Golf After Bailout at Northern Trust Prompts Outcry (Update1)
By Christopher Condon and Alison Vekshin
Feb. 25 (Bloomberg) -- U.S. lawmakers are asking companies
to repay taxpayer money spent on private jets and other perks
after Northern Trust Corp., the Chicago-based custody bank that
got $1.6 billion, hosted a golf tournament this month.
Representative Barney Frank, the chairman of the House
Financial Services Committee, yesterday co-signed a letter with
17 colleagues demanding that Northern Trust return money spent on
the event. Senator John Kerry said he would introduce a bill
banning firms getting U.S. aid from paying for conferences and
parties.
“I’m sick and tired of picking up the newspaper and reading
about another idiotic abuse of taxpayer money while our country
is on the brink,” Kerry said in a statement yesterday. He and
Frank are both Massachusetts Democrats.
Members of Congress have scolded companies getting funds
through the Treasury’s $700 billion Troubled Asset Relief Program
for spending on corporate jets, conferences and employee bonuses
after accepting taxpayer dollars meant to help them weather the
financial crisis. At the Northern Trust Open, a PGA Tour event
outside Los Angeles from Feb. 19 through Feb. 22, the bank hosted
parties and concerts including performances by Sheryl Crow and
Chicago, according to the Web site TMZ.com.
“We came to the conclusion that no public purpose would be
served by canceling the Northern Trust Open and related events,”
Northern Trust Chief Executive Officer Frederick Waddell said in
a statement on the company’s Web site. He didn’t say whether the
company would return any government money.
No TARP Money
Waddell said no TARP funds had been used for operating
expenses, including marketing, advertising or corporate
sponsorship.
He said government funds had supported “high-quality loan
growth,” helping to increase Northern Trust’s loans and leases
by 21 percent in 2008 to more than $30 billion.
Frank and the Democrats who wrote to Waddell said they were
“dismayed and angered” by reports the bank “hosted clients and
employees at places like the Beverly Wilshire and Ritz Carlton
hotels and gave away Tiffany souvenirs.”
“We insist that you immediately return to the federal
government the equivalent of what Northern Trust frittered away
on these lavish events,” the lawmakers wrote in a letter
released yesterday.
‘Business Decision’
John O’Connell, a spokesman for Northern Trust, said in an
e-mailed statement that sponsoring the golf tournament and
related events “is part of a business decision regarding an
annual event to show appreciation for clients.” He declined to
provide details of what the company spent on the events.
Kerry said his legislation would impose a $100,000 fine on
any TARP recipients misusing the funds and require them to
reimburse the government. It would ban the companies from hosting
or sponsoring conferences and events and paying for holiday or
entertainment events for the year they receive TARP funds.
President Barack Obama this month announced new conditions
on TARP recipients that would force companies to disclose more
about expenses such as corporate jets, office renovations,
entertainment and holiday parties. Obama also said the government
would require companies getting future aid to cap compensation
for top officials at $500,000 a year.
‘New Landscape’
Some recipients have responded to lawmakers’ criticism by
scaling back. American International Group Inc., Wells Fargo &
Co. and Citigroup Inc.’s Primerica unit have canceled corporate
events set for resort locations. Goldman Sachs Group Inc., which
received $10 billion in TARP funds, this month moved a technology
conference to San Francisco from Las Vegas, citing the “new
landscape for our industry.”
Citigroup Chief Executive Officer Vikram Pandit told
lawmakers at a Feb. 11 congressional hearing that he canceled an
order for a $50 million corporate jet after a Treasury official
called the company to question the purchase.
The bank agreed in 2007 to sponsor the annual tournament,
held at Riviera Country Club in Pacific Palisades, California,
for five years beginning in 2008. The event, one of the oldest
stops on the PGA Tour, drew 29 of the top 50 ranked golfers in
the world. Phil Mickelson won the tournament last weekend, taking
$1.13 million of the $6.3 million purse.
“The Northern Trust Open is an integral part of Northern
Trust’s global marketing activities, focusing on retaining and
growing business with existing clients, and attracting new
clients,” O’Connell said.
Under TARP, Northern Trust sold the U.S. Treasury $1.6
billion in preferred stock and warrants.
Dividend
“Northern Trust did not seek the government’s investment,
but agreed to the government’s goal of gaining the participation
of all major banks in the United States,” O’Connell said.
The company pays the Treasury $19.7 million in dividends
each quarter.
“It’s the controllable part of the event, the royal
treatment of employees and clients, that shows once again that
banks aren’t fully aware of how taxpayers feel about events like
this,” Thomas Schatz, president of Washington-based Citizens
Against Government Waste, said yesterday in an interview.
The taxpayer group criticized Bank of America Corp., another
TARP recipient, for sponsoring events at the Super Bowl in Tampa,
Florida, earlier this month.
The group was founded in 1984 by the late industrialist J.
Peter Grace and syndicated columnist Jack Anderson, according to
its Web site.
Custody banks keep records, track performance and lend
securities to institutional investors including mutual funds,
pensions and hedge funds.
To contact the reporters on this story:
Christopher Condon in Boston at
ccondon4@bloomberg.netAlison Vekshin in Washington at
avekshin@bloomberg.net;
Last Updated: February 25, 2009 09:08 EST