U.S. Home Price Slump to Last to Mid-2010, Pimco Says (Update1)
Nov. 4 (Bloomberg) -- The slump in U.S. housing prices is
unlikely to end before the middle of next year, and statistics
portraying rising values are misleading, according to Pacific
Investment Management Co.
An S&P/Case-Shiller index for 20 metropolitan areas showed
values rising 4.8 percent in the four months through August
after a record 33 percent drop from its July 2006 peak. Such
statistics are being distorted by U.S. efforts to reduce
foreclosures, which are temporarily limiting sales of seized
homes, said Scott Simon, Pimco’s mortgage-bond chief.
“It only makes prices look like they’re going up,” Simon
said yesterday in a telephone interview. “Think about it this
way: If you had 100 percent of the sales as foreclosure sales,
prices would look like they went down a ton, and if you had
none, prices would look like they went up a ton.”
Distressed sales fell to 29 percent of existing-home
transactions in September, from more than half in March, as loan
servicers assessed borrowers for the federal Making Home
Affordable mortgage-modification program and dealt with state-
law changes such as a California foreclosure moratorium,
according to National Association of Realtors data.
Mortgage-bond analysts at firms including Barclays Capital
Inc., Bank of America Corp. and Amherst Securities Group have
also said home-price data is being distorted by changes in the
types of sales, citing typical seasonal rises in non-foreclosure
transactions as another cause. About 7 million properties likely
to be seized by lenders have yet to hit the market, Amherst’s
Laurie Goodman wrote in a Sept. 23 report.
High-End Pressure
“Lower-priced houses have probably bottomed, but expensive
homes absolutely haven’t and they’re going to continue to go
down,” Simon said.
Newport Beach, California-based Pimco is the world’s
largest fixed-income manager, with $940 billion of assets.
About 25.3 percent of mortgages underlying the $1.7
trillion of U.S. home-loan securities without government backing
were at least 60 days late, in foreclosure or already turned
into seized property as of September bond reports, up from 20
percent in January, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
About 3.75 percent were 30 days late, up from a low this year of
3.57 percent in May and down from 4.18 percent in January.
Deteriorating Conditions
October disclosures for individual so-called non-agency
bond deals -- typically released on the 25th of a month --
generally showed pipelines of defaulted loans building and
early-stage delinquencies climbing, according to reports last
week by Barclays, Credit Suisse Group and Morgan Stanley.
After a record rally from all-time lows, non-agency home-
loan securities are “probably too expensive to buy giant
amounts and probably too cheap to sell giant amounts,” Simon
said. Still, “if the financial system is really repaired, these
may be quite cheap assets.”
In May, Simon said the bonds were “still really cheap,”
offering “awfully high yields” under “some pretty draconian
scenarios” for home prices, after being “just stupidly cheap”
months earlier.
Typical prices for the most-senior fixed-rate prime-jumbo
mortgage bonds rose to 85 cents on the dollar last week, from 63
cents in mid-March, according to Barclays Capital data. Similar
bonds backed by Alt-A loans with a few years of fixed rates were
at 60 cents, up from 35 cents.
Non-agency home-loan securities lack guarantees from Fannie
Mae and Freddie Mac, the government-supported mortgage-finance
companies, or federal agency Ginnie Mae. Jumbo mortgages are
larger than Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac can finance; Alt-A loans
fall between prime and subprime in terms of projected defaults.
Index Effect
David Blitzer, chairman of the index committee at New York-
based Standard & Poor’s, said in a telephone interview today
that the mix of sales types does affect its Case-Shiller
indexes. “Every month I get at least one realtor saying I
shouldn’t include foreclosures,” he said, because they may
overstate the extent of declines from the housing market’s peak.
The indexes give “a guide to what’s going on” and not “a
razor-sharp result” for the exact needs of every investor, he
said. Doing versions without foreclosures hasn’t been given
serious consideration as “the data-compilation issues get to be
pretty messy,” he said. “Should we have not included them in
the first place? They’re part of the market” and excluding
foreclosures would mean ignoring the “same houses that drove
prices up sky high.”
Bill Bemis, a portfolio manager who oversees about $8.5
billion of securitized debt at Aviva Investors in Des Moines,
Iowa, said in an interview yesterday that “in general, there’s
still value left” in non-agency mortgage bonds.
‘Technical Tailwind’
While coming months will likely follow seasonal patterns
and bring more delinquencies as well as weaker housing markets,
“we’re not going to see any sort of increase like we saw” in
late 2008 and early this year, he said. Prices may be supported
by a “technical tailwind” of demand for mortgage debt fueled
by government programs and low short-term rates.
“The real question,” Bemis added, “is when you get six
to nine months out, and these technicals start to fade, have we
reached a point where fundamentals have bottomed and are
improving and can justify where prices have gotten to?”
To contact the reporter on this story:
Jody Shenn in New York at
jshenn@bloomberg.net.
Last Updated: November 4, 2009 12:30 EST