Insider Selling Jumps to Highest Level Since 2007 (Update2)
By Michael Tsang and Eric Martin
April 24 (Bloomberg) -- Executives and insiders at U.S.
companies are taking advantage of the steepest stock market
gains since 1938 to unload shares at the fastest pace since the
start of the bear market.
Gap Inc.’s founding family sold $45 million of shares in
the largest U.S. clothing retailer this month, according to
Securities and Exchange Commission filings compiled by
Bloomberg. Daniel Warmenhoven, the chief executive officer at
NetApp Inc., liquidated the most stock of the storage-computer
maker in more than six years. Sales by the co-founders of Bed
Bath & Beyond Inc. were the highest since at least 2001.
While the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index climbed 28 percent
from a 12-year low on March 9, CEOs, directors and senior
officers at U.S. companies sold $353 million of equities this
month, or 8.3 times more than they bought, data compiled by
Washington Service, a Bethesda, Maryland-based research firm,
show. That’s a warning sign because insiders usually have more
information about their companies’ prospects than anyone else,
according to William Stone at PNC Financial Services Group Inc.
“They should know more than outsiders would, so you could
take it as a signal that there is something wrong if they’re
selling,” said Stone, chief investment strategist at PNC’s
wealth management unit, which oversees $110 billion in
Philadelphia. “Whether it’s a sustainable rebound is still in
question. I’d prefer they were buying.”
Insiders Sell
Insiders from New York Stock Exchange-listed companies sold
$8.32 worth of stock for every dollar bought in the first three
weeks of April, according to Washington Service, which analyzes
stock transactions of corporate insiders for more than 500
institutional clients.
That’s the fastest rate of selling since October 2007, when
U.S. stocks peaked and the 17-month bear market that wiped out
more than half the market value of U.S. companies began. The
$42.5 million in insider purchases through April 20 would
represent the smallest amount for a full month since July 1992,
data going back more than 20 years show. That drop preceded a
2.4 percent slide in the S&P 500 in August 1992.
The index rose 1.7 percent to 866.23 today after the
Federal Reserve said most banks that underwent stress tests hold
enough capital and companies from Ford Motor Co. to American
Express Co. posted better-than-estimated results.
Looking Forward
The S&P 500 has jumped 28 percent in 33 trading days, the
sharpest rally since the 1930s, on speculation the longest
recession since World War II will soon end.
Stocks rebounded as President Barack Obama outlined a $787
billion package of spending and tax cuts to stimulate growth,
the Treasury unveiled plans to finance as much as $1 trillion in
purchases of banks’ distressed assets and the Fed pledged to buy
more than $1 trillion of Treasuries and bonds backed by
mortgages to drive down interest rates.
With corporate America stuck in its seventh straight
quarter of earnings decreases, the longest in seven decades,
executives may have become too cautious, said Penn Capital
Management’s Eric Green.
Investors are looking to the final quarter of the year,
when S&P 500 companies will increase operating income by 71
percent, according to analyst estimates compiled by Bloomberg.
They forecast profits will fall 33 percent in the second quarter
and 21 percent in the third.
“Things are a lot better than they were,” said Green,
director of research at Penn Capital, which oversees $3 billion
in Cherry Hill, New Jersey. Recent history also shows that
“insiders have been wrong,” he said.
Confidence Game
Jeffrey Immelt, CEO of General Electric Co., purchased
50,000 shares at prices from $16.41 to $16.45 on Nov. 13, when
the stock closed at $16.86. The shares have since fallen 28
percent after the Fairfield, Connecticut-based company reduced
its dividend for the first time since 1938 and lost the AAA
credit rating from S&P that it held for more than 50 years.
Insiders of consumer and technology companies have been
selling the most stock relative to the amount they purchased
this month, data compiled by Washington Service show.
John Fisher, Robert Fisher and William Fisher, whose
parents Donald and Doris Fisher founded San Francisco-based Gap
in 1969, sold a combined 2.99 million shares at between $15.11
and $15.36 a share on April 3 and April 17, SEC filings show.
Gap rebounded 55 percent from its low on March 6. The stock
gained 1.1 percent since the Fishers’ last sale.
Reasons to Sell
Gap spokesman Bill Chandler said that “from time to time,
based upon the advice of financial advisers, the members of the
Fisher family will decide to sell stock.”
Warren Eisenberg and Leonard Feinstein, who founded Union,
New Jersey-based Bed Bath & Beyond in 1971, sold 1.05 million
and 1.1 million shares at $30.90 apiece on April 9, the most
since at least December 2001, the filings show.
The offerings came one day after Bed Bath & Beyond surged
24 percent, the biggest advance in nine years, on a smaller than
estimated decline in fourth-quarter profit. Spokesman Ken
Frankel said Eisenberg and Feinstein, who currently serve as co-
chairmen of the largest U.S. home-furnishings retailer, sold for
“estate-planning purposes and diversification.”
At NetApp, Warmenhoven sold 1.25 million shares, the most
since at least 2002, for about $21.3 million between April 3 and
April 21 at prices from $16.10 to $18.10 a share, the SEC
filings show. Shares of the Sunnyvale, California-based company,
up 49 percent from $12.52 on the March 9 stock market low,
gained 3.3 percent since then.
Moving On
Warmenhoven sold shares he received from exercising stock
options that were due to expire next month, according to an e-
mailed response by Lindsey Smith, a spokeswoman for NetApp. He
reaped a profit of about $7.3 million selling the shares at an
average price of $17.08 apiece, based on the conversion price of
$11.25 for options he held, the data show.
“They’re going to say, ‘Thank you very much,’ and move on
to cash or something else,” said David W. James, who helps
manage about $2 billion at James Investment Research Inc. in
Xenia, Ohio. “This is not a situation that suggests to us we’re
seeing an economic recovery.”
To contact the reporters on this story:
Michael Tsang in New York at
mtsang1@bloomberg.net;
Eric Martin in New York at
emartin21@bloomberg.net.
Last Updated: April 24, 2009 16:50 EDT