Bloomberg Anywhere Bloomberg Professional About Bloomberg


 
Lehman Shuts Unit; Toll of Lenders Tops 100: Subprime Scorecard

By Rick Green

Aug. 23 (Bloomberg) -- Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc.'s shutdown of its subprime lending unit helped push the tally of mortgage companies that have halted operations or sought buyers since the start of 2006 to at least 100.

Lehman became the first of Wall Street's five biggest securities firms to close its subprime business yesterday when it shut BNC Mortgage LLC. The New York-based firm bought BNC in 2004 to expand lending to borrowers with weak credit.

Until last year, sales of mortgage companies fetched hundreds of millions of dollars, capped by Merrill Lynch & Co.'s $1.3 billion purchase of First Franklin on Dec. 30. Since then, 15 have gone bankrupt and about 50 have suspended loans or closed entirely. The total may be higher because some defunct firms didn't make public announcements or court filings.

``I don't think we are going to see the bottom for at least another six months,'' Edward Resendez, ex-chief executive officer of Resmae Mortgage Corp., said yesterday. Resendez sold Resmae to Citadel Investment Group at a bankruptcy auction. ``The lenders that are struggling out there are not going to survive. As soon as their liquidity runs out, they are going to go under.''

The industry slump pushed shares of mortgage companies down 58 percent from June 14, 2005, through yesterday, according to Bloomberg's index of mortgage real estate investment trusts, compared with a 22 percent gain for the Standard & Poor's 500 stock index. Among last year's 20 largest subprime lenders ranked by Inside Mortgage Finance, a trade publication, more than half have tried to sell themselves or left the business.

Late Loans

Overdue payments on U.S. subprime mortgages rose to the highest level since 2002 during the first quarter of this year, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association. That's made investors who buy mortgages reluctant to bid, driving down prices and cutting into the profit of home lenders.

Subprime loans are made to borrowers with poor credit ratings or heavy debts. The mortgages often charge higher interest rates to compensate for the greater risk of default.

The table below tracks sales, shutdowns, bankruptcies and transactions tied to home lenders. The list includes companies that may have offered subprime, prime or Alternative-A loans. The latter are an alternative for A-rated borrowers who fall just short of standards for regular prime mortgages.

Some of the most recent developments:

-- Accredited Home Lenders Holding Co. will close ``substantially all'' of its retail lending business and halt U.S. loan applications. About 1,600 people will lose their jobs.

-- Capital One Financial Corp. shut its GreenPoint Mortgage unit, eliminating 1,900 jobs.

-- Quality Home Loans, a California-based subprime lender, filed for bankruptcy.

-- Amstar Financial Holdings Inc., a Houston-based lender, said its mortgage division will cease operations.


                                                          PRICE
BUSINESSES SOLD          PARENT            BUYER          ($ MLN)     DATE*
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Centex Home Equity       Centex            Fortress          554(c) Mar. 06
Chapel Funding           ---               Deutsche Bank     N/D    May  06
Aames Investment         ---               Accredited Home   301    May  06
HomEq                    Wachovia          Barclays          469    June 06
MortgageIT               ---               Deutsche Bank     430    July 06
Saxon                    ---               Morgan Stanley    706    Aug. 06
First Franklin           National City     Merrill Lynch   1,300    Sep. 06
Encore Credit**          ECC Capital       Bear Stearns       26    Oct. 06
Irwin Mortgage**         Irwin Financial   Four buyers       261    Oct. 06
Irwin Mortgage**         Irwin Financial   New Century       N/D    Nov. 06
Champion                 KeyCorp           HSBC, Fortress    N/D    Dec. 06
Millennium Funding Grp   ---               Roark Capital     N/D    Dec. 06
EquiFirst                Regions Fin'l     Barclays           76    Jan. 07
ABN Amro Mortgage        ABN Amro          Citigroup         N/D    Jan. 07
New York Mortgage(a)     NY Mort. Trust    IndyMac            14    Feb. 07
New York Mortgage(b)     NY Mort. Trust    Franklin Credit   N/D    Feb. 07
Senderra Funding****     ---               Goldman Sachs     N/D    Mar. 07
ResMae Mortgage          ---               Citadel           180    Mar. 07
PHH Mortgage             PHH Corp.         Blackstone(e)     N/D    Mar. 07
SB Financial             ---               W.J. Bradley      N/D    Mar. 07
MortgageTree Lending     ---               W.J. Bradley      N/D    Apr. 07
Fremont(d)               Fremont General   Ellington         ---    Apr. 07
Lime Financial Services  ---               Credit Suisse     N/D    Apr. 07
New Century servicing    ---               Carrington Cap.   184    Apr. 07
Option One Mortgage      H&R Block         Cerberus Capital  800    Apr. 07
Opteum Fin'l retail      Opteum            Prospect Mortgage 1.5    May  07
Pinnacle Financial       ---               Impac Mortgage    N/D    May  07
Green Tree Servicing     Fortress/Cerberus Centerbridge      N/D    June 07
First NLC Financial      Friedman Billings Sun Capital        60    July 07
Winstar Mortgage**       ---               Am. Sterling Bank N/D    Aug. 07

PARTIAL/POSSIBLE SALE    PARENT                                       DATE*
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
ACC Capital assets***    ACC Capital Hld.  Citigroup         ---    Feb. 07
C-Bass/Sherman Fin'l     MGIC/Radian       ---               750(g) Mar. 07
WMC Mortgage             General Electric  ---               ---    July 07
CIT home lending         CIT Group         ---               ---    July 07
Delta Financial          ---               Gordon / Pabrai   ---    Aug. 07
Luminent Mortgage        ---               Arco Capital      ---    Aug. 07

CUTS/CLOSED/BANKRUPT     PARENT             STATUS                    DATE*
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Acoustic Home Loans      ---                Halted applications     Apr. 06
Ameriquest Mortgage      ACC Capital Hld.   Shut retail branches    May  06
Meritage Mortgage        NetBank            Closed                  Nov. 06
Summit Mortgage          Summit Financial   Closed                  Nov. 06
Sebring Capital          ---                Closed                  Dec. 06
Ownit Mortgage Solutions ---                Bankruptcy              Dec. 06
Harbourton Mortgage      Harbourton Capital Closed                  Dec. 06
Alliance Home Funding    Alliance Bankshrs. Closed                  Dec. 06
Millennium Bankshares    ---                Closed mortgage unit    Dec. 06
Popular Financial        Popular            Closed subprime unit    Jan. 07
Bay Capital              Clear Choice Fin'l Closed                  Jan. 07
EquiBanc Mortgage        Wachovia           Closed                  Jan. 07
Funding America LLC      Ocwen Financial    Closed                  Jan. 07
DeepGreen Financial      Lightyear Capital  Closed                  Jan. 07
Eagle First Mortgage     ---                Closed                  Jan. 07
Mortgage Lenders Network ---                Bankruptcy              Feb. 07
Lenders Direct Capital   ---                Halted wholesale loans  Feb. 07
ResMae Mortgage                             Bankruptcy, revived     Feb. 07
Central Pacific Mortgage ---                Closed                  Mar. 07
FMF Capital LLC          FMF Capital Group  Closed                  Mar. 07
Silver State Mortgage    ---                License revoked         Feb. 07
Ameritrust Mortgage      ---                Shut subprime unit      Mar. 07
Master Financial         ---                Halted originations     Mar. 07
Investaid Corp.          ---                Suspended               Mar. 07
People's Choice          ---                Bankruptcy              Mar. 07
LoanCity                 ---                Closed                  Mar. 07
New Century Financial    ---                Bankruptcy              Apr. 07
SouthStar Funding        ---                Bankruptcy              Apr. 07
Peoples Mortgage         Webster Financial  Closed                  Apr. 07
WarehouseUSA             NovaStar           Closed                  Apr. 07
Copperfield Investments  ---                Bankruptcy              Apr. 07
First Horizon National   ---                Halted subprime loans   Apr. 07
Opteum Fin'l wholesale   Opteum             Closed unit(h)          Apr. 07
H&R Block Mortgage       H&R Block          Closed                  Apr. 07
MILA(i)                  ---                Bankruptcy              Apr. 07
Texas Capital Bank       Texas Cap. Banc.   Closed mortgage unit    Apr. 07
Millennium Funding Grp   Roark Capital      Halted originations     Apr. 07
Columbia Home Loans      OceanFirst         Closed                  May  07
Lancaster Mortgage       ---                Halted wholesale loans  June 07
Oak Street Mortgage      ---                Bankruptcy              June 07
Starpointe Mortgage      ---                Closed                  June 07
Heartwell Mortgage(j)    ---                Halted retail/wholesale June 07
Wells Fargo              ---                Shut correspondent unit June 07
Premier Mortgage Funding ---                Bankruptcy              July 07
Alliance Mtg Investments ---                Bankruptcy              July 07
Wells Fargo              ---                Shut subprime wholesale July 07
Entrust Mortgage         ---                Halted loans            July 07
Alternative Financing    ---                Halted wholesale loans  Aug. 07
Trump Mortgage           ---                Closed                  Aug. 07
American Home Mortgage   ---                Bankruptcy              Aug. 07
MLSG Home Loans          ---                Halted loans            Aug. 07
Impac Mortgage           ---                Suspended Alt-A loans   Aug. 07
Fieldstone               C-Bass             Closed                  Aug. 07
HomeBanc Mortgage        HomeBanc Corp.     Bankruptcy              Aug. 07
Aegis Mortgage           Cerberus(k)        Bankruptcy              Aug. 07
Regions                  Regions Fin'l      Shut warehouse unit     Aug. 07
Express Capital Lending  ---                Halted acceptances      Aug. 07
Bay Finance              Commerce Group     Halted loans            Aug. 07
First Indiana            ---                Shut wholesale unit     Aug. 07
Guardian Loan            ---                Closed                  Aug. 07
Unlimited Loan Resources ---                Halted loans            Aug. 07
Pacific American Mtg.    Golden Empire      Halted wholesale loans  Aug. 07
Thornburg Mortgage       ---                Suspended applications  Aug. 07
National Home Equity     National City      Halted loans, merged    Aug. 07
NovaStar Financial       ---                Halted wholesale loans  Aug. 07
GreenPoint Mortgage      Capital One        Shut wholesale unit     Aug. 07
First Magnus Financial   ---                Bankruptcy              Aug. 07
First Nat'l Arizona      1st Nat'l Hld      Halted wholesale loans  Aug. 07
Quality Home Loans       ---                Bankruptcy              Aug. 07
Amstar Mortgage          Amstar Financial   Closing                 Aug. 07
Accredited Home          ---                Halted loans            Aug. 07
BNC Mortgage             Lehman Brothers    Closed                  Aug. 07

Notes:
 -- Some names have been abbreviated for space. Companies listed
may have engaged in conventional, Alternative A or subprime
mortgage lending. Status of deals and companies, prices and terms
are subject to adjustment after the announcement date.
 N/D Not disclosed or not available.
 *   Announced date, first known disclosure or effective date
     if disclosed after completion. Some announced closings have
     not yet been completed.
 **  Asset sale
 *** Citigroup obtained an option to buy ACC Capital's
     wholesale mortgage origination and servicing businesses.
**** Per Goldman Chief Financial Officer David Viniar 6/14/07
     in conversation with reporters. Web site lists
     company name as Avelo Mortgage LLC d/b/a Senderra Funding.
 (a) Retail assets
 (b) Wholesale assets
 (c) Actual price before taxes, per 10-Q filing. Centex's
     release cited after-tax proceeds of about $540 million.
 (d) Residential subprime unit
 (e) After sale of PHH Corp. to General Electric Co.
 (f) Purchased in July 2007 for $188 million.
 (g) Projected, after taxes, from partial divestiture.
     See Page 41 of the MGIC Form S-4, March 19, 2007.
 (h) Units served mortgage brokers and bought home
     loans from mortgage bankers, thrifts, builders and
     credit unions.
 (i) Formally known as Mortgage Investment Lending Associates.
 (j) Confirmed by company e-mail on July 5, 2007.
 (k) Owners included Cerberus Capital Management LP. Retail
     lending halted in June, wholesale lending in August.

To contact the reporter on this story: Rick Green in New York at rgreen18@bloomberg.net.

Last Updated: August 23, 2007 13:14 EDT

Sponsored links