the U.K.
To contact the reporter on this story: Brian Parkin in Berlin at firstname.lastname@example.org
To contact the editor responsible for this story: James Hertling at email@example.com