Obama Raises 2010 Deficit Estimate to $1.5 Trillion (Update3)
By Roger Runningen and Brian Faler
Aug. 25 (Bloomberg) -- U.S. unemployment will surge to 10
percent this year and the budget deficit will be $1.5 trillion
next year, both higher than previous Obama administration
forecasts because of a recession that was deeper and longer than
expected, White House budget chief Peter Orszag said.
The Office of Management and Budget forecasts a weaker
economic recovery than it saw in May as the gross domestic
product shrinks 2.8 percent this year before expanding 2 percent
next year, according to the administration’s mid-year economic
review issued today. The Congressional Budget Office, in a
separate assessment, forecast the economy will grow 2.8 percent
next year. Both see the GDP expanding 3.8 percent in 2011.
“While the danger of the economy immediately falling into
a deep recession has receded, the American economy is still in
the midst of a serious economic downturn,” the White House
report said. “The long-term deficit outlook remains daunting.”
The budget shortfall for 2010 would mark the second
straight year of trillion-dollar deficits. Along with the
unemployment numbers, the deficit may complicate President
Barack Obama’s drive for his top domestic priority, overhauling
the U.S. health care system.
“It throws a wrench in health-care reforms,” Maya
MacGuineas, president of the bipartisan Committee for a
Responsible Federal Budget, said in an interview. “No matter
the specific numbers, they’re a constant reminder that we’re in
bad, bad shape.”
Spending Caps
House Republican Leader John Boehner of Ohio seized on the
estimates to call for the Democrat-controlled Congress to impose
“strict annual caps on federal spending.”
The health-care overhaul “is just the latest in a long
line of expensive Democratic experiments that will add to the
deficit, raise taxes on families and small businesses and cost
more American jobs,” Boehner said in a statement.
The two budget agencies say the shortfall is being driven
by the recession as outlays rise for unemployment compensation,
food stamps or other programs meant to stabilize the economy
rise and tax receipts fall.
Administration and congressional budget officials expect
the unemployment rate, which was 9.4 percent last month, to keep
rising. White House officials said the rate likely will rise to
10 percent by the end of 2009, averaging 9.3 percent for the
entire year. It will worsen to a 9.8 percent average in 2010
instead of the 7.9 percent estimate in May.
The CBO report also estimates the 2009 jobless rate at 9.3
percent. It puts next year’s average at 10.2 percent.
Deficit Projections
The OMB raised its deficit projection for fiscal 2010,
which begins Oct. 1, from the $1.26 trillion forecast in May,
reflecting slower economic growth this year and next because of
“the severity of the crisis in the U.S. and in our trading
partners,” said Christina Romer, White House chief economist,
who along with Orszag briefed reporters on the report.
The median estimate of 31 economists in a Bloomberg News
survey completed Aug. 21 was for a fiscal year 2010 deficit of
$1.3 trillion.
The outlook for the 2009 fiscal year is slightly better
than the previous forecast. The government’s shortfall will peak
this year at $1.58 trillion before narrowing over the next
decade. That is less than the $1.84 trillion projected in May
because budget officials were able to delete hundreds of
billions of dollars that had been set aside for bank bailouts.
Last year’s deficit was $459 billion.
The CBO estimates the budget deficit will total $1.6
trillion this year, or 11.2 percent of the GDP, and $1.4
trillion in 2010.
Bailout Money
“The Obama White House deserves some credit for managing
the financial situation so that the additional bailout wasn’t
necessary,” said Stan Collender, a former budget analyst for
the House and Senate budget committees.
Orszag said reining in the deficit is a “top priority” of
the administration. He said the budget blueprint Obama submits
to Congress in February will “include proposals to put the
nation back on a fiscally sustainable path.” He declined to
give specifics.
The OMB added almost $2 trillion to the 10-year deficit
from its May forecast, to $9.05 trillion. The nonpartisan CBO’s
long-range projection was $7.14 trillion. The difference stems
from the CBO’s assumption that tax cuts enacted in 2001 and 2003
will expire on schedule in 2011. Obama has promised to keep the
lower tax rates for middle-income Americans.
Market Reaction
“The market will view this as a very consensus-oriented
forecast” and there won’t be any significant reaction, said
Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody’s Economy.com in West
Chester, Pennsylvania.
Zandi predicted Congress will pass a second “mini”
stimulus bill next year of about $250 billion to aid jobless
workers, state governments and home buyers. “The economy will
be growing at an uncomfortably slow rate, not enough to bring
down unemployment, and of course it’s an election year” for
Congress, he said.
Orszag defended the trillion-dollar deficits during a
recession and said they shouldn’t be used to block the
administration’s health-care initiative. Revising the way the
nation pays for medical care will help save money, he said.
“I know there are going to be some who say this report
proves we can’t afford health reform,” Orszag said. “I think
that has it backwards” because savings must be squeezed from
the system.
Back to Growth
Even with economic conditions worse that originally
forecast, Romer said “we do expect positive GDP growth by the
end of this year” for the fourth quarter as the economy reaches
“a turning point.”
“A return to employment growth will take longer,” Romer
said, adding that the jobless rate likely will peak in the
fourth quarter of this year.
Romer said the economic stimulus package probably is adding
“between 2 and 3 percentage points” to economic growth in the
second quarter of this year, blunting conditions that would have
been worse. A report on the effect of the stimulus program is
due to Congress next month, she said.
Inflation will remain subdued. Projections for the consumer
price index show a contraction of 0.7 percent this year, a rise
of 1.4 percent next year and 1.5 percent in 2011, Romer said.
The economic assumptions were compiled by the Council of
Economic Advisers, Treasury Department and the Office of
Management and Budget. The estimates reflect conditions as of
early June.
To contact the reporters on this story:
Roger Runningen in Washington at
rrunningen@bloomberg.netBrian Faler in Washington at
bfaler@bloomberg.net
Last Updated: August 25, 2009 15:48 EDT