Subprime Bondholders May Lose $75 Billion From Slump (Update2)
April 24 (Bloomberg) -- Bond investors who financed the U.S.
housing boom are starting to pay the price for slumping home
values and record delinquencies in subprime loans.
They will lose as much as $75 billion on securities made up
of millions of mortgages to people with poor credit, says Pacific
Investment Management Co., manager of the world's biggest bond
fund. Some of the $450 billion in subprime mortgage-backed debt
sold last year has lost 37 percent, according to Merrill Lynch &
Co.
BlackRock Inc., AllianceBernstein Holding LP and Franklin
Templeton Investments are vulnerable because investors have
replaced banks and thrifts as the primary source of money for
U.S. mortgages. More than $6 trillion of mortgage bonds are
outstanding, dwarfing the amount of U.S. government debt by about
50 percent.
``Bond investors will be the ones who will take the
losses,'' not the banks, said Scott Simon, who oversees $250
billion in asset-backed securities at Newport Beach, California-
based Pimco, a unit of insurer Allianz SE in Munich.
Investors are losing money because of places like Riverside
County, California, where foreclosures almost tripled last
quarter to 6,103 from a year earlier, the biggest increase in the
U.S., according to Foreclosures.com.
Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc., the fourth-largest U.S.
securities firm, used Riverside loans as collateral for $1.5
billion of bonds sold in January 2006. Some of the lowest-rated
portions of the securities trade at 63 cents on the dollar, down
from more than 100 cents in October, according to data compiled
by Merrill Lynch.
BlackRock, Franklin Templeton
Investors in the Lehman bonds include New York-based
BlackRock, which oversees $1 trillion of assets and
AllianceBernstein, which manages $726 billion, according to
filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Franklin
Templeton, a San Mateo, California-based firm that oversees $565
billion, also bought the bonds, data compiled by Bloomberg show.
Bond investors paid for the decade-long real estate
expansion that led to a record 69 percent of Americans owning
their own houses.
Home buyers were able to get loans from banks, thrifts and
mortgage companies who would then typically sell them to
underwriters, freeing up cash for more lending. New York-based
Lehman; Bear Stearns Cos., the biggest underwriter of mortgage
bonds; Morgan Stanley, Wall Street's biggest real estate
investor, and other securities firms packaged loans into bonds
and then sold them.
`More Lenient'
About two-thirds of mortgages get turned into bonds, up from
40 percent in 1990, when the market was $1.08 trillion and the
country suffered its last real estate slump, according to data
from the Federal Reserve and Fannie Mae in Washington.
Mortgage companies increased the amount of loans they
provided when the economy was accelerating by accepting home
buyers who previously couldn't obtain credit. These subprime
mortgages totaled almost 20 percent of all new home loans last
year, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association, a
Washington-based trade group.
When U.S. growth slowed and home prices stopped rising last
year, delinquencies mounted. About 13 percent of subprime
mortgages made in 2006 were delinquent after 12 months, with 6.65
percent considered ``seriously delinquent,'' or more than 90 days
late, Standard & Poor's estimates.
``Underwriter standards have gotten progressively more
lenient,'' said Mark Tecotzky, chief investment officer at
Greenwich, Connecticut-based Ellington Management Group LLC, a $4
billion hedge fund that invests in mortgage bonds.
`Feet to the Fire'
Bondholders are as much to blame as lenders, Federal Deposit
Insurance Corp. Chairwoman Sheila Bair in Washington says.
``We should hold the servicers' and the investors' feet to
the fire on this,'' Bair said in testimony to the House Financial
Services Committee last week. ``We did not have good market
discipline with investors buying all these mortgages.''
Barney Frank, a Democrat from Massachusetts and chairman of
the House Financial Services Committee, and Spencer Bachus of
Alabama, the top Republican on the committee, said earlier this
month that they favor legislation making bond investors liable
for loans that end up in default.
`Attractive Yield'
Investors say more regulation may dry up financing for
homes, causing more delinquencies and damaging the economy. The
National Association of Realtors in Washington said today that
sales of previously owned U.S. homes declined 8.4 percent in
March to an annual rate of 6.12 million, the lowest level in
almost four years.
The bond market has reduced ``the cost of mortgage credit by
linking investors and home-buying families through mortgage
securitization,'' said George Miller, executive director for
American Securitization Forum, an industry trade group for
investors and underwriters in New York. Miller made the comments
last week in testimony to the House Financial Services Committee.
Roger Bayston, director of fixed income at Franklin
Templeton, which bought $800,000 of the Lehman bonds, said his
firm hasn't lost money because it purchased the highest-rated
portions of the securities. He would buy them again, he said.
BlackRock bought the portion of the SAIL 2006-1 bonds rated
AAA and due in six months because ``it offered an attractive
yield relative to similar securities,'' said Aaron Read, fixed-
income portfolio manager at the firm.
The AAA rated part pays 8 basis points more than the London
interbank offered rate in yield while securities based on credit-
card payments and with the same ratings pay about 2 basis points
or 3 basis points less than Libor, Read said. A basis point is
0.01 percentage point.
Contained
``The advantage of the asset-backed structure is that it
passes the credit risk to the lower-rated tranches and insulates
the AAA classes from losses,'' Read said.
AllianceBernstein spokeswoman Stephanie Giaramita didn't
return calls seeking comment. Pimco's Simon said his firm is also
only buying the highest-rated parts of mortgage bonds.
The losses in mortgage bonds haven't spread to other
markets, even though more than 50 lenders have halted operations,
gone bankrupt or sought buyers since the start of 2006, according
to Bloomberg data. Defaults on subprime mortgages tracked by the
Mortgage Bankers Association surged to a four-year high in the
fourth quarter.
``The economic risk, the macro risk -- I don't see it posing
a serious problem,'' U.S. Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson said
after a speech in New York on April 20 in response to questions
on the collapse of the subprime mortgage market.
Brown Grass
Driving around Riverside County's Lake Elsinore, realtor
Abdul Syed counts about 40 lots with brown grass in the 1,200-
home Tuscany Hills subdivision. Owners stop watering their lawns
when they are about to lose their homes, he said.
``All of these people are probably in default and probably
going to face foreclosure really soon,'' said Syed, who in 2002
moved to the town of 38,000 about 60 miles from San Diego.
The owner of 16 Ponte Russo paid $650,000 for the Mission-
style house in November 2005 and got financing for 100 percent of
the price from BNC Mortgage Inc. in Irvine, California, according
to country records. BNC is a subprime lender owned by Lehman.
The owner never made mortgage payments. Now, the house is on
sale for $496,000 following a foreclosure. Attempts to reach the
owner weren't successful.
That house is ``a real nice one because it backs up into a
canyon and you have endless views of hills,'' Syed said. ``That's
a great deal. The banks must be getting kind of desperate.''
Rates Reset
More than 43 percent of the bonds sold by Lehman, called
SAIL 2006-1, are based on property in California. Foreclosures in
the state have quadrupled since September to $2 billion,
according to Foreclosure Radar in Sacramento. SAIL stands for
Structured Asset Investment Loan Trust.
The SAIL bonds were backed by 7,600 mortgages when they were
issued. Almost $50 million of the loans are in foreclosure, some
$25 million are 90 days delinquent and banks have seized property
backing $30 million more, according to data compiled by
Bloomberg.
The bonds are one of only six to ever be downgraded before
their first anniversary, and the biggest of that group, S&P said.
Coupons range from 5.4 percent for the highest-rated portions to
7.82 percent for the lowest-rated pieces.
Rates on almost half of the loans in the Lehman bonds are
scheduled to increase to an average 10.3 percent in December from
about 7 percent now, according to the prospectus for the
securities.
Fees
David Sherr, the managing director in charge of global
securitized products at Lehman, and Steven Skolnik, chief
executive officer of BNC, declined to comment.
Packaging mortgages into bonds has been the fastest-growing
part of the debt market since 1995, providing investors with
securities and a default rate below 1 percent.
Fees from securitizing assets like mortgages and student
loans almost tripled in the past five years to $5.6 billion, Bank
of America Corp. analyst Michael Hecht in New York estimated.
Like Lehman, underwriters including Bear Stearns, Merrill Lynch
and Morgan Stanley bought lenders to gain access to a steady
supply of loans.
Much of the demand for the mortgage bonds came from Europe
and Asia, where investors borrowed in their currencies and used
the proceeds to buy higher-yielding assets in America. The Fed
holds $675 billion of mortgage bonds and debt sold by Fannie Mae
and Freddie Mac -- the two biggest financiers of home loans --on
behalf of foreign central banks and international accounts, an
eightfold increase this decade.
Demand Jumps
Demand for high-yielding mortgage bonds jumped after the Fed
in 2003 cut its target interest rate for overnight loans between
banks to a 45-year low of 1 percent. Subprime mortgages typically
have rates at least 2 percentage points or 3 percentage points
above safer prime loans.
Subprime mortgage bond sales grew to $450 billion last year
from $95 billion in 2001, according to the Securities Industry
Financial Markets Association, a New York-based industry trade
group. The amount of mortgage bonds outstanding increased 82
percent over that period.
``More money was being lent than should have been lent,''
Congressman Frank said in an interview. Mortgage bond investors
``provided liquidity without responsibility,'' he said.
Subprime mortgage-backed securities from 2006 may be the
worst ever, with delinquencies on the underlying debt
``consistently higher'' than in the prior five years, according
to S&P. Losses on loans backing bonds will be between 5.25
percent and 7.75 percent, S&P said.
Losing Homes
As many as 2.4 million Americans may lose their homes, the
Center for Responsible Lending in Durham, North Carolina said in
testimony to Congress last month. The National Association of
Realtors this month said the median price for an existing home
likely will fall 0.7 percent to $220,300 this year, the first
annual drop since the trade group began keeping records in 1968
and probably the first decline since the Great Depression.
Foreclosures in California will rise to 70,000 in 2008 from
3,000 in 2005, said Bruce Norris, a resident of Riverside,
California, who buys houses in foreclosure.
``There is no way this is going to play out without pain,''
Norris said. ``It's already not OK. It just hasn't hit the
courthouse steps.''
To contact the reporter on this story:
Mark Pittman in New York at
mpittman@bloomberg.net.
Last Updated: April 24, 2007 13:52 EDT