? I've been had! |
| Keynote Day ?
January 06, 2006
Will Steve Jobs Become Disney's Chairman? I'm Betting No
I've got a running debate with a BW colleague on one of longest-running rumors in Hollywood: that Disney will buy Pixar, and make Steve Jobs its chairman. And that rumor is red-hot once again, as Disney and Pixar are negotiating an extension of their partnership that was supposedly going to be finalized by the end of 2005. In fact, Pixar shares are up 9% so far in this young year, to $57-plus, on the speculation.
Now, that's more than $300 million of extra pocket change for Jobs, who owns half of Pixar. Not bad for five days' work. But my guess is that Jobs isn't gunning for authority over the Magic Kingdom (It seems John Frost at The Disney Blog agrees with me).
For starters, Jobs has always maintained that he likes Pixar just the way it is: independant. It's located in a beautiful campus in Emeryville, Calif. that he helped design, sequestered far from the exigencies of Hollywood. There's no one to tell Pixar how to run its business--for example, to push it to make more movies each year, even at the expense of sacrificing the quality that's enabled Pixar to crank out an unblemished run of blockbusters. And there's no troubled TV networks or theme parks or live action movie studios to run. From where he sits, as CEO of both Pixar and Apple, he can focus on shaping the future of media--rather than figure out a way out of its messy present.
And then there's the practicalities. Think about it. On this particular day, he's likely negotiating the Disney deal, sheparding Apple's transition to Intel on the Mac and the creation of other new products, cutting video deals to get more content on iTunes, and keeping an eye on an investigation into digital music pricing by New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer, while also preparing for his annual Macworld keynote--which, as this article suggests, is a big job in itself. And heck, he's got enough leverage over Disney as it is to influence its future direction.
Plus, I don't think Jobs is in need of the prestige that would come with presiding over the board of one more of the world's most famous companies. As tempting as that would be for most, Jobs does not strike me as a guy that's particularly interested in prestige of that sort. Other than Apple-related events, he actually doesn't seek out much notoriety--far less than he could, for sure. For example, he spends far less time on the speaking or conference circuit than most CEOs.
Indeed, if this discussion of a Pixar buyout is even being discussed, I'd bet what's happening is this: that Disney is trying to come up with a package Jobs couldn't refuse without doing a disservice to Pixar's other shareholders, to get him to both sell Pixar and join Disney's board.
Personally, I doubt they'll succeed.
TrackBack URL for this entry:
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Will Steve Jobs Become Disney's Chairman? I'm Betting No:
? What if Disney takes a bite of the Apple? from The Disney Blog
In the original, and still the best, Disney Animated Feature 'Snow White', the beautiful Snow White is placed under a sleeping spell at the bite of an enchanted apple. There she lay until awaken by loves first kiss. Is that [Read More]
Tracked on January 7, 2006 11:06 AM
Let me join the probably dozens of others to point out the redundancy in the article. Everybody makes typos, though, so don't worry about it. I really am enjoying all of your articles.. keep up the good work!
Posted by: Jon Sibley at January 6, 2006 05:07 PM
I couldn't agree more, Peter. I'm amazed that this "story" continues to have traction, because anyone floating it has yet to persuasively explain why (a) Jobs would even want that position, or (b) why he would be any good at it. I suppose people are fixated on the media synergies involved with bringing Jobs and Pixar to Disney, but "synergy" as a reason for business deals has been pretty roundly discredited in entertainment, media, and technology in recent years. Jobs's real power at the moment comes from delivery, not content (he's not the content guy at Pixar; John Lasseter is) and that's a position he's be surrendering to take the reins at Disney. I just can't see him trading stewardship of his beloved Apple for -- what, running Disneyworld? He's way too hands-on for a job of that scope, anyway, and I suspect his methods and the Disney culture would clash almost immediately (although the friction would probably be good for Disney, at least). And I agree that money likely is not a motivating factor for him at this point. So if Disney really wants him, the only way I see Steve Jobs going there is if he makes a conscious decision to change himself and his life -- completely. And I don't see him doing that.
Posted by: Mark U. at January 6, 2006 05:28 PM
I agree - while I'm sure that Disney would love to buy Pixar - how secure would you feel with Steve Jobs as your largest shareholder?
Posted by: jbelkin at January 7, 2006 03:51 PM
Sadly... you were very wrong.
Not the chairman, but close...
Posted by: Jay at March 3, 2006 04:52 AM