Bernanke Signals U.S. Should Pay More for Bad Debt (Update2)
By Craig Torres and Kathleen Hays
Sept. 23 (Bloomberg) -- Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S.
Bernanke signaled that the government should buy devalued assets
at above-market values to make its proposed $700 billion rescue
package most effective in combating the financial crisis.
``Accounting rules require banks to value many assets at
something close to a very low fire-sale price rather than the
hold-to-maturity price,'' Bernanke said in testimony to the
Senate Banking Committee today. ``If the Treasury bids for and
then buys assets at a price close to the hold-to-maturity price,
there will be substantial benefits.''
Bernanke's remarks, an unusual departure from his prepared
testimony, come as lawmakers and the Bush administration
negotiate a rescue plan aimed at easing the worst financial
crisis since the Great Depression. The Fed chief said paying
prices higher than the bad assets would fetch in the open market
would help ``unfreeze'' credit markets and aid the economy.
Analysts said Bernanke is essentially advocating that
government use a pricing model that assumes that the debt will
be paid in full over a long period of time. That is different
from the mark-to-market model used by investment banks that
prices assets at what they are worth on a given day.
The risk is that the model does not provide transparent
pricing of the assets taxpayers are taking on, said Ann
Rutledge, partner at R&R Consulting in New York, a firm that
specializes in structured finance. Many of the securities ``are
not going to pay at maturity,'' Rutledge said.
Housing Recession
Nearly one in 10 mortgage loans are in default or
delinquency and house prices have fallen for eight consecutive
quarters, according to the S&P Case-Shiller Index. Paulson and
Bernanke are betting that the asset purchases will free up
lending and break a self-perpetuating cycle of tight credit
leading to lower home prices and more defaults.
``Under the Treasury program, auctions and other mechanisms
could be designed that will give the market good information on
what the hold-to-maturity price is for a large class of
mortgage-related assets,'' Bernanke said. There are
``substantial benefits'' to buying assets at a cost close to the
``hold-to-maturity'' price, he said.
Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson, who with Bernanke urged
lawmakers to act on the plan quickly to address investor
concerns at the deepening crisis, said the ``major focus'' of
debt purchases would be mortgage-linked assets.
Seeking Flexibility
Paulson rejected an idea floated by Democratic Senator
Sherrod Brown of Ohio for banks to retain some portion of the
asset they sell to the Treasury.
``I don't think that that would be a successful way to deal
with something systemically,'' Paulson said at the hearing.
Bernanke opposed efforts by banks to lobby regulators to
remove mark-to-market pricing in their portfolios. A suspension
of such accounting would hurt investor confidence, he said.
Anne Canfield, executive vice president at the Consumer
Mortgage Coalition, an industry group representing mortgage
lenders and loan-servicing companies, sent a letter to Treasury
officials yesterday evening saying the bailout plan ``will only
be successful if it leads to substantially higher prices'' for
mortgage assets, according to a copy obtained by Bloomberg News.
``In past bailouts (Brady bonds, etc.), discounted
Treasuries (zero-coupon bonds) have been used to create the
perception that principal would be fully repaid,'' Canfield said
in a letter to Acting Treasury Undersecretary Anthony Ryan and
David Nason, an assistant Treasury secretary. ``Under mark-to-
market rules it is more difficult to create such perception.''
Letter to Treasury
Treasury spokeswoman Brookly McLaughlin wasn't available
for comment.
Merrill Lynch & Co. in July sold more than half of its
mortgage-linked collateralized debt obligations for about a
fifth of their original price, setting a price for those
securities at that time.
Bernanke's remarks today indicate he favors paying above
the market rate. ``We cannot impose punitive measures on the
institutions that choose to sell assets,'' the Fed chief said
today. ``That would eliminate or strongly reduce participation
and cause the program to fail.''
``They are basically saying, `Let's take a best-case
scenario, let's assume we don't have losses,''' said Julian
Mann, vice president at First Pacific Advisors LLC in Los
Angeles. ``Home prices continue to deteriorate. There are real
losses here.''
Political Shield
The pricing method Bernanke is advocating would also
provide a political shield, analysts said. Congress wouldn't be
able to see if prices fell during a quarter, nor would they be
able to push the Treasury to sell if they saw the value of the
securities rise. That would also protect the market from the
sense of an overhang if in fact the government did acquire a
$700 billion pool of mortgage-related assets.
``The plan allows you to hold the assets off the market,''
says Bradley Hintz, former chief financial officer at Lehman
Brothers Holdings Inc. and now an analyst at Sanford C.
Bernstein & Co. Inc. It treats the Treasury as ``an investor
with a perpetual life span, an infinite amount of money, and no
commercial interests.''
To contact the reporters on this story:
Craig Torres in Washington at
ctorres3@bloomberg.net;
Kathleen Hays in New York at
khays$@bloomberg.net
Last Updated: September 23, 2008 15:09 EDT