Columbia's $6 Billion Expansion Likely to Win Approval From NYC
Nov. 23 (Bloomberg) -- Columbia University's $6 billion
expansion plan in Harlem may win approval from a New York City
panel next week, five years after the school began an effort to
double in size.
The city's Planning Commission is scheduled to vote Nov. 26
on the school's rezoning request, which has aroused opposition
from some residents and business owners. Columbia wants to
transform 17 acres north of its existing campus in New York City
with academic buildings, research labs and dormitories.
Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts; Yale
University in New Haven, Connecticut; Brown University in
Providence, Rhode Island; and the University of Pennsylvania in
Philadelphia all are pursuing major expansions, largely for
research labs to attract federal money, professors and prestige.
As Columbia seeks city approval, the commission will also rule on
a competing plan by a community board that says the school would
wipe out blue-collar jobs and homes.
``Columbia ultimately will get nearly everything it's asking
for,'' said Julia Vitullo-Martin, a senior fellow specializing in
development at the Manhattan Institute, a New York nonprofit
whose members analyze public issues. She said the neighborhood is
underdeveloped, with good access to transportation, ``and New
York needs Columbia. It's an important international university
and a major employer.''
Columbia needlessly generated animosity in the neighborhood,
Vitullo-Martin said in a telephone interview. The community
board, some residents and business owners say the university must
do more to preserve jobs and homes in the Manhattanville section
of the western edge of Harlem.
Legal Challenge Possible
Even if Columbia gets the rezoning it seeks, some residents
vow to continue fighting the university. Tom DeMott, a member of
Coalition to Preserve Community, a group opposed to Columbia's
plans, raised the possibility of lawsuits over environmental
threats, or legal challenges to the possible use of eminent
domain where the government has the right to acquire property.
``We have all kinds of things that we're prepared and
willing to do to make this plan not go through if they don't
compromise the way they should, and if the elected officials sell
us out,'' DeMott said.
``Columbia has got a good case for its expansion,'' said the
Reverend Earl Kooperkamp, rector of St. Mary's Episcopal Church,
near the expansion zone. ``However, the neighborhood is
historically low-income -- a disempowered, disenfranchised
neighborhood. We want to see what we can do to change that.''
Kooperkamp said the community board's plan treats
Manhattanville like a multifaceted village. Columbia's plan, he
said, envisions the area as a ``plantation.''
``It's one crop, one owner,'' he said.
Five Building
Columbia plans to begin construction of five buildings in
about a year, assuming it gets zoning approval: a science center,
new homes for the schools of business, arts and international
affairs, and a 600-seat auditorium, said Robert Kasdin, senior
executive vice president of the school.
When the expansion is complete in 2030, the school expects
to have 19,000 graduate students, a 27 percent increase, said
Joseph A. Ienuso, executive vice president of facilities.
Columbia said it now has 326 square feet of buildings for
each student, less than the amount of space at Harvard, Yale,
Princeton University in New Jersey and some other schools.
``There's a growing recognition that the absence of space
was beginning to threaten Columbia University's ability to remain
a great global university,'' Kasdin said.
Columbia has won support from Manhattan Borough President
Scott Stringer. The city's Planning Department has recommended
modifications to both Columbia's and the community board's plans,
said Rachaele Raynoff, a department spokeswoman. The department's
director, Amanda Burden, won't comment further on the issue until
the Nov. 26 vote, Raynoff said.
City Council
Burden, an appointee of Mayor Michael Bloomberg, also chairs
the 13-member Planning Commission, whose recommendation will be
forwarded to the City Council for final approval.
The mayor is also founder and majority owner of Bloomberg
LP, the parent company of Bloomberg News.
University officials say the expansion depends on the
construction of a vast basement, in some places seven stories
deep. Kasdin said the subterranean space will contain unsightly
infrastructure and services, such as energy plants, trash removal
and deliveries.
``We can create an active street life that will benefit the
university and surrounding communities,'' Kasdin said.
Columbia says it needs to raze most of the buildings in the
development zone, now dominated by warehouses and auto repair
shops. Two storage companies and a gas station have refused to
sell their property to the school. Columbia has asked the state
to consider whether the use of eminent domain would be
appropriate for taking those properties, if necessary.
`Hammer to My Head'
``I'm not going to negotiate with a proverbial gun or hammer
to my head,'' said Nick Sprayregen, 44, owner of Tuck-It-Away, a
self-storage company. He said he is the largest property owner in
the expansion zone, with five buildings there.
The community board, a 50-member body appointed by the
borough president, objects to the height and bulk of Columbia's
proposed buildings, said Jordi Reyes-Montblanc, the board's
chairman. Columbia officials say the tallest buildings will be
260 feet, a bit shorter than the neighborhood's highest
structures.
The board voted 32 to 2 against recommending Columbia's
request to rezone the area from light manufacturing to mixed use.
Reyes-Montblanc said some board members also expressed concern
that excavation for the basement would result in noise, fumes and
the scattering of rats and roaches, and had doubts about its
long-term safety, he said.
The underground space symbolizes what some residents say
will be the destruction of the neighborhood.
``Sure, things happen, the world changes and all the rest,''
said DeMott, the opponent of the expansion. ``But it doesn't have
to be such a dramatic change, where everything is just swept
away.''
To contact the reporter on this story:
Brian Kladko in Boston at
bkladko@bloomberg.net.
Last Updated: November 23, 2007 00:04 EST