Harvard, Sidwell Embrace Green Design in Labs, Roof (Update1)
Review by James S. Russell
June 30 (Bloomberg) -- A small middle school with plants
sprouting on its roof and a research complex at Harvard
University with sunlight-harvesting glass-bubble lounges would
seem to have little in common. Yet both show how quickly the
green revolution in building design is moving -- unleashing
architectural inventiveness not seen in 100 years.
Climate change has lent urgency to building-industry efforts
that have simmered quietly for years. This fall, when students
return to Sidwell Friends, a private K-12 school in Washington,
D.C., they'll check rooftop succulents that are now three seasons
old.
The plants are a teaching tool, though they also harvest
rainwater and add insulation. They are among a wide array of
devices that reduce energy and otherwise soften the school's
effect on the environment.
Sidwell was a pioneering effort all of two years ago.
Building green is moving so quickly that it's now seen as
mainstream.
Harvard wants to be the Sidwell of the university set. It's
building a new $1.2 billion, four-building science complex in
Boston where swooping bridges and bubble-shaped winter gardens
will emerge from sober, four-story limestone rectangles. This is
style that, in green terms, ``does everything,'' said the
architect, Stefan Behnisch of Behnisch Architekten in Stuttgart,
Germany.
Sidwell Expansion
Both Sidwell and the Harvard complex are called platinum
buildings in green parlance. That refers to the top rating in the
U.S. Green Building Council's voluntary Leadership in Energy and
Environmental Design program, or LEED. Sidwell was the first
school to secure a platinum rating, a very demanding standard.
Philadelphia architecture firm Kieran Timberlake added wings
to a small brick building at Sidwell to make a casual, open U. It
faced one part with a handsome fretwork of angled vertical boards
to deflect unwanted summer sun.
Sidwell's kids happily act as docents. On a tour, one child
volunteered that the chimes I heard tinkling in the science-wing
hallway signaled that the solar chimney was working. This device
eliminates air-conditioning by using the buoyant effect of sun-
warmed air to draw ventilating breezes into the classroom.
Horizontal shelves in the hallway bounce daylight inward,
which makes the school a pleasant place -- and light fixtures are
rarely needed.
Bleachers were recycled as window sills. An enhanced-
efficiency heating and cooling system saves energy.
Upfront Costs
According to Rachel Gutter, the schools sector manager at
the Green Buildings Council, public systems in five states and
the District of Columbia have committed to various levels of LEED
certification.
``Sidwell Friends raised the bar,'' she said.
Michael Saxenian, assistant head of Sidwell and its chief
financial officer, said there was a long debate about how green
to go, with the school's leadership worrying that the upfront
costs might be seen as frivolous. With energy prices soaring,
Sidwell's commitment now seems prudent.
Architects are also learning how to build-in low-energy
tactics for less, according to architect Stephen Kieran. He said
optimizing the building's orientation to the sun can be complex
to analyze but cost nothing extra to build.
Student Activism
Pushed by student and academic activism, universities
compete to out-green each other. Harvard's science complex became
a showcase because it will inaugurate the university's new 200-
acre Allston campus when it is completed in 2011. When the campus
is built out 30 years from now, Allston will add 10 million
square feet across the Charles River from the Cambridge campus.
Behnisch's low-rise buildings, which will house stem-cell
research and other science programs, shift horizontally like a
stack of limestone-and-glass dominos. Calibrated to changes in
the sun's angle, the overlaps protect labs and offices from
unwanted heat and glare while letting in ambient light. The
plant-filled gardens draw sunlight, controlled by reflective
louvers, into collaboration-enhancing lounges and cafes.
Behnisch stretches hallways into tapering tubular bridges
that link the buildings like stretched musculature. These are
among the spaces that will be minimally heated and cooled, saving
more energy.
Who says green buildings must look like windmill-decorated
bunkers?
Saving Energy
The laboratories in the 1-million-square-foot science
complex are especially difficult candidates for green design
because so much research is undertaken in controlled environments
that demand enormous amounts of energy-intensive heating and
cooling. Behnisch, working with Payette, a local lab-design
expert, discovered they could drastically reduce the space
dedicated to the most exacting lab functions. That choice alone
will cut energy use some 70 percent.
Green-building advocates don't yet know how to design
buildings that are truly carbon-neutral. (That means using no
fossil fuels or electricity generated off-site.) Yet now they
know they can get close -- which could not be claimed
persuasively when Sidwell Friends opened such a short time ago.
With a little school and a gigantic university pushing this
trend, green building's massive potential may trickle down fast.
(James S. Russell is Bloomberg's U.S. architecture critic.
The opinions expressed are his own.)
To contact the writer of this story:
James S. Russell in New York at
jamesrussell@earthlink.net.
Last Updated: June 30, 2008 08:35 EDT