Four Seasons, Power Lunch Palace, Gets 50th Birthday Remodeling
Commentary by James S. Russell
June 10 (Bloomberg) -- Architect Philip Johnson hung
sparkling curtains of metal mesh in the windows of the Four
Seasons restaurant in 1959, then lunched there regularly for
decades, keeping an owlish eye on the place through his thick,
round glasses. After all, the restaurant is as famous for its
modern grandeur as for its food and power-broker patrons.
The Four Seasons is throwing itself a half-century bash
tomorrow, with 800 of its closest friends, including Blackstone
Group co-founder Peter G. Peterson, home-style doyenne Martha
Stewart, and fashion royalty Oscar de la Renta. Then it’s
quietly giving itself a facelift.
Through food fads, economic gyrations and a shifting
celebrity clientele, the Four Seasons has endured -- but the
recession taxes even the legendary adaptability of co-owners
Alex von Bidder and Julian Niccolini. These days bass carpaccio
is a mere $12 at the bar, and a three-course prix-fixe menu is a
steal (in Four Seasons terms) at $59.
With customers’ closed wallets and fickle tastes, pumping
cash into this lavish monument to New York’s “Mad Men” era is
an act of faith.
“The restaurant has been admirably maintained,” said
Belmont Freeman, the restoration architect, “but it needs
help.” Though Freeman’s work tends to minimalist surfaces in
glass and steel, his role isn’t to transform the restaurant
wholesale, but to gently usher the institution into the 21st
century, “to reveal more of its elegance,” he said.
The entire interior has been a New York City historic
landmark since 1989, permitting little obvious change.
Mies Modernism
Up a bronze-railed stair from a low-ceilinged lobby on East
52nd Street, the 20-foot-high volume of the Grill Room billows
grandly upward. It is one of a pair of high, 60-foot-square
rooms (or 3,600 square feet each) that the famed International
Style architect Mies van der Rohe created at the base of the
spare-no-expense Seagram Building, on Park Avenue.
Johnson -- a card-carrying Modernist in thrall to Mies --
leavened the exterior’s austere grandeur in his design for the
restaurant with suave, luxe finishes. He covered the Grill Room
walls with acres of book-matched French walnut alternating with
bronze panels. (The once-golden tones will soon glow anew.)
The main dining room’s iconic marble-lined pool, in which a
quartet of tipsy young women once took a naked dip, isn’t going
anywhere. Freeman will replace the famous but fading curtains
Johnson had made of delicate chains of aluminum anodized in
gold, silver and copper. They transform the city outside into an
elegantly grainy abstraction and sparkle as they shiver in the
air conditioning. He’s found the original Fortuny fabric for the
ladies room walls.
‘We Had No Budget’
It is impossible to imagine that kind of lavishness, even
with all the showplace restaurants built to the cult of brand-
name TV chefs. “We had no budget,” Johnson told architect and
historian Robert A.M. Stern. “We just bought things.” They
added up to $4.5 million (a staggering $33 million today).
An artisan has already begun cleaning a cloud of bronze
rods sculptor Richard Lippold suspended over the bar. A grand
stage curtain by Picasso hangs in the passage between the two
dining rooms. Mark Rothko was commissioned to create paintings
for the balcony over the Pool Room, but realized that the place
fed “the richest bastards in New York” and didn’t deliver
them. (They are now in major collections.) Jackson Pollock’s
“Blue Poles” once hung in a private dining room.
Do changing tastes demand more than a curatorial approach?
“How could the Four Seasons be dated?” replied Phyllis Lambert
by telephone from the Canadian Centre for Architecture, which
she founded in Montreal. “Is Versailles dated?”
Seagram Building
In the 1950s, she persuaded her father, Samuel Bronfman, to
hire both Mies and Johnson to design the building named after
his spirits empire. She is overseeing the restoration. The work
is being undertaken now, she explained, precisely because the
Four Seasons is a work of art that deserves proper care.
Noting the vintage look of early lunchers on a recent
visit, I asked Freeman if the very idea of the Four Seasons was
too tied to legends of yesteryear like Jacqueline Onassis, Henry
Kissinger and Barbara Walters. A younger generation gets it, he
said. “It’s a modern classic -- like the martini.”
(James S. Russell is Bloomberg’s U.S. architecture critic.
The opinions expressed are his own.)
To contact the writer of this column:
James S. Russell in New York at
jamesrussell@earthlink.net.
Last Updated: June 10, 2009 00:01 EDT