Google Phone May Add to Network Strain
(Bloomberg) — Google Inc.'s (GOOG) Nexus One phone, a bid to lure customers from Apple Inc. (AAPL), may spur further network capacity crunches for carriers as more people use handsets for Web surfing and video.
The number of smartphones like the iPhone, sold by AT&T Inc. (T) in the U.S., may more than double globally by 2013, according to researcher IDC. Verizon Wireless, the largest U.S. mobile carrier, and T-Mobile USA Inc. both said this week they will offer the Nexus One, which lets users run multiple programs at once and upload high-resolution videos to the Web.
AT&T, which says it has more than twice as many smartphone customers as Verizon, has already faced complaints over dropped calls as iPhone traffic flooded parts of its network. That may spread to other carriers as they add more smartphones, said Craig Moffett, an analyst at Sanford C. Bernstein & Co.
"It's obviously already a problem for AT&T," said Moffett, who's based in New York. "The sand is running out of the hourglass pretty quickly just given the lead time that it takes to make spectrum available."
Dallas-based AT&T and other carriers may have as little as three years to find new airwaves to meet demand as more customers surf on their phones, analysts say. AT&T, which introduced Apple's iPhone in 2007, has seen data traffic increase 5,000 percent in the past three years.
Not Enough?Although U.S. carriers are adding new towers and building out infrastructure to handle the capacity, that won't be enough as smartphone numbers surge, according to Moffett.
The growth may lead carriers to institute more strict usage caps and usage-based pricing, he said. AT&T wireless chief Ralph de la Vega has said AT&T has no immediate plans to institute a so-called tiered pricing model.
AT&T's network doesn't differ that much from Verizon's, other than the data load it has to carry, UBS Securities LLC analyst John Hodulik said. Carriers will have to increase investments in their networks if they want to keep up with the growing popularity of devices like Mountain View, California-based Google's Nexus One, he said. Google spokeswoman Katie Watson declined to comment.
"AT&T continues to invest aggressively in our networks and works relentlessly to make the user experience even better," spokesman Fletcher Cook said in an e-mail. "But spectrum availability is a core industry challenge that will need to be addressed." AT&T trails only Verizon Wireless in mobile subscribers.
AT&T dropped 41 cents to $27.61 in New York Stock Exchange composite trading yesterday. New York-based Verizon Communications Inc. (VZ), which co-owns Verizon Wireless with Vodafone Group Plc, fell 95 cents to $31.92. AT&T slid 1.6 percent last year, compared with a 2.3 percent decline at Verizon. Google dropped $15.73 to $608.26 on the Nasdaq Stock Market.
Poor PerformanceAT&T ranked last in a Consumer Reports survey of the top four U.S. wireless companies last month as subscribers complained about poor voice quality. The carrier has added infrastructure and updated equipment to handle more traffic, logging about $17 billion in capital spending last year, similar to Verizon's amount.
As they add feature-laden devices, Verizon and other carriers will grow more vulnerable to the same traffic surges that plagued AT&T, UBS's Hodulik said. AT&T and Basking Ridge, New Jersey-based Verizon Wireless will have to increase network spending about 10 percent this year to keep up with the traffic, he said. Sprint Nextel Corp., the third-biggest carrier, might have to boost expenditures as much as 20 percent, he estimated. 'Lifeblood'"While we do not have an immediate need for additional spectrum, it is the lifeblood of our network so we can't rule it out for the future," Verizon spokesman Jim Gerace said. Network investments over the past decade will give Verizon an advantage as data traffic grows, he said.
James Fisher, a spokesman for Overland Park, Kansas-based Sprint (S), said the company's investments in newer technology through a partnership with Clearwire Corp. will help the carrier meet higher demands for data.
T-Mobile, the last of the four carriers to roll out a so-called third-generation network, has seen data grow on its network at about the same rate as AT&T, said Mark McDiarmid, a T-Mobile executive in charge of systems engineering.
"This is not a T-Mobile concern or an AT&T concern, it's really an industry concern," McDiarmid said in an interview. "As we've mobilized the Internet and really brought great devices to market, we've seen dramatic increases, too."
Limiting FeaturesWhile carriers can build out their networks to handle the increased traffic, if no new spectrum is found, companies like T-Mobile will have to limit new features, McDiarmid said. Bellevue, Washington-based T-Mobile probably won't need more spectrum for three to five more years, he said.
"We are victims of our own success," said Christopher Guttman-McCabe, a vice president at Washington-based CTIA-The Wireless Association. "The technology, the innovation is just taking off."
That leaves the carriers looking for new ways to handle the burden, like asking the U.S. Federal Communications Commission to make more airwaves available. Adding towers and updating technology only partly solves the problem of congestion on networks, Guttman-McCabe said. Identifying and allocating the new network space may take more than a decade, according to the CTIA, whose members include AT&T and Verizon.
More ProblemsAT&T and Verizon added spectrum in 2008 after the FCC freed up airwaves used by television broadcasters, raising almost $20 billion in the auction. Carriers are asking whether TV companies should relinquish more airwaves, a plan broadcasters oppose.
"You see the struggles AT&T is having with the new demand created by the iPhone, and you project forward not just for one company and one network but for the entire country," said Blair Levin, the FCC official overseeing an initiative to add high-speed Internet capacity in the U.S. "That's a serious potential problem."
The carriers are also investing in newer technology known as long-term evolution to cope with the onslaught. Verizon will start its LTE service this year, and AT&T may follow in 2011.
The upgrades will make the spectrum four times more efficient, leading to faster data speeds and greater capacity, according to the 3rd Generation Partnership Project, a technical association. Still, those gains will likely be outpaced by data traffic without additional spectrum, said Bernstein's Moffett.
"It's going to take more than just better technology," Moffett said. The increase "pales in comparison to the 50-fold increase in data traffic that AT&T has seen in just the past three years."
To contact the reporters on this story: Amy Thomson in New York at email@example.com; Todd Shields in Washington at firstname.lastname@example.org.