Nokia U.S. Future at Risk as AT&T Sales Seen Below Millio
Nokia Oyj (NOK) is seeking to revive its U.S. business with a smartphone release this weekend that may determine the company’s future. Initial sales will probably trail competitors’ recent debuts, hurting the company’s chances.
Nokia’s flagship Lumia 900 that runs Microsoft Corp. (MSFT)’s Windows Phone software will start selling through AT&T Inc. (T), the second-largest U.S. wireless carrier, on April 8. Sales in the first three months of availability may reach hundreds of thousands, rather than millions like for the market-leading iPhone, according to Deutsche Bank AG and Avian Securities LLC.
“It’s going to be an uphill fight,” said Matthew Thornton, an analyst at Avian in Boston. “The Nokia brand, while I think it’s still known here, lags Apple and even Samsung. I don’t see the phone becoming a hit.”
The price has been set at half that of the iPhone as Nokia is trying to rekindle sales in a market that drives smartphone innovation and global consumer trends. The Espoo, Finland-based company losing its mobile-phone leadership in the U.S. years ago foreshadowed eroding sales in Europe and Asia too as consumers worldwide followed U.S. users in adopting Apple Inc. (AAPL)’s iPhone and phones running Google Inc. (GOOG)’s Android software.
“This launch will set the tone for Nokia’s recovery,” said Alex Spektor, an analyst at Strategy Analytics in Newton, Massachusetts. “The U.S., since the rise of the iPhone, has become the most important market for mobile devices so success here is important for any vendor who wants to succeed on a global scale.”
Nokia, once the world’s biggest smartphone maker, has lost more than 80 percent, or $80 billion, of its market value since the iPhone’s 2007 release. The stock has slid 51 percent since Chief Executive Officer Stephen Elop started in 2010. The shares rose 0.9 percent to 3.88 euros as of 10:11 a.m. in Helsinki.
While Nokia and AT&T declined to give specific targets for the device, quarterly sales at below one million would likely disappoint them given Nokia’s typical volumes in other markets, according to John Jackson, an analyst at CCS Insight in Boston.
“It’ll have to be a number that starts with an ‘m,’” Jackson said. “Nokia doesn’t tend to get out of bed for any less than several million in the course of a year.”
Elop has said Nokia needs a revival in the U.S. as part of its turnaround plan. The debut at AT&T may be Nokia’s best chance to win back U.S. customers because new models from Apple and BlackBerry maker Research In Motion Ltd. (RIMM) aren’t expected before the second half.
IPhone, Android Debuts
“It’s critical for them to get this phone in people’s hands,” said Roger Entner, an analyst at Recon Analytics in Dedham, Massachusetts. “The timing is good, there’s no other major phone entering the market right now. The iPhone 5 is still months away.”
Citing muted consumer demand for Windows Phone and intense competition, Deutsche Bank’s Kai Korschelt estimates that Nokia could sell 680,000 Lumias a quarter at AT&T. If consumers show little interest and AT&T cuts back its support, sales could be as small as 140,000 a quarter, the analyst said in a March 30 research note.
Avian’s Thornton, who rates Nokia shares neutral, estimates that the company will sell 370,000 Lumia 900s this quarter. That would be about 5 percent of AT&T’s smartphone sales, he said.
In the fourth quarter, AT&T activated 7.6 million iPhones after introducing the latest version in October. Apple sold more than 4 million units of the new model in its first weekend alone, though it was released in other countries in addition to the U.S. Samsung Electronics Co. (005930), the biggest manufacturer of Android phones, sold 5 million Galaxy Note phones worldwide in the first five months after its debut.
Banking on Windows
The Lumia’s aggressive price and marketing spending may mean Nokia and Microsoft won’t make any profit with the device, and that may not be their focus, Thornton said. It’s crucial for the phone to become a hit to give carriers a reason to offer Nokia’s future Windows Phone devices, he said.
“If it flops, AT&T is going to have very little incentive to push this again when they come out with the next product,” Thornton said.
Nokia’s strategy is risky because while it can support its smartphone business with the money it makes from cheaper phones, its financial performance as a whole has deteriorated.
Plunging smartphone demand has driven Nokia’s revenue to below 2006 levels and the company’s loss exceeded $1 billion last year. Standard and Poor’s cut Nokia’s rating to one level above junk last month and signaled it may reduce it further.
To fight Apple and Google, Elop sidelined Nokia’s own operating systems and rebuilt a smartphone business using Windows Phone. His plan is to differentiate Nokia from rivals in markets such as the U.S., where the iPhone, Android and BlackBerry control 94 percent of sales.
As part of the debut, the Lumia 900 is being supplied free to the sales staff at AT&T stores in a bid to persuade them to recommend it to shoppers. The phone costs $99.99 with a two-year AT&T contract and $449.99 without one.
Windows Phone, unveiled in 2010, has so far won a niche following. At the end of 2011, it ranked sixth with 1.9 percent of the global market, down from 5th place and 3.4 percent of the market at the end of 2010, according to researcher Gartner Inc.
“Windows Phone is the best operating system that no one is using,” Entner said.
The software is attractive, yet the Lumia 900 has drawbacks including a Web browser that stalled frequently, a battery that drained in less than a day in heavier use and a camera that took worse photos than the iPhone, Walt Mossberg, the technology columnist for the Wall Street Journal, said in his review. Rich Jaroslovsky, the technology columnist for Bloomberg, called the device “a very good phone and an even better value,” citing its user-friendly interface, video-chat function and camera quality.
The Lumia 900 is the first Nokia device to run on so-called long-term evolution, or LTE, networks that allow faster data speeds. The first models in the Lumia line were introduced already last year and have sold “well over 1 million” units, Nokia said in January.
Still, Nokia and AT&T executives still say they don’t put a lot of emphasis on Lumia’s sales numbers right out of the gate.
Chris Weber, Nokia’s U.S. sales chief, said the important number he will look for is the Lumia’s net promotion score. That is the tally from a one-question survey asking users how likely they are to recommend the device to a friend or colleague, on a scale of 1 to 10. Low scores are subtracted from high scores to give a numerical rating, which Nokia hasn’t revealed.
“How many we sell on the first weekend may not be the most important metric for us,” said Jeff Bradley, AT&T senior vice president of devices. “We want to see slow, steady growth.”
Bloomberg moderates all comments. Comments that are abusive or off-topic will not be posted to the site. Excessively long comments may be moderated as well. Bloomberg cannot facilitate requests to remove comments or explain individual moderation decisions.