Mayne's Federal Building Blends Brute Energy, `Green' Design
Review by James S. Russell
March 2 (Bloomberg) -- Architect Thom Mayne has covered the
18-story south side of the San Francisco Federal Building with
perforated metal panels. It's an armor that evokes Baghdad's
Green Zone more than the California city's soft, fogged hills.
Yet behind the bristling facade of this slim, $144-million slab
lurks flower-power idealism. It's a building that addresses the
growing concerns of global warming.
Mayne, principal of Santa Monica-based Morphosis, bracingly
applies brute urban-industrial energy to his environmental
agenda. The 3-foot-by-8-foot stainless-steel panels, which appear
translucent, are supported in front of the all-glass building
wall by a metal framework. Functionally, they shade the building
from low winter sun, cutting daylight to a comfortable level for
office workers.
That's just one of the ways the building cuts energy use. In
total, it's designed to consume about half the power of a
standard office tower -- an indication of how building design can
help slash emissions of greenhouse gases.
Stylistically, Mayne has gone post-apocalyptic. The blanket
of metal panels angles up over the roof and folds down at a
slightly crazed angle to make a jaunty hat tipped to the city.
Then it plunges down the south side, and undulates like a stock-
market graph to shade a public plaza and the skylight-dotted roof
of a child-care center.
Sharp Edges
That plaza, a welcome bit of sun-splashed public space,
echoes in its toughness the gritty south-of-Market-Street
surroundings: trendy industrial-look lofts jammed against
methadone clinics and check-cashing outlets. The sharp edge of
the shading pergola, with its pistonlike, tubular-metal braces,
looks as if it could impale an invading tank.
For all its architectural showmanship, the design
painstakingly coordinates strategies that harvest sun and breezes
to replace electric lighting and air-conditioning. The use of the
metal panels came out of an emerging discipline called ``building
physics,'' provided here by Ove Arup & Partners, a London-based
international engineering giant.
Through a building-physics analysis, those panels were
designed to retain accumulated solar heat as a thermal blanket
over the building's facade. When that air warms, it floats
upward, coaxing cooler air through the building via windows that
open automatically when instructed by sensors. The result is free
air-conditioning.
By carefully controlling unwanted glare on all sides, most
people can work using the daylight from the floor-to-ceiling
glass instead of electric lights. The north side has its own
sunshade system, vertical milky-glass fins angled to protect
occupants from late-afternoon summer sun.
Windows for All
With its ample daylight, soft breezes and gorgeous city
views, the 575,000-square-foot federal building is a more
pleasant place to work than today's sealed-up, tinted-glass
buildings pumped full of refrigerated air. Even a worker in the
``worst'' seat, only about 25 feet from a window, can grab that
precious daylight.
For some San Franciscans, it hasn't been love at first
sight. ``Very military-industrial complex,'' commented one
passerby on a recent visit. Still, Mayne gives a welcome jolt to
a once-charming skyline that decades of knee-jerk populism have
pummeled to dumpiness.
Buffed, dream-factory California doesn't interest him.
Instead, he channels the heedless kaleidoscopic energy of the Los
Angeles flatlands, where skinny palm trees rise amid elevated
freeways and billboards, and sun glints off endless lines of car
bodies.
Bold Move
The U.S. General Services Administration commissioned this
building because Edward Feiner, who recently left his post as the
agency's chief architect, had pledged that the government would
use the nation's best all-around designers. The agency took a
risk with Mayne's gutsy aesthetic, but he delivered not only the
environmental regime and visual bravura but an unusually high-
quality workspace.
The main elevators stop only at every third floor, which
urges people to stroll handsome stairways and engage with each
other informally in appealing lobbies. A ``skygarden'' within a
three-story-high hole poked high in the building is transected by
slick little bridges. It imbues the prosaic coffee break with
urban theatricality and drop-dead views.
While the federal building imports technologies and concepts
developed in Europe more than a decade ago, it's revolutionary by
U.S. standards -- and far ahead of the low-ambition ``greening''
prevalent in the private sector that touts bamboo flooring as an
eco-credential. The G.S.A., Mayne and Arup have shown that U.S.
buildings can set a much higher standard for workplace quality at
considerably lower cost to the environment.
(James S. Russell is Bloomberg's U.S. architecture critic.
The opinions expressed are his own.)
To contact the writer of this story:
James S. Russell at
jamesrussell@earthlink.net.
Last Updated: March 2, 2007 00:07 EST