Oct. 16 (Bloomberg) -- U.S. President George W. Bush arrives
in Asia tomorrow to discuss trade, the war on terrorism and Iraq
reconstruction. Another issue will dominate his time, and the
headlines: currencies.
It's rare indeed for heads of state to discuss exchange
rates, let alone have them eclipse other pressing issues. But
that's the rhetorical and policy tempest into which Bush steps as
he arrives here in Tokyo tomorrow.
Bush's team bears some blame. His finance minister, John
Snow, who's been calling on China to let the yuan float freely,
started the latest currency tussle. U.S. manufacturers, who've
shed 2.5 million jobs on Bush's watch, say China uses a currency
peg to the dollar to gain an unfair trade advantage.
The good news is that the U.S. is shifting its focus in a
more logical direction: Japan. It's here Bush could help end
Asia's escalating currency war, whereby neighbors try to outdo one
another in making their economies more competitive through low
exchange rates.
Attempts by the wealthy U.S. to make a scapegoat of
developing China have further damaged Washington's image in Asia.
At a time when less U.S. investment is flowing this way and the
economic outlook is murky, the White House's fixation with China
is misguided. In 1997, the U.S. begged China not to unpeg its
currency. Now, that same peg is killing the world's biggest
economy?
Beggar Thy Neighbor
Until now, the fact Japan spent at least 13.5 trillion yen
($123 billion) this year manipulating its currency was tolerated
by Washington. That's changing, and for good reason.
``We'll talk about the currency with the Chinese and with my
friend Prime Minister Koizumi'' of Japan, Bush told reporters in
Washington. ``We expect the markets to reflect the true value of
the currency.''
Targeting Tokyo's beggar-thy-neighbor policies could encourage
Asians to let currencies rise versus the dollar, facilitating a
necessary adjustment in global markets. Now that Asia is booming
again, currencies should be allowed to rise. Yet that shift won't be
possible until Tokyo stops manipulating the yen.
There's nothing wrong with central banks smoothing out sharp
moves in currencies. It's another story for the world's second-
biggest economy to spend the equivalent of entire Southeast Asian
economies to boost exports. Tokyo is doing just that to avoid
painful structural reforms.
Fetish
And if the region's biggest economy can manage its currency
as obsessively as it does, why can't others? Aware of the
hypocrisy surrounding the issue, smaller nations are following
suit. On the one hand you have South Korea, which isn't hiding the
fact it's been selling won. On the other, there are nations taking
backdoor steps.
Taiwan, for example, is easing rules on offshore investment.
Thailand will stop paying interest to overseas depositors who hold
baht in checking and savings accounts in the nation to try to curb
demand for its currency.
If only Asia would get over its weak-currency fetish. Now
that it's home to the world's fastest growing economies, it stands
to reason exchange rates should rise. Capital flows brought on by
strong currencies would boost equities and lower bond yields,
giving companies more latitude to raise funds. Low rates also
would help develop an increasingly affluent middle-class.
Bush will preach the strong-currency gospel when he visits
Indonesia, Japan, Singapore, the Philippines and Thailand. (He's
visiting Australia, too, but Canberra has let its dollar surge 22
percent this year.)
APEC Forum
Currency issues will be especially prominent during his stop
in Bangkok next week for the annual summit of the Asia-Pacific
Economic Cooperation forum. Bush will also have to convince Asians
the U.S. won't turn around and weaken the dollar.
The perception the U.S. wants a weaker dollar to boost its
economy marks an intriguing reversal of fortune. If it's true, and
many here think it is, the White House is criticizing China for
having the very thing it desires: a competitive exchange rate.
As Bush makes his way around Asia, he's sure to notice
China's rapidly rising clout. The U.S. is still the region's
biggest trading partner and the dollar is still the currency of
choice for central bankers and investors. But China's growing
influence may startle Bush and his entourage.
The U.S. is having trouble creating new jobs, but Asian
economies generally aren't. For that, many have China at least
partly to thank. Trade between China and the rest of Asia is
booming -- the country's imports rose 40 percent in September from
a year ago to a record level -- and many governments are all too
happy to live with the yuan-dollar peg. Asia is relying less on
the U.S. for growth.
Economic Diplomacy
That's why Bush will have a hard time selling Asia on the
idea that China's currency is a problem. What if Beijing is right
and its financial system is too fragile to withstand a floating
exchange rate right now? Why put the region's most dynamic economy
at risk?
China also is doing a better job of economic diplomacy in
Asia. Not only is it striking trade deals with neighbors, Beijing
is also working overtime to assuage fears it means the region's
economies harm. The Bush administration's best-known economic
policies here are its dislike for China's currency peg and its
belief Vietnamese catfish farmers are damaging U.S. producers.
Yet Washington would have an easier time convincing Beijing
and other Asians to let currencies float freely if Japan would.
Then, the U.S. would have a more receptive Asian audience for
issues ranging from terrorism to Iraq to North Korea. The road
toward a stronger Chinese currency -- and better Asian relations
-- may very well run through Tokyo.