Moody's May Lower FGIC, XL Ratings; MBIA Outlook Cut (Update1)
By William Selway and Christine Richards
Dec. 14 (Bloomberg) -- FGIC Corp. and XL Capital Assurance
Inc., two bond insurers, may lose their Aaa credit ratings at
Moody's Investors Service after a slump in the value of the debt
they guarantee.
MBIA Inc., the largest bond insurer, and CIFG Guaranty had
their outlooks lowered to ``negative'' by the New York-based
ratings company today. The Aaa rankings of Ambac Financial Group
Inc., Assured Guaranty Corp., and Financial Security Assurance
Inc. were all affirmed, signaling no plans to change them,
Moody's said. Radian Group Inc. was also affirmed.
``Several of the guarantors still have appropriate levels of
capitalization to support the current rating and those that may
not are taking active steps to strengthen their position,''
Moody's managing director Jack Dorer said in a statement.
The ratings of bond insurers came under scrutiny by Moody's,
Standard & Poor's and Fitch Ratings last month after declines in
the credit quality of the securities they guarantee raised
concerns they may need more capital. A loss of the top rankings
would throw into doubt the ratings of $2.4 trillion in debt
guaranteed by the insurers and would wipe out the companies' main
business of underwriting risk.
``In the cases in which we moved to a negative outlook or
have initiated a review for possible downgrade, capitalization
currently falls below Aaa levels or could fall under that level
in one of our stress cases,'' Dorer said in the statement.
FGIC Has Plan
FGIC said today it has developed a plan to ensure it can
continue to meet Moody's requirements for the top credit rating.
``The company's investors have voiced their support for the
plan and their commitment to maintaining FGIC's triple-A
ratings,'' FGIC said in a statement distributed by Business Wire.
``However, the company can give no assurance that the plan will
be implemented to the satisfaction of all rating agencies in a
timely manner.''
For more than 20 years, the safety of bond insurance has
eased the way for elementary schools, Wall Street banks and
thousands of municipalities to sell debt with unquestioned credit
quality. The bond insurers promise to make interest and principal
payments as they come due on securities if the issuer faltered.
Stocks, Bonds Hurt
U.S. bond prices and the stocks of insurers have been hurt
by concerns about the financial health of the bond insurance
companies amid record defaults on subprime loans that back bonds
and other securities, such as collateralized debt obligations.
MBIA and Ambac lost more than half their stock market value
this year on concerns they may lose their ratings.
Ambac, the second-biggest in the industry, guarantees $546
billion of securities. MBIA stands behind about $652 billion of
municipal and structured finance bonds, while FGIC has insured
$314 billion of debt.
MBIA this week said it received a $1 billion investment from
private equity firm Warburg Pincus LLC to bolster its capital
after Moody's said on Dec. 5 the Armonk, New York-based company
is ``somewhat likely'' to face a shortage of capital. Less than a
month earlier, Moody's had described a potential shortfall as
``unlikely.''
``While Moody's believes that the Warburg Pincus investment
will address the estimated hard capital shortfall at MBIA, the
negative outlook incorporates uncertainty about the performance
of the guarantor's portfolio,'' Dorer said in today's statement.
Paying a Price
The bond insurers are paying a price for expanding beyond
municipal bonds to guaranteeing debt backed by subprime mortgages
and home equity lines of credit as well as CDOs that contain
asset-backed debt. CDOs take pools of securities and then slice
them into pieces with different credit ratings, from no rating
through AAA.
Record defaults on the subprime debt contained in the bonds
sparked losses that have spread throughout the credit markets,
forcing the writedowns by banks. The collapse of the U.S.
subprime mortgage market has led to about $76 billion of losses
at securities firms and banks this year. Subprime loans are made
to people with poor credit.
The bond insurers reported combined losses of $2.9 billion
in the third quarter after writing down the value of some of the
CDOs and other securities they guarantee amid the worst housing
slump in two decades.
To contact the reporter on this story:
Christine Richard in New York at
crichard5@bloomberg.net
Last Updated: December 14, 2007 21:07 EST