Luxury Hotels Risk Default as $850 Rooms Remain Empty (Update1)
Sept. 24 (Bloomberg) -- Luxury hotel owners risk defaulting
on their debt as the recession cuts occupancies and the credit
crunch constrains refinancing.
Loans secured by more than 1,500 hotels with a total
outstanding balance of $24.5 billion may be in danger of
default, according to Realpoint LLC, a credit rating company
that tracks commercial mortgage-backed securities. Some of the
biggest loans, put on the company’s watch list because of late
payments, decreasing occupancies or cash flow, were made to
luxury properties where rooms can cost more than $850 a night.
“All segments are showing signs of distress but the luxury
segment carries much higher loan balances and is more clearly
affected,” Frank Innaurato, managing director of CMBS
analytical services at Horsham, Pennsylvania-based Realpoint,
said in a telephone interview.
Lodging owners are struggling after adding rooms and
properties at the peak of the CMBS market from 2004 to 2007,
when $83.4 billion in hotel-backed securities was issued.
Occupancy among chains with the costliest rooms fell to 60
percent in the first half from 70 percent a year earlier,
according to Smith Travel Research. The decline was the
industry’s largest for that period.
“Luxury hotels have been aggressively financed during the
peak CMBS issuance years,” David Loeb, an analyst at Robert W.
Baird & Co., said in a phone interview. “That’s why luxury
hotel loans crowd these watch lists.”
Four Seasons
A $90 million loan secured by the Four Seasons San
Francisco, a 277-room, five-star property, is 90 days delinquent
and foreclosure proceedings have begun, according to Realpoint.
A notice of default has been filed, according to Bloomberg data.
The borrower was Millennium Partners LLC, a real estate
firm founded in 1990 by Christopher Jeffries. The company
controls 1,860 residential units, more than 2,000 hotel rooms
and 1 million square feet (93,000 square meters) of office
space, Realpoint said.
Nicola Blazier, a spokeswoman for Four Seasons San
Francisco, didn’t respond to e-mails and phone calls for
comment. Millennium principal Jeffries didn’t return a call.
The Dream Hotel, a 220-room hotel on West 55th Street in
New York City that features 300-thread count Egyptian bed linens
and iPods, is collateral for a $100 million loan taken by Surrey
Hotel Associates LLC that’s at risk of default, Realpoint said.
The borrower is trying to restructure the debt and defer
payments, said Riyaz Akhtar, vice president at Surrey.
More Defaults?
“What’s happening to us right now is happening, and will
continue to happen, to many hotel properties given the current
market,” Akhtar said in a telephone interview.
The U.S. hotel loan-delinquency rate may climb to 8.2
percent by year-end, Morgan Stanley analysts led by Andy Day
said in a June 23 report. That would match the peak from the
last recession in 2001.
Upscale hotels are suffering from “a heightened focus on
prudent corporate travel expenditures,” as well as the pullback
in vacation travel, Day said.
Microsoft Corp., coping with its first annual sales
decline, said in July it would slash $3 billion in operating
expenses, including travel spending.
The number of luxury-brand rooms in the U.S. as of the end
of July rose 9.1 percent from a year earlier to 100,000, Loeb
said.
Occupancy Decline
A $190 million loan secured by the 640-room Arizona Grand
Resort is 90 days delinquent, according to Realpoint. If the
loan is liquidated it may lead to a $111.9 million loss, the
credit rating company said.
The property’s occupancy rate fell to 64 percent as of
December 2008 from 70 percent a year earlier, Realpoint said.
The borrower was Pointe South Mountain Resort LLC, a Grossman
Company Properties affiliate. Pamela Kerner, a spokeswoman for
Phoenix-based Grossman, declined to comment.
Realpoint also is monitoring a $1 billion loan taken by CNL
Hotels and Resorts, a company acquired by a Morgan Stanley real
estate fund. The loan is secured by five properties with 14 golf
courses, including the Arizona Biltmore in Phoenix and the Grand
Wailea Resort Hotel & Spa in Maui, Hawaii.
Falling cash flow and weakening economic conditions put
those properties on the watch list, Realpoint said. Revenue is
sufficient to meet interest payments, and the assessed
collateral value of $1.4 billion lowered the loan’s risk,
Realpoint said. Alyson Barnes, a Morgan Stanley spokeswoman,
declined to comment on the analysis.
Westin Aruba
The Westin Aruba Resort & Spa, managed by Starwood Hotels &
Resorts Worldwide Inc., was foreclosed on in May, according to
Realpoint. The property is controlled by Wachovia Corp., the
ratings company said.
The property’s occupancy rate dropped to 41 percent in May
from an average of 63 percent in 2008, the report said.
Servicers are used when a loan is in or near default and needs
to be reviewed or modified, according to Innaurato.
The Westin Aruba has been hurt by competition from a 450-
room luxury resort built next door, Realpoint said.
Another property on Realpoint’s watch list is the Four
Seasons New York, where a standard room with a king-sized bed
starts at $855 a night. The hotel is among four used as
collateral for a $344.6 million loan, Realpoint said.
The properties’ occupancy rate fell to 57 percent in the 12
months through June. At the end of 2007 and 2008 it was 73
percent and 69 percent, respectively, Realpoint said.
‘Moderate’ Risk
Four Seasons New York’s net cash flow “is well below
historical trends,” the credit rating company said, without
being more specific. While the property’s revenue per available
room and net cash flow have jumped since bottoming in 2003, the
hotel “is more recently showing signs of New York’s weakening
economy,” Realpoint said.
The property is owned by Ty Warner Hotels & Resorts.
“We consider this loan a moderate default risk based on
declining performance along with the lower expectations on the
lodging-resort industry given the current economic conditions,”
Realpoint said in its report. “Our analysis of the collateral
suggests that the combined value of the assets are below the
current loan amount.”
Donna Snopek, chief financial officer of Ty Warner Hotels,
said in an e-mail that the loan “is performing well.”
‘No Impact’
“Moreover, the properties in the pool are all performing
at the top of their respective markets,” Snopek said. “We are
fully committed to our loan and can assure you that there is no
impact to the current high standard of services at this
property.”
Lowe Enterprises Inc. of Los Angeles, the operator and
developer of a 582-room resort on the Pacific Coast, said in
August it’s trying to restructure a mezzanine loan after
defaulting two months after the hotel opened.
The Terranea Resort in Rancho Palos Verdes, California, a
$480 million property, opened June 12 with a golf course, three
pools and eight restaurants. Lowe is among a group of investors
in the property and is in negotiations about restructuring the
loan, spokeswoman Jann Diehl said.
To contact the reporter on this story:
Nadja Brandt in Los Angeles at
nbrandt@bloomberg.net
Last Updated: September 24, 2009 18:29 EDT