Dimon Vows Fight Moynihan Lost Over Claims From Mortgages
Stock Chart for JPMorgan Chase & Co (JPM)
Investors demanding that the biggest U.S. lender buy back soured loans or compensate them for losses on mortgage securities “face a long and difficult road,” Dimon said last week in a shareholder letter. Those lining up include holders of $95 billion of bonds represented by Gibbs & Bruns LLP, the law firm that won $8.5 billion last year from Bank of America Corp. (BAC)
“We are going to fight repurchase claims that pretend the steep decline in home prices and unprecedented market conditions had no impact on loan performance,” Dimon, chief executive officer of the New York-based lender, wrote in the April 4 letter. He’ll also oppose “securities claims brought by sophisticated investors who understood and accepted the risks.”
Dimon, who updates investors on his firm’s mortgage losses tomorrow, is seeking to contain expenses from faulty loans that have cost the industry more than $72 billion. Similar combative language didn’t work for Bank of America CEOBrian T. Moynihan, who said in 2010 the firm will engage in “hand-to-hand combat” to fend off demands before agreeing to a string of settlements.
“They were in the same businesses as everyone else,” Mark Williams, a former Federal Reserve bank examiner who teaches finance at Boston University, said of JPMorgan. “If everyone around them is basically settling, it’s hard for me to think that there’s not something there that will make them settle.”
JPMorgan had a $3.6 billion liability for repurchases at the end of last year, the firm said in January. Losses of as much as $2 billion beyond that are “reasonably possible,” and the firm expects repurchase costs of $350 million per quarter, according to a January presentation. Lenders can be forced to repurchase a loan, called a putback, if data backing it including borrower income or home values proves incorrect.
The bank may have as much as $9.7 billion in further liability for loan buybacks, with about half tied to the acquisition of assets of Washington Mutual Inc. after it failed in 2008, said Pri de Silva, a senior analyst at New York-based CreditSights Inc. The Washington Mutual costs may ultimately be borne by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., he said.
JPMorgan has braced investors for the possibility of greater losses, saying that legal costs could exceed reserves by as much as $5.1 billion. Amy Bonitatibus, a spokeswoman for JPMorgan, declined to comment beyond Dimon’s remarks. Rick Simon of Bank of America also declined to comment.
Dimon, 56, acknowledged in the letter that the firm made “too many mistakes” in mortgages, including by originating loans with poorer underwriting standards and being unprepared for a surge in foreclosures. The industry’s $25 billion settlement in February ends claims tied to servicing, he said.
The firm has hired “top lawyers” to help defend itself against rising claims, Dimon said in December. The company was a target in suits tied to $54 billion in private label securities at the time, which involve firms other than U.S.-owned Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, a figure Dimon said would rise.
“Jamie probably doesn’t want to provide incentive for mortgage investors to come after the bank for more money,” said de Silva. “There’s also an advantage in paying tomorrow as opposed to today regarding when they have to take the reserve.”
JPMorgan may be in a better position than Bank of America was to resist settlement demands. Dimon’s bank earned a record $19 billion in profit in 2011, compared with $1.4 billion at Charlotte, North Carolina-based Bank of America. Plagued by concern that mortgage losses would force it to raise capital, Bank of America’s shares sunk 58 percent last year, compared with the 22 percent decline of JPMorgan.
Moynihan even briefly weighed limiting payouts with a bankruptcy filing for Countrywide Financial Corp., the unit acquired in 2008 and the firm’s biggest source of losses. Most of JPMorgan’s loan problems were inherited from the Bear Stearns & Co. and Washington Mutual takeovers, Dimon has said.
In December, Houston-based Gibbs & Bruns said it had asked trustees of $95 billion in bonds to investigate whether JPMorgan included ineligible loans in the securities. Kathy Patrick, a Gibbs & Bruns partner, didn’t return messages seeking comment.
Other firms that bought or insured mortgage securities have since filed lawsuits against the lender. Asset Management Fund, based in Chicago, sued in February over claims the bank gave faulty information involving $515.6 million in bonds. In March, DZ Bank AG, Germany’s largest cooperative lender, claimed it had about $400 million in damages over similar allegations.
That month, Ambac Assurance Corp. sued JPMorgan, accusing the company’s EMC Mortgage and Bear Stearns units of fraud and breach of contract over the sale of mortgage securities. The bond insurer said that it had to pay more than $200 million in claims because of the failed investments.
BofA Buybacks Ebbing
Dimon’s comments come as some analysts say that Moynihan’s woes from mortgage buybacks may be ebbing.
Recent favorable court decisions increase the likelihood of approval of the lender’s $8.5 billion settlement, CreditSights analysts de Silva and David Hendler wrote last week in a note. That would resolve about 60 percent of private label loans created by Countrywide from 2004 to 2008.
Remaining costs should be manageable, the analysts wrote in the April 3 note. The biggest expense left is about $8 billion a year from servicing troubled mortgages, according to CreditSights. Bank of America had a $15.9 billion liability for repurchase claims as of Dec. 31 and legal losses could reach $3.6 billion beyond reserves, the firm said. Bank of America shares have surged more than 50 percent this year amid signs the U.S. economic recovery is strengthening.
Moynihan, 52, has spent his first two years as CEO atoning for his predecessor’s purchase of Countrywide, once the biggest mortgage company and one that was blamed by lawmakers for irresponsible lending that fueled the crisis.
Less than two months after saying in November 2010 that the bank is waging “hand-to-hand combat” over repurchase demands, Moynihan agreed to a $3 billion deal settling some claims with government-owned firms Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. That accord was followed in April 2011 by one valued at $1.6 billion with bond insurer Assured Guaranty Ltd. (AGO)
In June 2011, Moynihan agreed to the $8.5 billion deal resolving claims from investors including BlackRock Inc. (BLK) and Pacific Investment Management Co. If approved by a court, the pact resolves claims tied to $424 billion of bonds. That month, the firm also set aside $5.5 billion for other demands.
The CEO said at the time that settling with investors was preferable because it avoids the “possible outcome being much more adverse to the company if we kept fighting.”
Moynihan’s truce with mortgage buyers didn’t last. Fannie Mae, seeking to limit the cost of its U.S. taxpayer bailout, stepped up demands last year, saying that the lender must repurchase loans if an insurer drops coverage. Bank of America refused, and in January Fannie cut the company off as a partner for the funding of new loans.
-- Editors: Pierre Paulden, Rick Green
To contact the reporter on this story: Hugh Son in New York at email@example.com
Bloomberg reserves the right to edit or remove comments but is under no obligation to do so, or to explain individual moderation decisions.