IMF Should Sell Gold to Cover Losses, Directors Say (Update1)
Nov. 22 (Bloomberg) -- The International Monetary Fund, the
world's third-largest owner of gold, should sell some of its
hoard to cover projected operating losses, say a growing number
of the fund's executive directors.
The Washington-based lender predicts it will lose $87.5
million next year and $280 million in 2009. Some directors say
the fund should sell a portion of its 103 million ounces of
gold, valued at $64.7 billion, and invest the proceeds in
interest-bearing assets.
``We would support the use of fund gold as part of the
solution to IMF financial needs,'' Tuomas Saarenheimo of
Finland, chairman of a group that coordinates the position of
European Union members on the fund's 24-person board, said in an
interview in Washington.
The prospect of gold sales highlights the financial crunch
faced by the fund as countries such as Uruguay repay loans
early, reducing the fund's interest income, and demand for fresh
credit ebbs. Proponents must overcome opposition from the U.S.,
the world's third-largest producer and the biggest owner, which
wants to keep gold prices high.
``Large gold holders and producers like the U.S. have been
worried that IMF sales would drive down the gold price,'' said
Ted Truman, a former U.S. Treasury assistant secretary and a
scholar at the Peterson Institute for International Economics in
Washington.
Brookly McLaughlin, a spokeswoman for the Treasury
Department, said sales aren't ``the appropriate option at this
time for dealing with funding issues at the IMF.'' She declined
to elaborate.
Rather than sell gold, the IMF should rein in an annual
budget that has doubled to $980 million in the past decade, said
Devesh Kapur, an economist at the University of Pennsylvania in
Philadelphia.
Staff Grows
``Costs at the fund have been allowed to get out of
control,'' said Kapur. ``It now has a far bigger staff and
budget than its role justifies.''
A sale of gold is among the options before an eight-person
panel on IMF finances appointed in May by Managing Director
Rodrigo de Rato. The panel, whose members include former Federal
Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan, is to submit its report early
next year. Other solutions include cutting expenses and asking
member states to make contributions.
Jeroen Kremers, the executive director from the
Netherlands, said limited gold sales are preferable to seeking
handouts.
``Becoming dependent on member states for annual budget
contributions would seriously undermine the IMF's independence
and thus its ability to fulfill its role in the world financial
system,'' Kremers said in an interview in Washington.
Interest Earnings
Created at the end of World War II to promote global
financial stability, the fund uses capital contributed by
members to lend to governments in crisis. It pays its staff and
covers costs from interest earned.
Following bailouts in Mexico and Asia in the 1990s, demand
for IMF loans has waned, in part because governments are
reluctant to fulfill requirements such as spending cuts and
sales of government assets.
The IMF has sold gold before. The most recent sales took
place between 1976 and 1980, when the fund unloaded 50 million
ounces following an international agreement to reduce the role
of the metal in the global monetary system.
Support for fresh sales is building. Six directors
representing 39 countries said they are in favor, while a
seventh declined to comment. Finland and other Nordic nations,
which opposed an unsuccessful 2005 plan to sell gold to fund
debt relief for poor nations, now back sales.
Opposition
One director who declined to be identified said gold sales
would win the necessary 85 percent of votes of IMF members if
U.S. opposition could be overcome. The U.S. has a 17 percent
voting share in the fund, giving it a veto.
Expenses have risen as the fund embraced new roles such as
surveillance of international money laundering. Staff has
mushroomed to 2,700 from 1,800 in 1990.
Lending is the lowest in 25 years, with a single borrower,
Turkey, now accounting for more than 80 percent of the fund's
$12.2 billion in loans. The second-largest borrower, Uruguay,
this month said it would repay $1.1 billion ahead of time.
``It's hard to imagine a solution to the IMF's financial
problems without gold sales,'' said Eduardo Loyo, the director
from Brazil.
The IMF finance department in February recommended selling
11 million ounces of gold, or about 11 percent of its stockpile.
With gold at $627.75 an ounce in London early today, more than
double the price in April 2002, that would raise $6.9 billion.
Timing Is Right
John Lipsky, the second-ranking IMF official, said selling
gold is a decision for member countries. ``Gold sales could mean
a lot of different things, and do not imply one course of
action,'' he said in an interview this month during a trip to
Africa, without elaborating.
Finland's Saarenheimo said the IMF may be able to overcome
U.S. objections by selling gold to central banks, which would
avoid driving down the price. The IMF could also sell over a
period of years and convince central banks to control their own
sales.
To contact the reporter on this story:
Christopher Swann in Singapore at
cswann1@vloomberg.net
Last Updated: November 22, 2006 08:38 EST