Stop the Boondoggles, Six-Lane Highways, MPOs: James S. Russell
Commentary by James S. Russell
Jan. 22 (Bloomberg) -- In a narrow swath along Manhattan’s
Hudson River, stone walls and beautiful arched bridges set off
with trees disguise a buried railroad and entwine a six-lane
highway.
This is Riverside Park, and it’s an infrastructure
masterpiece.
Congress and President Obama shouldn’t commit themselves to
spending billions for “shovel-ready” infrastructure projects
before examining every inch of the park, which was built during
the Depression.
Regrettably, we can’t create its contemporary equivalent
today. Great ossified bureaucracies make it all but impossible to
unite highways, rails, transit and appealing walkways.
I fear that “shovel ready” means boondoggles like the E-
470 beltway, a six-lane, 46-mile arc through empty high-desert
grasslands dotted with new subdivisions east of Denver. Cars
cruise the wide-open toll road at 80 miles per hour.
Touted as essential to the metro area’s growth, this land
developers’ delight hasn’t lightened loads on more centrally
located highways. It’s just rearranged growth patterns,
scattering splotches of development over an unimaginably large
landscape. New residents depend on long beltway commutes by car.
We can’t do better now, the lobbying legions say, we need to
start the bulldozers fast. Translation: No bridge to nowhere will
be left behind.
What’s wrong with America’s way of building transportation
has long been known. We segregate roads, mass transit, railways
and air. Each has its own pot of money. It’s no one’s job to
assemble a transportation system that offers the right travel
mode for the task at hand.
Obscure MPOs
Aside from the odious earmarks, most transportation funding
decisions are made by Metropolitan Planning Organizations. Never
heard of MPOs? They’re supposed to set priorities based on real
needs, though instead they operate in obscurity and allow the
political horse-trading to go on unimpeded by real oversight.
So much is made of the nation’s neglect of infrastructure,
yet the U.S. actually is spending record sums on it.
We don’t make progress because the nation fails to lay out
new communities so they can be efficiently served by means other
than the auto. A start would be to group people-intensive
colleges and commercial centers as hubs along corridors served by
transit and walkable streets.
While the bureaucracies (state and federal) get overhauled,
officials can easily cross off much on the wish lists, like all
those beltways that are really land-development schemes posing as
congestion relief. (Charlotte, North Carolina, killed an outer-
beltway plan some years ago and has done fine, thank you.)
Next, knock out the fourth, fifth and sixth expressway
lanes. When roads get that big, there’s enough demand to support
high-quality transit. The six rail tracks that tunnel into New
York’s Penn Station haul as many people as 45 freeway lanes.
Walkable Downtowns
What should Obama support? Lots of innovation has been
trickling up from municipalities. Beltway suburbs like Bellevue,
Washington, turned their parking-lot acres into high-value
suburban downtowns. Focused on transit, they’re appealing as
places to walk, shop, work and live.
Some metro areas are aligning roads and rails (both freight
and passenger) in corridors to support these emerging urban hubs.
The San Francisco Bay Area could use some cash to finally finish
a rapid-transit extension linking Oakland and the East Bay to San
Jose and Silicon Valley. Without additional aid, underfunded and
overburdened big cities will soon have to stop long-planned,
often-deferred projects like New York’s Second Avenue Subway.
Little Parks
Express bus lanes and bikeways sharing “green streets”
with cars can reduce auto dependency. In the best cases, each
mode is physically separated from the others by planted buffers.
These little Riverside Parks aren’t just pretty. They make
pedestrian crossings safer and sop up storm water -- essential in
an increasingly flood-prone era.
Dollars spent that get Americans out of cars will ease
traffic, save money, reduce pollution, slow global warming and
make us less vulnerable to volatile oil oligarchs.
Road projects do little more than rearrange the traffic
jams. Look for freeway spectaculars among the proposals, like the
23-lane extravaganza touted for Atlanta’s suburbs. Mark them
“D” -- for delusional.
(James S. Russell is Bloomberg’s U.S. architecture critic.
The opinions expressed are his own.)
To contact the writer of this column:
James S. Russell in New York at
jamesrussell@earthlink.net.
Last Updated: January 22, 2009 00:01 EST