Class War on Janitors Raises Deficit Fever: Margaret Carlson

A good litmus test of how far right a politician is leaning is the question of President Barack Obama’s place of birth.

Yes, this is still an issue. A recent survey of 400 Republican primary voters nationwide by Public Policy Polling found that 51 percent believed that the president wasn’t born in the U.S.

Here’s what one prominent Republican figure said on the so- called birther issue: “It’s distracting. It gets annoying, and let’s just stick with what really matters.”

A second important Republican, asked to stand up to birther ignorance, responded, “It’s not my job to tell the American people what to think.” And, on the canard Obama is secretly a Muslim: “The president says he’s a Christian. I accept him at his word.” (Taking the president “at his word” is code to Tea Partiers. It means, “He’s a liar but there’s nothing I can do about it.”)

Here’s what’s interesting. The first quote -- the more reasonable, if we’re grading on a curve -- happens to be from Sarah Palin, the person we normally think of as holding the pole position in the Republicans’ daily race to the outer edge of our political galaxy. The latter quotes are from House Speaker John Boehner, on NBC’s “Meet the Press.”

Lapping Palin is one way Boehner can prove himself to his House freshmen. The insider of insiders, boon companion of lobbyists, Boehner smoked, drank and wept his way to his gavel. Now the man who once handed out campaign checks from the tobacco industry on the House floor finds that his old unsubtle ways don’t win quite so many friends.

Closing Yellowstone

It must be a strain on the wily veteran to defer so much to his newbies. They have no patience for history; tourists seeing the Capitol for the first time from the upper deck of a bus probably know more about Washington. Some freshmen seem practically giddy about shutting down the federal government, a budgetary D-Day that looms on March 4. Boehner remembers how that worked out last time, when then-Speaker Newt Gingrich got blamed for closing Yellowstone National Park and furloughing federal workers.

Just the other day Boehner must have swallowed tears as funding for a second engine for the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter -- a project that delivers jobs to his home state of Ohio -- was killed by his deficit hawks.

Pander Problem

Boehner is being pulled in different directions by his freshmen, by the larger Republican Party, and by his own nature. Republicans can’t win the presidency in 2012 by ceaselessly pandering to the Tea Party, a lesson even Palin has absorbed -- as shown by her slight retreat on Obama’s citizenship. To win, Republicans must appeal to moderates and independents, many of whom are partial to clean water and Pell Grants.

Already the cutters have shown Boehner who’s boss. His $35 billion in pledged budget cuts quickly morphed into their $100 billion. Where he would trim, they would slash, even if it means being penny-wise and pound-foolish.

Cut home-heating-oil assistance and you risk sending more people to emergency rooms and seeing homes flooded by burst pipes. Demolish neighborhood block grants and you get more homeless people evicted when because there’s no one to negotiate rent payments with landlords. Cut food inspections and you get more E. coli.

More than Ross Perot, the Tea Party has focused the country on the crazy aunt in the attic, the deficit, so that fighting it trumps concerns over unemployment, failing schools, crumbling infrastructure and health care. As long as the supposedly adult conversation we’re having remains childishly vague, it’s easy to turn those complaining about cuts into welfare queens who should toughen up.

Tax Cuts

Even worse is how some supposed budget hawks, on the eve of battle, made deficits even worse with tax cuts for the haves, then used mounting deficit projections to justify cuts to discretionary program that mostly hurt the have-nots. So much for spreading the pain.

The new austerity-chic is playing out in Wisconsin, where Republican Governor Scott Walker gave tax cuts to businesses while demanding give-backs from public employees. He also wants to strip most public workers of their collective bargaining rights to make sure they don’t ever get their sweet packages again.

Analysts say public pay in Wisconsin is in line with private pay for similar work. State workers have agreed to contribute more for their benefits. Walker, refusing to take yes for an answer, prefers to use the issue as a pretext to cripple organized labor.

Class Warfare

What an odd chapter in American history we’re living through. Suggesting that the financial elite might be responsible for the economic mess we’re in brings cries of “class warfare.” Meanwhile, congressmen and governors, under cover of cutting deficits created by congressmen and governors, wage real class warfare on janitors and on parents trying to pay their mortgage or send their kids to college.

Blaming nurse’s aides and prison guards for the death grip this economy has on the middle class is to indulge a fantasy on par with the fairy tale of an American president born in Kenya and secretly Muslim.

Margaret Carlson, author of “Anyone Can Grow Up: How George Bush and I Made It to the White House” and former White House correspondent for Time magazine, is a Bloomberg News columnist. The opinions expressed are her own.)

To contact the writer of this column: Margaret Carlson in Washington at mcarlson3@bloomberg.net

To contact the editor responsible for this column: James Greiff at jgreiff@bloomberg.net

Press spacebar to pause and continue. Press esc to stop.

Bloomberg reserves the right to remove comments but is under no obligation to do so, or to explain individual moderation decisions.

Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.