Johnson & Johnson Settlement Resolves Metal Hip Lawsuits But Weak Oversight Of Medical Device Industry Leaves Hundreds of

Johnson & Johnson Settlement Resolves Metal Hip Lawsuits But Weak Oversight Of
 Medical Device Industry Leaves Hundreds of Thousands of Patients Vulnerable

PR Newswire

TOLEDO, Ohio, Nov. 19, 2013

Consumers Union Calls for Stricter Safety Testing & Warranties for Implants

TOLEDO, Ohio, Nov. 19, 2013 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ --Johnson & Johnson
announced today that it has reached a multi-billion dollar settlement for
victims of the company's flawed all metal hip implant. The problems patients
have experienced with the device demonstrate the need for stricter implant
safety testing and show why medical implant makers should provide warranties
to back their products in the event of failure, according to Consumers Union,
the policy division of Consumer Reports.

"The horrendous injuries suffered by tens of thousands of metal hip implant
patients are a terrible reminder of how current oversight of the medical
device industry fails to protect the public," said Lisa McGiffert, manager of
Consumers Union's Safe Patient Project (
"Patients shouldn't serve as unwitting experimental subjects for medical
implants that haven't been thoroughly tested by industry for safety and
effectiveness. We need to require stricter safety testing of all implants
before they are allowed on the market. And medical device makers should stand
by their products by providing a warranty to patients."

Earlier this year, Consumers Union called on the top manufacturers of hip and
knee implants to provide a 20 year warranty to patients. Consumers Union has
developed standards for a fair warranty that would cover the full cost of
replacing a flawed device, including the device, surgeon and hospital costs as
well as related patient out-of-pocket costs. Under Consumers Union's proposed
warranty, patients would retain the right to sue the manufacturer to recover
other damages.

Consumers Union is pushing device makers to equip patients with warranties to
give them a better understanding of how long an implant is expected to last
and a clear process to follow in the event that it fails prematurely.
Ultimately, warranties will encourage companies to make their devices safer
and more durable, according to Consumers Union.

Most hip and knee implants are allowed on the market without being reviewed
for safety and effectiveness by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).
Instead, under current law, the companies simply have to demonstrate that the
devices are "substantially equivalent" to a product already being sold. Since
most new hip and knee implants are similar to ones already on the market,
manufacturers are able to gain approval through the FDA's fast track 510(k)
clearance process without having to prove the device is safe and effective.

Consumers Union and other patient safety groups urged Congress to require more
pre-market testing of devices like hip and knee implants during last year's
reauthorization of the Medical Device User Fee Act. But those efforts were
blocked by the politically powerful medical device industry.

Over 750,000 Americans got metal on metal hip implants during the past decade,
which were supposed to last longer than devices made with a combination of
ceramic, metal and plastic. But unusually high failure rates have been
documented in metal hip implants in Australia, England, and Wales where
devices are tracked through national registries. The data from these
countries showed that one in eight of the Johnson & Johnson DePuy ASR XL metal
hip implants failed within five years.

Some patients have experienced debilitating symptoms from metal debris that
flakes off the device over time, including cardiomyopathy and neurological
problems. Due to the significant problems experienced with metal on metal
hip implants, the FDA has proposed that they be subject to a more rigorous
review process but has yet to finalize this policy, thus keeping the door open
for fast track review of future metal hip implants. Consumers Union has urged
the FDA to finalize this requirement as soon as possible.

Further, the FDA should be doing more to inform the hundreds of thousands of
people who have metal hips of the steps they should take to regularly monitor
the way the device may be affecting their health, according to Consumers
Union. The agency has information on its website but many people with
implants are unaware of the danger the devices could pose to their health.

"The FDA advises surgeons to follow up with their patients – whether
symptomatic or asymptomatic – every one to two years for the long term and the
FDA should regularly remind the public to do so," said McGiffert.

SOURCE Consumers Union
Press spacebar to pause and continue. Press esc to stop.