Unemployment at 10% to Depress Consumer Spending, Survey Shows
By Bob Willis and Alex Tanzi
June 10 (Bloomberg) -- Surging unemployment in the U.S.
will delay a recovery in consumer spending and mute the rebound
when it does materialize, according to a Bloomberg News survey.
The jobless rate will climb to 10 percent by the end of
2009, 1.6 percentage points higher than projected at the start
of the year, according to the median forecast of 62 economists
surveyed from June 1 to June 8. Household purchases will drop
this year more than previously estimated.
Fewer jobs, lower home values, limited credit and shrinking
retirement funds will prompt Americans to save, blunting the
Obama administration’s stimulus efforts. Still, government
infrastructure projects, smaller stockpiles and stabilization in
residential construction will help the economy start growing in
the second half of this year.
“Consumer spending will come back grudgingly, slowly,”
said John Lonski, chief economist at Moody’s Capital Markets
Group in New York. “The unemployment rate should continue to
rise and remain stubbornly high.” Lonski forecast the jobless
rate will reach 10.2 percent in early 2010, higher than he
previously estimated.
Personal spending, which accounts for 70 percent of the
economy, will fall at a 0.6 percent annual pace in the current
quarter and rise at an average 1.1 percent pace in the last six
months of the year, down from last month’s projections. For all
of 2009, purchases will drop 0.7 percent, the worst performance
since 1974.
Spending ‘Muted’
“Consumer spending does look to be more muted in this
recovery than typically after a deep recession,” said Dean
Maki, chief U.S. economist at Barclays Capital Inc. in New York.
“We would attribute that to the negative wealth effects from
housing and stock market declines. There will only be a modest
rebound in the next couple of quarters.”
The world’s largest economy will contract at a 2 percent
pace this quarter, before growing 0.5 percent in the July-to-
September period and 1.9 percent in the final three months of
the year, according to the survey. For all of 2009, the economy
will contract 2.7 percent, the biggest drop in the post-World
War II era.
The jobless rate will average 9.2 percent in 2009, higher
than the 8.9 percent worst-case scenario the government used in
tests to determine whether a deteriorating economy would require
the 19 largest banks to boost capital. The results last month
showed 10 of those firms needed more funds. Unemployment climbed
to 9.4 percent in May, the government reported last week.
The survey also showed unemployment will average 9.8
percent in 2010, compared with the 10.3 percent the government
used in its stress test.
Stress Tests
The weakening in the labor market is one reason the panel
overseeing the financial bailout yesterday said regulators
should repeat the tests.
Restructuring efforts in the auto industry mean more job
losses are on the way. AutoNation Inc., the largest U.S. new-
vehicle retailer, plans to close seven showrooms, while Visteon
Corp., the former parts-making unit of Ford Motor Co., and
chassis manufacturer Metaldyne Corp. have joined General Motors
Corp. and Chrysler LLC in declaring bankruptcy.
“Businesses have been very aggressive in cutting costs
relative to declines in output,” said Robert Mellman, an
economist at JPMorgan Chase & Co. in New York. “It could be
because of financial difficulties and uncertainties about access
to capital and unwillingness to borrow.”
Stimulus Plan
Already, the economy has lost 6 million jobs since the
recession began in December 2007, the most of any slump since
the Great Depression. That’s nearly double the 3.5 million jobs
President Obama seeks to save or create with the $787 billion
recovery plan passed in February.
The president last week announced 10 projects, including
improvements in parks, highways and veteran medical facilities,
intended to save or create more than 600,000 jobs over three
months in an effort to stem the damage. “We have a long way to
go on our road to recovery but we are going the right way,”
Obama said in a statement.
The jump in government spending will cause the budget
deficit to swell to 12 percent of gross domestic product this
fiscal year, the highest since monthly records began in 1968,
according to the survey median.
Still, government efforts to thaw credit are starting to
pay off, making it easier for companies to borrow.
“Capital markets have largely healed,” General Electric
Co. Chief Executive Officer Jeffrey Immelt said at a conference
yesterday. “As a company you have to invest now. You have to
invest when things are darkest.” Still, the economic recovery
will be slower than that following the 1982 recession, he added.
A subdued expansion means Federal Reserve policy makers
will hold the benchmark interest rate near zero until the second
half of 2010, according to the survey median.
To contact the reporters for this story:
Bob Willis in Washington at
bwillis@bloomberg.netAlex Tanzi in Washington at
atanzi@bloomberg.net
Last Updated: June 10, 2009 00:00 EDT