JetBlue's New Terminal at JFK Offers Huge Capacity, No Charm
Review by James S. Russell
Oct. 22 (Bloomberg) -- A canopy over the departure curb of
JetBlue's new terminal at New York's John F. Kennedy Airport is
about as welcoming as what you would find at a million-square-
foot warehouse along the New Jersey Turnpike. You expect to see
tractor-trailers backing into the doorways. The new building,
called Terminal 5, opens to passengers today.
JetBlue Airways has invented a loyalty-inspiring bargain
brand with smart customer service and meaningful design touches
-- like bigger seats -- that actually improve today's degraded
flying experience. A few of those touches still can be found
within Terminal 5, but that savvy goes missing in the
architecture of the building itself by New York-based Gensler,
one of the largest architecture firms in the U.S.
As if intended to remind passengers of the genteel flying
experience of yore, Terminal 5 wraps around Eero Saarinen's 1962
TWA Flight Center, stranding it on a plane of gravel. Beneath
TWA's lusciously curving, white concrete roofs, graceful
stairways swept passengers up to preflight martinis and views of
the swirling crowds below.
Long obsolete, it's also a reminder of how changes in
airline technologies and business models have ground to dust
engineers' ideal layouts and architects' grandest aspirations.
The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, which put up
$663 million of the terminal's $743 million cost (JetBlue is
covering the rest), reluctantly agreed to retain the Flight
Center and is completing an asbestos cleanup. You'll be able to
check in there someday, but other possible uses remain in play.
Bill Hooper, Gensler's project director, chose not to
compete with the Flight Center's self-conscious acrobatics in his
design of the expanded terminal. Yet he seems to have ceded any
attempt whatever at expressiveness.
Massive Concrete Walls
The terminal hunkers behind massive retaining walls of
precast concrete. The departure canopy tips up at one end in what
is described as a gesture reminiscent of Saarinen's soaring
shape. It is, instead, one of many architectural afterthoughts:
an awkward transition between a high pedestrian bridge and the
lower terminal building.
Passengers will scurry through Terminal 5's ticketing hall
as quickly as possible, so JetBlue has traded the old
architectural grandeur for a ceiling that slopes up to high
windows diffusing welcome daylight through thick metal trusses.
The central half of the hall is devoted to waiting lines for the
20-lane security area.
Shoeless Feet
JetBlue claims it's the largest checkpoint in the country,
and some nice details reduce the usual stockyard anxiety.
Frequent travelers can select lines that bypass those with
children or otherwise need to move more slowly. Rubber flooring
feels more comfortable under shoeless feet. A long bench beyond
the X-ray scanners allows disheveled passengers to regroup after
a pat-down.
The security area opens to a 55,000-square-foot
``marketplace.'' Tightly packed masses of tables serving 47
stores, restaurants and fast-food outlets herd 40,000 or more
daily passengers through this awkwardly laid-out triangle to
three concourses, two of which are tucked obscurely in far
corners.
The airline brought in David Rockwell, the well-known
designer of restaurants and Broadway shows, to liven up the
clumsy trusses supporting a tipped-up ceiling of corrugated
metal. He suspended a 40-foot-diameter ring hosting video
graphics using spindly metal wires that JetBlue, in a moment of
PR desperation, has compared to Brooklyn Bridge cables.
Clever Stores
The airline redeems itself somewhat with clever stores --
among them a Ron Jon Surf Shop and Muji to Go, the low-priced
Japanese retailer of minimalist clothing and pencil holders.
Gensler has inelegantly though effectively provided high
windows to light the concourses, a spirit-lifter, especially for
delayed passengers.
The architect devoted well-deserved attention to the waiting
areas by providing a higher-than-average seating count. (The
chairs are good-looking and comfortable but nap-resistant.) A
high-stooled bar offers outlets to charge electronics and touch
screens to order food.
JetBlue says it can deliver luggage to the claim area nine
minutes after arrival. Since a one-hour wait for bags at JFK is
not unusual, this counts as some kind of miracle.
Most of what's best about the terminal is service-driven. If
JetBlue can keep that up, few will worry that this monument to
human throughput (20 million passengers annually) resigns itself
to the increasingly grueling experience of flying rather than
enlivening it.
(James S. Russell is Bloomberg's U.S. architecture critic.
The opinions expressed are his own.)
To contact the writer on the story:
James S. Russell in New York at
jamesrussell@earthlink.net.
Last Updated: October 22, 2008 00:01 EDT