Feb. 10 (Bloomberg) -- Roger Bertrand lines up, mug in hand,
at an Ottawa homeless shelter at 7:30 every morning to get a free
pick-me-up: white wine.
``I can get only a shot an hour,'' says Bertrand, 45, an
alcoholic and former mechanic who credits the free-drinks program
at the Shepherds of Good Hope with reducing his consumption by
half. ``I don't drink beer, just the house wine. Next it will be
Nestle's Quik.''
Canada is spending about C$400 million ($349 million) over
three years to get homeless people like Bertrand off the streets.
The Shepherds of Good Hope program, which costs about C$231,000 a
year, tries to help alcoholics cut back, drink in a safe
environment and avoid hospital visits or clashes with police.
The shelter has found homeless alcoholics taking part in the
program reduced their intake by 80 percent after 16 months.
Bertrand, for example, was downing as many as five bottles of
whisky or Chinese wine a day before he joined the plan four
months ago.
``This is a last-ditch attempt to try and control a very
long-standing problem in some people,'' said Dr. Tiina Podymow of
the University of Ottawa. Homelessness is ``a very dangerous
lifestyle. The approach was to try to reduce harm without
demanding abstinence.''
Not All Agree
The approach used by the shelter runs counter to that of
groups such as the Salvation Army and the U.S. government-funded
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, which
encourage abstinence to fight the disease.
Podymow's research is the first controlled study in the
world to determine whether monitored drinking can help alcoholics
reduce their dependency. Other Canadian shelters began allowing
drinks after a 1996 coroner's report suggested that an alcohol
ban played a role in the freezing deaths of three homeless people
during winter in Toronto. Seaton House, a Toronto shelter, now
allows people to drink and to exchange non-potable alcohol such
as mouthwash and cologne for beer.
Some clinics in the U.S. use methadone, a synthetic
narcotic, to help heroin addicts kick their habit. And a shelter
in Vancouver offers free needles so that heroin users can inject
their drugs in a safe environment.
The participants in the Ottawa study made 35 percent fewer
trips to emergency rooms and had about half as many altercations
with police after entering the program, Podymow and Dr. Jeff
Turnbull wrote in a report published last month in the Canadian
Medical Association Journal.
Results 'Promising'
``The results were very promising,'' said Podymow, who
helped start the program in 2001. ``But it's a small study, and
it warrants further investigation.''
Some charitable groups that help addicts will never be
swayed by evidence that programs like these can be effective,
said James Baumohl, a social work professor at Bryn Mawr College
in Pennsylvania who used to run a homeless shelter. Most agencies
think of addiction in terms of moral values and argue it
shouldn't be made sustainable, he said.
``We're not condemning the folks that are doing it -- we
just can't do it on our site, because it goes against what our
stance is,'' said Perry Rowe, the executive director of the
Salvation Army's Ottawa Booth Centre. The center includes a
shelter for 168 men and a treatment facility for addicts.
Unlike at the Salvation Army, Shepherds' residents get a
room, which they share with up to three others, meals and alcohol
in exchange for their monthly welfare check. The residents can
drink the white wine made on the premises, or bring their own
beer. During the day, they watch television, play cards, clean,
cook, read and paint. There's no restriction on going outside,
Podymow said.
Savings in Health Care
``Since I've been here I gained 18 pounds, so I'm getting
healthier every day,'' said Bertrand, who wants to return to
work. ``I didn't think I'd like it here, but I really do.''
Fewer visits to the hospital and scuffles with the police
help offset part of the cost. The program spends C$771 a month on
each participant and saves governments C$447 in health-care and
other related costs, the team found.
At normal shelters, people ``get good and drunk in the
evening and the first thing they have to do in the morning is go
out and find another source of alcohol,'' said Ken Kraybill in
Seattle, who runs the training program of the U.S. National
Health Care for the Homeless Council network. ``That ends up
creating visits to the ER.''
The Ottawa program also has been a hit in the Byward Market
neighborhood where the shelter is located, near the city's
busiest bars and restaurants and a 15-minute walk from the
Parliament buildings. In the two years since Georges Bedard has
been city councilor for the area, he's had only one complaint
about the free-drink program.
``If it remains as successful as it's been and if it helps
lower their alcoholism level, it's a good thing,'' Bedard said.
To contact the reporter on this story:
Alexandre Deslongchamps in Ottawa at
adeslongcham@bloomberg.net .