By Nicholas Johnston
May 16 (Bloomberg) -- The Senate today refused to strike a guest-worker program from legislation overhauling U.S. immigration policy while voting to reduce the number of immigrant workers who would be able to participate.
The Senate set aside an amendment eliminating the program and then agreed to a proposal reducing the number of visas available each year to 200,000 from 325,000.
``I believe that we need to be a little more judicious with respect to the number of visas we are allocating,'' said New Mexico Democrat Jeff Bingaman, the sponsor of the amendment reducing the program's size.
Today's votes were the first on more than 20 amendments the Senate will consider as it debates immigration legislation that would strengthen border security, create a new guest-worker program and allow many of the estimated 11 million undocumented immigrants to apply for legal status.
President George W. Bush, in a prime-time televised address last night, said he favors ``comprehensive'' legislation that addresses border security, guest workers and undocumented immigrants. Bush also said he will send 6,000 National Guard troops to the U.S.-Mexican border and endorsed giving undocumented immigrants who have been in the U.S. ``for many years'' a way to apply for citizenship.
Amendment Votes
Today the Senate voted 69-28 to set aside an amendment by North Dakota Democrat Byron Dorgan to eliminate the guest-worker program from the measure. Dorgan said the program would cost Americans jobs and wages. ``The guest-worker provision is about importing cheap labor,'' he said before the vote.
Republican Arlen Specter of Pennsylvania opposed Dorgan's measure, saying if the U.S. doesn't ``provide for guest workers who can fill the needs of the American economy, then we're going to create a vacuum of a situation where illegal immigrants will come into fill those needs.''
The Senate then backed, by a voice vote, Bingaman's amendment to reduce the number of yearly visas available to foreign workers by 40 percent and prohibit increases that may be sought by industry if the visa-cap is met in any year.
Specter opposed Bingaman's amendment, saying the legislation is designed to ``accommodate the market.''
70 Senators
Legislation passed by the Senate will have to be reconciled with a House measure passed last year that focuses on border security and the hiring of undocumented workers, and does not address a work program or legalization of undocumented immigrants.
Senator Lindsey Graham, a South Carolina Republican, said that Bush's speech on Monday will help the final legislation pass the Senate with the support of about 70 of the 100 senators. A majority that large will strengthen the position of Senate negotiators when they meet with members of the House of Representatives in a conference committee to craft a final measure.
``Momentum in the Senate creates opportunity in conference with the House,'' Graham said.
The Senate earlier rejected, by a vote of 55-40, an amendment sponsored by Georgia Republican Johnny Isakson that would have required the president to certify that border- strengthening measures in the legislation were put in place before any system was established allowing undocumented immigrants to seek citizenship.
`A Wink and a Nod'
Isakson said the failure to adopt his amendment gives ``a wink and a nod one more time to those who would come here illegally.''
Opponents said the amendment would undermine the legislation's goals of addressing security and immigration issues at the same time.
``We cannot deal with this issue of immigration reform in a piecemeal matter,'' said Democratic Senator Ken Salazar of Colorado.
The Senate adopted, by a vote of 79-16, Salazar's competing amendment to delay implementation of a guest-worker program or legalization for undocumented immigrants only until the president certifies the proposals ``strengthen the national security of the United States.''
The Senate is also likely to consider amendments that will bar felons in the country illegally from gaining legal status, require employers to advertise jobs to Americans before foreign employees can gain permanent residency, and call for additional fencing along the U.S.-Mexico border.
Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, a Tennessee Republican, has said the Senate will complete work on the measure by the end of the month.
To contact the reporter on this story: Nicholas Johnston in Washington at njohnston3@bloomberg.net
Last Updated: May 16, 2006 18:33 EDT
HOME
