Google's Own Executives Rate the Shares `Sell': Mark Gilbert
Commentary by Mark Gilbert
Aug. 18 (Bloomberg) -- Wondering why your investment in
Google Inc. has lost 18 percent of its value since the shares
peaked at about $475 in January? Relentless stock sales by the
Internet search company's executives might be to blame.
Since Feb. 14, 2005, the expiration date of the biggest and
final restriction on insider sales following Google's initial
public offering, managers have dumped a truckload of stock.
As of Aug. 9, they had sold almost 23 million shares. That
means Google's top executives have offloaded about $7.4 billion
of stock, equal to about a third of the company's starting market
value when it sold shares at $85 each in the August 2004 IPO.
There would be nothing evil about the people who built
Google into a $119 billion company parlaying their squarely
gotten gains into McMansions, private jets, home cinemas, Aspen
ski-lodges, or whatever else the financially well-endowed are
conspicuously consuming. Diversification is divine; they deserve
every cent.
Nevertheless, it is remarkable that not a single Google
insider has bought a single share of the company in the 18 months
since the IPO lock-ups expired, according to data compiled by
Bloomberg from the Washington Service, which tracks insider
sales. Philip Remek at Guzman & Co. in Coral Gables, Florida, is
still the only equity analyst with a ``sell'' rating on Google;
you could argue that he's not such a lone wolf, given the
behavior of the company's owners.
Google acknowledged telephone calls and e-mailed questions
to its press office, though failed to provide comment in time for
this article.
Billionaire Pair
Larry Page and Sergey Brin, who founded the company, have
led the exodus. Page's share sales have sucked about $2 billion
out of the market, while Brin has pocketed a bit more than $1.9
billion.
Other Google insiders have also scaled back their
investments in their employer. Omid Kordestani, the company's
senior vice president of sales, has sold $1.1 billion of shares.
Eric Schmidt, chief executive officer, and Google director Ram
Shriram have each sold more than $650 million of stock.
David Drummond, development vice president; George Reyes,
chief financial officer; and Jonathan Rosenberg, head of product
management, have each raised more than $200 million through post-
IPO share sales.
Americans used Google for 45 percent of the 6.4 billion
Internet searches they conducted in June, according to Comscore
Networks Inc., which tracks Web data. Second-placed Yahoo Inc.
had just 29 percent of the market. Google's second-quarter profit
more than doubled to $721 million, or $2.33 a share, as revenue
climbed 77 percent to $2.46 billion. Google, though, says it
won't massage earnings to meet analysts' estimates, making share-
savaging swings from quarter to quarter more likely.
The Mild Bunch
There's little evidence that the two 30-something
billionaires who invented Google are funding extravagant
lifestyles that will drain their wealth. Brin and Page ranked
26th and 27th, respectively, in the 2006 list of the world's
richest people, published by Forbes magazine.
If you combine their names with the word ``gossip'' and
search the Internet using Google (what else?), you get a couple
of lame stories about alleged membership in a Los Angeles club
called Xenii, costing the pair $4,500 a month. Unless there's
some special Google censorship filter running, Page and Brin
don't seem to be painting the town red.
There was a brief blizzard of excitement in July when their
planned refurbishment of a Boeing 767-200 jetliner prompted a
flurry of lawsuits between Blue City Holdings LLC, the company
that owned the plane, and interior designer Leslie Jennings, who
was hired to do the makeover. Lurid insights into a mile-high
nightclub seemed assured.
Tesla Boys
The seemingly exciting news that the Googlers were shelling
out for a 150-seater corporate plane was undermined by its
unmasking as a clunker with more than a decade of service for
Australia's Qantas Airways Ltd. The best the Wall Street Journal
could come up with was an argument between Page and Brin over bed
sizes, and a request for hammocks hung from the ceiling of the
plane.
The raciest splurge the Internet wizards have made with
their money is an investment in San Carlos, California-based
Tesla Motors Inc. Tesla is designing a $100,000 sports car
powered by electric batteries with a claimed performance of zero
to 60 miles per hour in 4 seconds and a 250-mile range between
recharges.
The pace of Google share sales by the founders shows no
signs of slowing. Page sold more than $1.2 billion of stock last
year, while Brin shed about $1.15 billion, for a divestment rate
of about $22 million a week. This year's sales of $762 million
and $790 million equal about $24 million a week. Based on the
number of shares Page and Brin said they owned in April filings,
they each still have about $12 billion in Google stock at the
current price of about $386 a share.
This year, Google shares are down about 7 percent. Gauging
whether Page and Brin now have enough walking-around money to
halt their stock sales might be a better guide to the stock's
future performance than trying to forecast quarterly earnings,
assess new products or predict the company's market share.
(Mark Gilbert is a Bloomberg News columnist. The opinions
expressed are his own.)
To contact the writer of this column:
Mark Gilbert in London at
magilbert@bloomberg.net.
Last Updated: August 17, 2006 19:05 EDT